← Back to Philosophy

Utilitarianism: the greatest good

Utilitarianism holds that the right action is the one that produces the best overall consequences. Its simplicity and impartiality have made it influential, and its implications have made it controversial.

The core idea

Utilitarianism is a form of consequentialism: actions are right or wrong only because of their consequences. Classical utilitarians hold that the right action maximises total well-being, or utility, counting everyone's interests equally. Jeremy Bentham's principle of utility judged actions by their tendency to promote happiness and reduce suffering.

Bentham

Jeremy Bentham (1748 to 1832) was a hedonist: he held that pleasure and pain are the only things good and bad in themselves. He proposed a 'felicific calculus' weighing pleasures by intensity, duration, certainty, nearness, and extent. A reformer, he applied utility to law and prisons, and argued that animals count because 'the question is not, Can they reason? nor, Can they talk? but, Can they suffer?'

Mill

John Stuart Mill (1806 to 1873), in Utilitarianism (1861), distinguished higher pleasures of the intellect, feelings, and imagination from lower bodily ones, arguing that those who have experienced both prefer the higher: 'better to be Socrates dissatisfied than a fool satisfied'. Mill also connected utility with liberty, arguing that freedom of thought and individuality promote long-run well-being.

Act and rule utilitarianism

Act utilitarianism judges each individual act by its consequences. Rule utilitarianism judges acts by whether they follow rules whose general acceptance would maximise well-being, such as 'keep promises' or 'do not punish the innocent'. Rule utilitarianism avoids some troubling verdicts but faces the objection that sticking to a rule when breaking it would be better looks like rule worship.

Strengths

Utilitarianism is impartial, treating everyone's interests equally regardless of race, class, or nationality. It gives a clear method for policy, weighing costs and benefits, and explains why cruelty is wrong. It has driven reforms from abolishing harsh punishments to animal welfare, and underpins much public health and economic policy analysis.

Objections

Critics argue that utilitarianism could justify terrible acts if they maximised utility, such as framing an innocent person to stop a riot, or a surgeon killing one patient to save five with the organs. It may ignore justice, rights, and the separateness of persons, as John Rawls argued. It may also demand too much: if donating more would help others more, almost all personal projects seem forbidden.

Modern developments

Peter Singer applied utilitarian reasoning to global poverty, arguing in 'Famine, Affluence, and Morality' (1972) that if we can prevent something very bad without sacrificing anything morally comparable, we ought to, comparing distant poverty to a drowning child nearby. This argument inspired the effective altruism movement, which uses evidence to find the most effective ways of helping others, itself a subject of debate.

Worked example

A hospital has funds for either one expensive treatment extending one patient's life by two years or vaccinations preventing 50 cases of a serious illness. A utilitarian compares expected well-being: health economists often use quality-adjusted life years (QALYs) to make such comparisons. If the vaccinations produce more total benefit, utilitarianism favours them, though critics worry that this reasoning can neglect the rights or claims of individuals with rare, costly conditions.

Key takeaways

Utilitarianism is a consequentialist theory requiring actions that maximise overall well-being, counting everyone equally. Bentham (1748 to 1832) was a hedonist who proposed a felicific calculus and included animals because they can suffer. Mill's Utilitarianism (1861) distinguished higher and lower pleasures and linked utility to liberty. Act utilitarianism judges individual acts; rule utilitarianism judges acts by beneficial rules. Strengths include impartiality and policy usefulness. Objections cite justice, rights, the separateness of persons, and demandingness. Singer's 1972 argument inspired effective altruism.

Flashcard

Consequentialism

Rightness depends only on consequences

Utilitarianism is one form.

Check your understanding

What is the main difference between act and rule utilitarianism?

Take the unit quiz

← Previous lesson Next lesson →