← Back to Philosophy

The meaning of life: absurdity and response

Does life have meaning, and if so, where does it come from? Philosophers offer religious, objective, subjective, and absurdist answers.

Asking the question

The question 'What is the meaning of life?' can ask several things: whether the universe has a purpose, whether human life as such has a point, or what makes an individual life meaningful. Thaddeus Metz and others distinguish meaning from happiness and morality: a life could be happy but trivial, or moral but unfulfilled.

Supernaturalist views

On supernaturalist views, meaning comes from God or a spiritual realm: a life is meaningful by fulfilling God's purpose or relating to the divine, sometimes with an afterlife that gives earthly choices lasting significance. Critics question whether being assigned a purpose by another being, even a divine one, would make a life meaningful for the person living it.

Subjectivist views

Subjectivists say a life is meaningful when the person is engaged in and fulfilled by what they care about, whatever it is. This respects individual differences, but implies that a life spent counting blades of grass could be fully meaningful if the person loved it, which many find implausible.

Objectivist and hybrid views

Objectivists hold that some activities, such as pursuing knowledge, creating beauty, loving relationships, and helping others, confer meaning whatever one feels. Susan Wolf's hybrid view says 'meaning arises when subjective attraction meets objective attractiveness': a meaningful life involves loving and actively engaging with projects that are genuinely worthwhile.

The absurd

Albert Camus, in The Myth of Sisyphus (1942), described the absurd as the clash between our longing for meaning and the universe's silent indifference. He rejected both suicide and 'philosophical suicide', escaping into religious hope. Instead we should live in revolt, freedom, and passion, embracing life without ultimate answers: 'one must imagine Sisyphus happy', pushing his rock forever.

Thomas Nagel on absurdity

Thomas Nagel's essay 'The Absurd' (1971) located absurdity in our ability to step back and view our serious concerns from a cosmic perspective, where they seem arbitrary, while continuing to take them seriously. He recommended irony rather than despair: the absurd is a sign of our capacity for self-transcendence.

Meaning in practice

Psychological research, from Viktor Frankl's Man's Search for Meaning (1946), drawing on his survival of Nazi concentration camps, to modern studies, suggests that people find meaning through purpose, relationships, contribution to others, and coherence in their life story. Frankl argued that even in extreme suffering people can choose their attitude, an idea that influenced later therapies.

Worked example

Consider a nurse who finds her work exhausting but believes it matters, and a person who loves playing a video game all day alone. A subjectivist sees both as meaningful if each is fulfilled. An objectivist judges the nurse's life more meaningful because caring for others is valuable. Wolf's hybrid view says the nurse's life is meaningful if she also cares about her work, and the gamer's life gains meaning to the extent his engagement involves worthwhile goods such as skill or community.

Key takeaways

The meaning-of-life question can concern the universe, human life, or individual lives, and meaning differs from happiness and morality. Supernaturalists ground meaning in God's purpose. Subjectivists ground it in fulfilment from what one cares about. Objectivists cite worthwhile activities; Wolf's hybrid view requires subjective attraction to objectively worthwhile projects. Camus's Myth of Sisyphus (1942) defines the absurd and recommends revolt and passion: imagine Sisyphus happy. Nagel (1971) recommends irony. Frankl (1946) and research link meaning to purpose, relationships, and contribution.

Flashcard

Meaning versus happiness

A life can be happy but not meaningful

Distinct values.

Check your understanding

How did Camus recommend responding to the absurd?

Take the unit quiz

← Previous lesson