How a bill becomes a law
Most bills introduced in Congress never become law. The legislative process, with committees, floor votes, the filibuster, and the president's veto, creates many points where bills can stall.
Introduction and referral
Only members of Congress can introduce bills, though ideas come from the president, agencies, interest groups, and constituents. In each Congress, thousands of bills and resolutions are introduced, but typically only a few percent become law. After introduction, a bill is referred to the relevant committee in each chamber.
Committee stage
Committees and subcommittees hold hearings, gather testimony, and 'mark up' bills by revising them. Most bills die in committee without action. If a committee approves a bill, it reports it to the full chamber. In the House, a discharge petition signed by 218 members can force a bill out of committee, though this is rarely successful.
The House floor
In the House, the Rules Committee sets the terms of debate for most major bills, deciding how long members may debate and whether amendments are allowed (open or closed rules). Because the Rules Committee is dominated by the majority party, it is a powerful tool of leadership. A bill passes the House with a simple majority of members voting.
The Senate floor and the filibuster
The Senate has fewer limits on debate. A filibuster, extended debate to block a vote, can be ended only by cloture, which requires 60 votes. In practice, most significant legislation therefore needs 60 votes in the Senate. The Senate eliminated the filibuster for executive nominations and lower-court judges in 2013 and for Supreme Court nominations in 2017; budget reconciliation bills can also pass by simple majority.
Reconciling the chambers
Both chambers must pass identical versions of a bill. Differences are resolved by one chamber accepting the other's version, by exchanging amendments, or by a conference committee of members from both chambers, whose compromise must then be approved by both. Conference committees have become less common in recent years as leaders negotiate informally.
The president's role
The president can sign a bill into law or veto it, returning it to Congress with objections; Congress can override a veto with two-thirds of both chambers, which happens rarely. If the president does not act within ten days (excluding Sundays) while Congress is in session, the bill becomes law without signature; if Congress adjourns during that period, the bill dies, a pocket veto.
The budget process
Congress controls federal spending through the 'power of the purse'. The annual process involves the president's budget proposal, congressional budget resolutions, and twelve regular appropriations bills funding government agencies. If appropriations are not passed by 1 October, the start of the fiscal year, Congress must pass a continuing resolution or the government partially shuts down, as happened for 35 days from December 2018 to January 2019 and for 43 days in October and November 2025, the longest on record.
Worked example
A bill to fund new bridges is introduced in the House, referred to the Transportation Committee, amended in markup, and reported. The Rules Committee sets a structured rule; the House passes it 230 to 200. In the Senate, a filibuster threat means 60 votes are needed for cloture; after negotiations add provisions for rural roads, cloture passes 62 to 38 and the bill passes. The House accepts the Senate version, and the president signs it into law.
Key takeaways
Only members introduce bills, and only a few percent of introduced bills become law. Committees hold hearings and markups; most bills die there; discharge petitions need 218 signatures. The House Rules Committee sets debate terms; bills pass by majority. In the Senate, filibusters require 60 votes for cloture, abolished for nominations in 2013 and 2017, with exceptions such as reconciliation. Both chambers must pass identical bills, sometimes through conference committees. The president signs or vetoes; overrides need two-thirds; pocket vetoes occur when Congress adjourns. Appropriations must pass by 1 October or government shuts down, as in 2018 to 2019 and 2025.
Flashcard
Only members of Congress may introduce bills
Check your understanding
Why do most major bills need 60 votes in the Senate?
