What public policy is
Public policy is what governments choose to do or not do about public problems. Studying policy means understanding how problems reach the agenda and how decisions are made and carried out.
Defining public policy
Public policy consists of government actions, laws, regulations, spending, and decisions, intended to address public problems, as well as deliberate choices not to act. Policies include distributive policies (spreading benefits widely, such as highways), redistributive policies (shifting resources between groups, such as welfare or progressive taxes), and regulatory policies (controlling behaviour, such as pollution limits).
The policy process
A common model divides policymaking into stages: problem identification, agenda setting, policy formulation, adoption, implementation, and evaluation, which may lead to change or termination. Real policymaking is messier, with stages overlapping and repeating, but the model helps organise analysis.
Agenda setting
Many problems compete for attention. John Kingdon's multiple streams model (1984) argues that policy change happens when three streams converge: problems (conditions recognised as problems), policies (solutions developed by experts), and politics (public mood, elections, interest groups), creating a 'policy window' that policy entrepreneurs exploit. Focusing events, such as disasters, can open windows suddenly.
Formulation and adoption
Policies are designed by legislators, agency staff, think tanks, and interest groups, who consider costs, benefits, and political feasibility. Adoption usually requires passing legislation or issuing regulations. Iron triangles, close relationships among congressional committees, agencies, and interest groups in a policy area, and broader issue networks shape these decisions.
Implementation
Implementation is carrying out policies, mostly by bureaucratic agencies, often in partnership with states, localities, and contractors. Policies can fail in implementation because of vague goals, inadequate resources, poor coordination, or resistance. Michael Lipsky's 'street-level bureaucrats', such as teachers, police officers, and caseworkers, exercise discretion that shapes how policies actually work.
Regulation
Agencies write regulations that have the force of law under authority delegated by Congress, following the Administrative Procedure Act (1946), which requires notice of proposed rules and public comment. Regulations are published in the Federal Register. In Loper Bright Enterprises v. Raimondo (2024), the Supreme Court overruled Chevron deference (from 1984), so courts no longer defer to agencies' reasonable interpretations of ambiguous statutes.
Evaluation
Policy evaluation assesses whether policies achieve their goals and at what cost, using methods such as cost-benefit analysis, randomised controlled trials, and comparisons across places or over time. The Government Accountability Office (GAO) and Congressional Budget Office (CBO) evaluate programmes and estimate the costs of legislation for Congress.
Worked example
Airline security after the 11 September 2001 attacks illustrates the policy process. The attacks were a focusing event that put aviation security at the top of the agenda; policymakers formulated proposals for federal screening; Congress adopted the Aviation and Transportation Security Act in November 2001, creating the Transportation Security Administration; the TSA implemented screening at airports; and evaluations since have assessed effectiveness and costs, prompting adjustments.
Key takeaways
Public policy is what governments do or choose not to do; it can be distributive, redistributive, or regulatory. The policy process runs through problem identification, agenda setting, formulation, adoption, implementation, and evaluation. Kingdon's multiple streams (1984) explain policy windows, often opened by focusing events. Iron triangles and issue networks shape formulation. Implementation depends on agencies and street-level bureaucrats. Regulations follow the Administrative Procedure Act (1946); Loper Bright (2024) ended Chevron deference. Evaluation uses cost-benefit analysis and trials, with the GAO and CBO advising Congress. The TSA's creation in 2001 illustrates the process.
Flashcard
What governments choose to do or not do
Check your understanding
According to Kingdon's multiple streams model, when does major policy change become likely?
