Forgetting and memory errors
Memory is not a video recording. We forget a great deal, and what we remember is reconstructed, which makes memories vulnerable to distortion.
The forgetting curve
Ebbinghaus found that forgetting is rapid at first and then levels off: much of newly learned material is lost within the first day, but what remains fades slowly. Harry Bahrick's research found that people who studied Spanish in school retained a surprising amount for decades after an initial drop, especially if they had learned it well.
Encoding and storage failure
Much apparent forgetting is encoding failure: we never encoded the information. Most people cannot draw the details of a coin they handle daily because they never attended to them. Storage decay, the gradual fading of memory traces, also occurs, especially for unused information.
Retrieval failure and interference
Sometimes information is stored but cannot be retrieved, as in the tip-of-the-tongue experience. Retrieval cues help: context-dependent memory means recall is better in the setting where you learned, and state-dependent memory means recall is better in the same mood or physical state. Interference also causes forgetting: proactive interference is when old learning disrupts new (an old password), and retroactive interference is when new learning disrupts old.
Motivated forgetting
Sigmund Freud proposed repression, pushing anxiety-provoking memories out of awareness. Modern researchers find that traumatic events are usually remembered vividly rather than repressed, and the idea of recovering long-repressed memories, particularly through suggestive therapy techniques, is highly controversial. People can, however, deliberately avoid thinking about painful memories.
Reconstruction and misinformation
Each time we recall a memory, we reconstruct it and may alter it. Elizabeth Loftus and John Palmer (1974) showed people a film of a car accident; those asked how fast the cars were going when they 'smashed' estimated higher speeds, and more often falsely recalled broken glass, than those asked about cars that 'hit'. This misinformation effect shows that misleading information after an event can distort memory.
False memories and source amnesia
Loftus's 'lost in the mall' studies led some participants to recall entirely false childhood events after repeated suggestion. Source amnesia, misattributing where a memory came from, underlies many false memories, such as believing you experienced something you only heard about. Confidence does not guarantee accuracy: vivid, confident memories can still be wrong.
Eyewitness testimony
Eyewitness errors contribute to many wrongful convictions; in the United States, mistaken eyewitness identification played a role in about 69% of over 375 wrongful convictions later overturned by DNA evidence, according to the Innocence Project. Stress, a weapon drawing attention (weapon focus), cross-race identification, and suggestive line-ups increase errors. Reforms include double-blind line-ups and recording witness confidence immediately.
Worked example
Two friends argue about who said what at a party years ago, each confident. Both memories have been reconstructed through retelling; each may have added details from later conversations (misinformation) or confused who said what (source amnesia). Neither's confidence proves accuracy. A photo or message from the time would be better evidence than either memory.
Key takeaways
Ebbinghaus's forgetting curve shows rapid early forgetting that levels off; Bahrick found long-term retention of well-learned material. Forgetting results from encoding failure, storage decay, and retrieval failure; retrieval cues, context, and state help recall. Proactive interference is old disrupting new; retroactive is new disrupting old. Repression is controversial; trauma is usually remembered. Memory is reconstructive: Loftus and Palmer (1974) showed the misinformation effect, and 'lost in the mall' studies showed false memories. Source amnesia fuels errors, and confidence does not guarantee accuracy. Eyewitness misidentification contributed to about 69% of DNA-overturned US wrongful convictions, prompting line-up reforms.
Flashcard
Rapid early forgetting that levels off
Check your understanding
After learning a new phone number, you keep dialling your old one. This is an example of:
