← Back to Anthropology

Making a living: modes of subsistence

How people get food shapes how they live: their mobility, group size, property, and inequality. Anthropologists classify these strategies as modes of subsistence.

Foraging

Foragers, or hunter-gatherers, obtain food by hunting, fishing, and gathering wild plants. For most of human history, all people were foragers. Foraging groups are typically small, mobile bands of perhaps 20 to 50 people, with flexible membership, little private property, and relatively egalitarian relations, sustained by food sharing and levelling practices that discourage boasting.

The 'original affluent society'

Marshall Sahlins (1966, 1972) argued that foragers such as the Ju/'hoansi of the Kalahari, studied by Richard Lee, were an 'original affluent society': they met their needs with modest working hours and had abundant leisure because their wants were limited. Later research questioned some figures, noting that processing food adds time and that hardship varies, but the idea challenged assumptions that foraging life was miserable.

Horticulture

Horticulturalists grow crops using simple tools such as digging sticks and hoes, without ploughs, irrigation, or fertilisers, often by shifting cultivation: clearing a plot, sometimes by burning (swidden or slash-and-burn), farming it for a few years, then letting it lie fallow. Horticulture supports larger, more settled villages than foraging.

Pastoralism

Pastoralists depend mainly on herding domesticated animals, such as cattle, camels, sheep, goats, yaks, or reindeer. Nomadic pastoralists move whole communities with their herds; transhumant pastoralists move herds seasonally between pastures while part of the community stays settled. Pastoralists, such as the Maasai of East Africa, often trade animal products with farmers for grain.

Agriculture

Agriculture, or intensive farming, uses ploughs, draft animals, irrigation, terracing, and fertilisers to farm the same land continuously. It supports dense populations and cities but demands much labour and creates vulnerability to drought and soil exhaustion. Agriculture began independently in several regions after about 11,500 years ago, starting in Southwest Asia's Fertile Crescent, and later in China, Mesoamerica, the Andes, New Guinea, and Africa.

Consequences of farming

The shift to farming increased food supply and population, but skeletal evidence from early farmers often shows more disease, tooth decay, and nutritional stress than among foragers. Settled farming allowed storage of surplus, which made possible full-time specialists, social classes, and states, but also inequality and organised warfare. Jared Diamond provocatively called agriculture 'the worst mistake in the history of the human race'.

Industrialism

Industrial production, beginning in Britain in the late eighteenth century, uses machines and fossil fuels to produce goods on a massive scale. Industrial agriculture means a small share of the population can feed everyone: in the United States, under 2% of workers are in farming. Industrialism brought great wealth and new inequalities, urbanisation, and environmental impacts including climate change.

Worked example

Compare a Ju/'hoansi foraging band and a Maasai pastoral community. The Ju/'hoansi move between waterholes, share meat widely to even out luck in hunting, and own few possessions, which suits mobility. The Maasai measure wealth in cattle, which can be accumulated and inherited, producing greater differences in wealth and status. Subsistence strategy helps explain differences in property, sharing, and inequality.

Key takeaways

Foragers, the original human mode of life, live in small mobile bands with sharing and relative equality. Sahlins's 'original affluent society' (from 1966) challenged views of foraging as miserable, though details are debated. Horticulturalists use simple tools and shifting cultivation; pastoralists, nomadic or transhumant, herd animals; agriculturalists farm intensively, beginning about 11,500 years ago in the Fertile Crescent and independently elsewhere. Farming brought surplus, specialists, classes, and states, but also disease, inequality, and war. Industrialism, from the late eighteenth century, transformed production, with under 2% of US workers in farming.

Flashcard

Mode of subsistence

How a society obtains food

Shapes social life.

Check your understanding

What distinguishes horticulture from intensive agriculture?

Take the unit quiz

← Previous lesson Next lesson →