← Back to Anthropology

Interpreting the past responsibly

Finds do not speak for themselves. Archaeologists build interpretations through theory and evidence, and they increasingly work with descendant communities to decide how the past is studied and shared.

Culture history

Early twentieth-century archaeology focused on culture history: describing sequences of artefact types and defining 'cultures' by distinctive pottery or tools, then tracing their spread. It built essential chronologies, but often assumed that changes in artefacts meant migrations of peoples, and sometimes linked ancient cultures to modern ethnic or national groups in ways later exploited by nationalist politics.

Processual archaeology

In the 1960s, the 'New Archaeology', led by Lewis Binford, aimed to make archaeology more scientific: testing hypotheses, using quantitative methods, and explaining how societies adapted to environments and changed as systems. It brought rigour and new techniques but was criticised for neglecting individuals, meaning, and the role of ideas.

Post-processual archaeology

From the 1980s, Ian Hodder and others argued for post-processual approaches emphasising symbolism, agency, gender, power, and the subjective nature of interpretation. They highlighted that archaeologists' own backgrounds shape their questions. Gender archaeology, pioneered by scholars such as Margaret Conkey and Janet Spector, revealed women's activities often overlooked in earlier accounts.

Ethnoarchaeology and experiments

To interpret remains, archaeologists study how living people make and discard things (ethnoarchaeology) and run experiments: knapping stone tools, building houses, or butchering carcasses to see what traces result. Such studies show, for example, which marks on bones come from tools and which from animal teeth.

Descendant communities

Many archaeological sites are ancestral places of living peoples. The US Native American Graves Protection and Repatriation Act (NAGPRA, 1990) requires museums and agencies to return certain human remains and sacred objects to tribes. Community-based and Indigenous archaeology involve descendant communities as partners in setting research questions, conducting work, and interpreting results.

Repatriation and museums

Museums hold many objects acquired during colonial rule, sometimes by force, such as the Benin Bronzes looted by British troops in 1897. Debates over returning such objects have intensified; since the late 2010s, several European institutions have returned items to Nigeria and other countries. Restitution raises questions about ownership, care, and access.

Heritage and the public

Archaeology shapes public understanding of the past. UNESCO's World Heritage List, established under a 1972 convention, protects sites of outstanding value, such as Machu Picchu and Great Zimbabwe. Archaeologists must guard against pseudoarchaeology, such as claims that aliens built pyramids, which ignore evidence and often deny the achievements of non-European peoples.

Worked example

Great Zimbabwe, a stone city built from about the eleventh to fifteenth centuries CE, was falsely attributed by colonial-era writers to foreign builders, because they refused to credit Africans with monumental architecture. Archaeological evidence, including radiocarbon dates, pottery, and trade goods, demonstrates it was built by ancestors of the Shona people. The case shows how interpretation can serve political agendas and how careful evidence corrects them.

Key takeaways

Culture history built chronologies but sometimes equated artefacts with peoples and served nationalism. Binford's processual archaeology (1960s) emphasised science, hypotheses, and adaptation. Post-processual archaeology (1980s, Hodder) emphasised meaning, agency, gender, and interpretation; gender archaeology recovered women's roles. Ethnoarchaeology and experiments aid interpretation. NAGPRA (1990) and community archaeology involve descendant peoples. Restitution debates, such as over the Benin Bronzes looted in 1897, have led to returns. UNESCO's World Heritage (1972) protects sites; pseudoarchaeology distorts the past, as colonial myths about Great Zimbabwe did.

Flashcard

Culture history

Describing artefact sequences and cultures

Early 20th century.

Check your understanding

What does the US law NAGPRA (1990) require?

Take the unit quiz

← Previous lesson Next lesson →