What religion is
Religion appears in every known society. Anthropologists study religion as a human phenomenon, asking what it is, what it does, and why it takes such varied forms.
Defining religion
Definitions vary. Edward Tylor (1871) defined religion minimally as 'belief in spiritual beings'. Emile Durkheim (1912) defined it as a unified system of beliefs and practices relative to sacred things, uniting followers into a moral community. Clifford Geertz (1966) called religion a system of symbols that establishes powerful moods and motivations by formulating conceptions of a general order of existence.
Studying religion anthropologically
Anthropologists approach religion with methodological agnosticism, neither affirming nor denying the truth of religious claims, and study what religions mean to believers and how they shape social life. This allows respectful understanding across traditions, from world religions to local practices.
Animism
Tylor proposed that religion began with animism, belief that souls or spirits inhabit people, animals, plants, and features of the landscape. Although his evolutionary scheme is rejected, animism remains a useful term. Many Indigenous traditions understand the world as a community of persons, only some of them human, a view anthropologists such as Nurit Bird-David and Philippe Descola have explored.
Mana and taboo
Mana, a concept from Polynesia and Melanesia, refers to an impersonal sacred power that can reside in people and objects, bringing success and authority. Taboo (tapu), also from Polynesia, refers to prohibitions surrounding sacred or dangerous things, such as chiefs' bodies or particular places. Both terms entered general use in anthropology and everyday English.
Functions of religion
Durkheim argued that religion binds society together: in worshipping the sacred, people worship society itself and renew their solidarity. Malinowski argued that religion and magic reduce anxiety in uncertain situations; he noted that Trobriand fishers used magic for dangerous open-sea fishing but not in safe lagoons. Religion also explains suffering, legitimises authority, and guides morality.
Religion and power
Karl Marx described religion as 'the opium of the people', soothing suffering and diverting attention from injustice, while also expressing protest against it. Religion has legitimised rulers, as with the divine right of kings, but has also inspired resistance, as in the US civil rights movement's churches and liberation theology in Latin America.
Cognitive and evolutionary approaches
Cognitive scientists of religion, such as Pascal Boyer, argue that religious ideas spread because they fit human cognitive tendencies: detecting agents behind events, attributing minds to unseen beings, and remembering 'minimally counterintuitive' concepts, such as a spirit that is like a person but invisible. Others study how religious rituals and moralising gods may have supported cooperation in large societies.
Worked example
A community holds a yearly harvest festival honouring ancestral spirits. Tylor would see belief in spirits; Durkheim would see the community celebrating and renewing its unity; Malinowski would note how it eases anxiety about the next harvest; Geertz would interpret its symbols and the moods they create; a Marxist might ask whether it legitimises landholders' authority; and a cognitive scientist would ask why ancestral spirits are easy to imagine and remember.
Key takeaways
Religion has been defined as belief in spiritual beings (Tylor, 1871), beliefs and practices about the sacred uniting a moral community (Durkheim, 1912), and a symbol system shaping moods and motivations (Geertz, 1966). Anthropologists practise methodological agnosticism. Animism sees spirits in the world; mana is sacred power and taboo is sacred prohibition. Durkheim stressed solidarity, Malinowski anxiety reduction. Religion can legitimise power or inspire resistance; Marx called it the opium of the people. Cognitive approaches, such as Boyer's, explain why religious ideas spread.
Flashcard
Belief in spiritual beings
Check your understanding
Why did Malinowski note that Trobriand fishers used magic in the open sea but not in the lagoon?
