← Back to Philosophy

Free will and determinism

If every event is caused by earlier events, can our choices really be free? The free will debate connects metaphysics, science, and our practices of praise, blame, and punishment.

Determinism

Determinism is the thesis that every event is fixed by prior events together with the laws of nature: given the past and the laws, only one future is possible. Pierre-Simon Laplace imagined an intellect that, knowing the positions and forces of all particles, could predict the entire future. If determinism is true, our choices too were settled long before we were born.

Indeterminism and quantum physics

Quantum mechanics, on standard interpretations, includes genuinely random events, so the universe may not be deterministic. But randomness does not obviously help free will: a choice caused by a random quantum event seems no more under my control than one caused by prior events. The free will problem therefore arises whether or not determinism is true.

Hard determinism

Hard determinists accept determinism and conclude that free will, and with it moral responsibility in the deep sense, is an illusion. Some, such as Derk Pereboom, defend hard incompatibilism and argue that society could abandon retributive punishment while keeping protection, rehabilitation, and moral education.

Libertarianism

Libertarians in the free will debate, not to be confused with the political view, hold that we do have free will and that it is incompatible with determinism, so determinism must be false for human choices. Agent-causal libertarians, following Thomas Reid and Roderick Chisholm, say agents themselves, rather than prior events, can cause their decisions. Critics ask how such causation fits with the natural world.

Compatibilism

Compatibilists, including Hobbes, Hume, and many contemporary philosophers, argue that free will is compatible with determinism. On classical versions, you act freely when you do what you want without external constraint. Harry Frankfurt refined this: you are free when you act on desires you endorse, desires that fit your 'second-order' wishes about what to want, rather than on compulsions you reject, as an addict might.

Frankfurt cases

Frankfurt (1969) challenged the principle that moral responsibility requires being able to do otherwise. Imagine Black has secretly arranged to force Jones to vote for a candidate if Jones shows any sign of choosing differently, but Jones votes that way on his own. Jones could not have done otherwise, yet he seems responsible. If so, responsibility may not require alternative possibilities.

Science of decision

In 1983 Benjamin Libet reported that brain activity (the readiness potential) preceded people's awareness of deciding to move by several hundred milliseconds, which some took as evidence that free will is an illusion. Later researchers questioned the interpretation, arguing that the readiness potential may reflect background neural noise rather than a decision, and that simple finger movements tell us little about deliberate choices.

Worked example

A driver who was drunk causes an accident. A hard determinist says the outcome followed inevitably from prior causes, so blame in the deepest sense is inappropriate, though preventing future harm still matters. A libertarian says the driver could have chosen not to drink and so is responsible. A compatibilist says the driver acted on desires he endorsed, without coercion, so he is responsible even if his choice was determined.

Key takeaways

Determinism holds that the past and laws fix the future, as in Laplace's predictor. Quantum randomness may make the universe indeterministic, but chance does not obviously give control. Hard determinists deny free will and deep responsibility, and some, like Pereboom, propose non-retributive practices. Libertarians affirm free will and reject determinism, sometimes appealing to agent causation. Compatibilists, from Hobbes and Hume to Frankfurt, locate freedom in acting on endorsed desires without constraint. Frankfurt cases question whether responsibility requires alternative possibilities. Libet's 1983 experiments are contested evidence.

Flashcard

Determinism

Past and laws fix a unique future

Laplace's intellect.

Check your understanding

What do compatibilists claim?

Take the unit quiz

← Previous lesson Next lesson →