← Back to Philosophy

Aesthetics: what makes something beautiful or art?

Is beauty in the eye of the beholder? What makes a urinal in a gallery art? Aesthetics examines beauty, art, and our responses to them.

What aesthetics studies

Aesthetics studies beauty, taste, and art: what makes things beautiful, sublime, or ugly; what art is; how we interpret and evaluate it; and why art matters. The term was coined by Alexander Baumgarten in 1735 from the Greek for perception, reflecting the idea that aesthetic experience involves the senses as well as the mind.

Is beauty objective?

Plato linked beauty to the Forms, an objective reality. David Hume's 'Of the Standard of Taste' (1757) argued that beauty depends on human sentiment, yet some judgements are better than others: ideal critics with delicacy of taste, practice, and freedom from prejudice converge over time, which is why works like Homer's endure. Kant held that judgements of beauty claim universal agreement while resting on feeling rather than concepts.

Kant's aesthetics

In the Critique of Judgment (1790), Kant described the experience of beauty as disinterested pleasure, enjoyment not tied to desire or use, arising from the free play of imagination and understanding. He distinguished the beautiful from the sublime, the overwhelming experience of vast or powerful things such as storms or mountains, which reveals both our smallness and the power of reason.

Theories of art

Imitation theories, from Plato and Aristotle, said art represents reality. Expression theories, such as R. G. Collingwood's and Leo Tolstoy's, held that art expresses or transmits emotion. Formalists, such as Clive Bell, held that art's value lies in 'significant form', arrangements of line, colour, and shape. Each theory captures some art but struggles with other kinds.

The challenge of modern art

In 1917 Marcel Duchamp submitted a signed urinal titled Fountain to an exhibition, challenging the idea that art requires skill or beauty. Andy Warhol's Brillo Boxes (1964) looked almost identical to supermarket boxes. Such works prompted philosophers to ask what makes something art if not its appearance.

Institutional and historical theories

Arthur Danto argued that what makes Warhol's boxes art is an 'artworld', a context of theory and history that lets them be interpreted as making a statement. George Dickie's institutional theory holds that art is something presented for appreciation by members of the artworld. Jerrold Levinson's historical definition says art is something intended to be regarded in ways earlier art has been regarded.

Interpretation and value

Does an artwork mean what its creator intended? Intentionalists say yes; anti-intentionalists, following Wimsatt and Beardsley's 'intentional fallacy' (1946), say the work stands on its own. Philosophers also debate whether a work's moral flaws affect its artistic value, and how to respond to great art by people who did terrible things.

Worked example

Is a beautifully designed smartphone art? An imitation theory says no, since it represents nothing. Formalism might say its form is significant. Expression theory asks whether it expresses emotion. Institutional theory says it becomes art if presented for appreciation in the artworld, as when design museums display everyday objects. The example shows how theories of art draw the boundaries in different places.

Key takeaways

Aesthetics, named by Baumgarten in 1735, studies beauty, taste, and art. Plato saw beauty as objective; Hume (1757) grounded it in sentiment refined by ideal critics; Kant's Critique of Judgment (1790) described disinterested pleasure and distinguished the sublime. Imitation, expression, and formalist theories each capture some art. Duchamp's Fountain (1917) and Warhol's Brillo Boxes (1964) challenged appearance-based definitions. Danto's artworld, Dickie's institutional theory, and Levinson's historical definition answer them. Intentionalists and anti-intentionalists debate meaning; moral flaws and artistic value remain contested.

Flashcard

Aesthetics

Study of beauty, taste, and art

Baumgarten, 1735.

Check your understanding

Why did works like Duchamp's Fountain push philosophers towards institutional theories of art?

Take the unit quiz

← Previous lesson Next lesson →