What is a psychological disorder?
Psychologists define, classify, and explain psychological disorders while recognising that labels carry both benefits and risks. This lesson is for learning about psychology, not for diagnosing yourself or anyone else; if you are struggling, talk to a qualified professional.
Defining disorder
A psychological disorder is a syndrome marked by clinically significant disturbance in a person's thinking, emotion regulation, or behaviour. Clinicians consider whether symptoms cause distress or impair daily functioning at work, in relationships, or in self-care, rather than whether behaviour is merely unusual. What counts as disordered can change over time and across cultures.
Historical views
In the past, people attributed disordered behaviour to evil spirits, and treatments included exorcism and confinement. Reformers such as Philippe Pinel in late eighteenth-century France argued for humane treatment, unchaining patients. The medical model, viewing disorders as illnesses that can be diagnosed and treated, grew with discoveries such as the finding that syphilis caused a form of mental decline.
The biopsychosocial approach
Today, most psychologists use a biopsychosocial approach: disorders arise from interacting biological factors (genes, brain structure and chemistry), psychological factors (stress, trauma, learned thought patterns), and social-cultural factors (roles, expectations, poverty, discrimination). The diathesis-stress model proposes that a predisposition (diathesis) combined with stress triggers a disorder.
Classification: DSM and ICD
The American Psychiatric Association's Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, now in its fifth edition (DSM-5, 2013, with a text revision, DSM-5-TR, in 2022), describes disorders and their criteria. The World Health Organization's International Classification of Diseases (ICD-11, in effect from 2022) is used worldwide. Both aim to give clinicians a shared language and guide treatment and research.
The value and risk of labels
Diagnostic labels help clinicians communicate, predict a disorder's course, choose treatments, and support research and insurance. But labels can also bias perceptions and create stigma. David Rosenhan's 1973 study, in which healthy people were admitted to psychiatric hospitals after reporting hearing voices, was taken to show labels' power, though later investigators questioned the study's accuracy.
How common are disorders?
Psychological disorders are common. In the United States, surveys estimate that roughly one in five adults experiences a mental illness in a given year. Globally, the World Health Organization estimated that about one in eight people were living with a mental disorder in 2019, with anxiety and depressive disorders the most common. Many disorders begin by early adulthood.
Risk, resilience, and stigma
Risk factors include genetic predisposition, childhood adversity, chronic stress, poverty, social isolation, and substance use. Protective factors include supportive relationships, coping skills, and access to care. Stigma discourages many from seeking help. Disorders are not character flaws, and most people with mental illness are not violent and are more likely to be victims than perpetrators of violence.
Worked example
Two people feel very anxious before public speaking. For one, the nerves pass and she gives her talk well; for the other, fear of speaking leads him to turn down promotions and avoid classes for years. Clinicians would focus on the second person's distress and impaired functioning, not simply the presence of anxiety, which is a normal emotion. Only a qualified professional could assess whether a disorder is present.
Key takeaways
A psychological disorder involves clinically significant disturbance in thought, emotion regulation, or behaviour, judged by distress and impaired functioning, and definitions vary by time and culture. Pinel promoted humane treatment; the medical model views disorders as treatable illnesses. The biopsychosocial approach combines biological, psychological, and social-cultural factors, and the diathesis-stress model links predisposition with stress. The DSM-5 (2013, revised 2022) and ICD-11 provide classification. Labels aid communication and treatment but risk stigma, as Rosenhan's contested 1973 study suggested. About one in five US adults experiences mental illness yearly, and about one in eight people worldwide lived with a disorder in 2019. Stigma deters help-seeking.
Flashcard
Clinically significant disturbance in thought, emotion, or behaviour
Check your understanding
What do clinicians mainly consider when judging whether behaviour reflects a disorder?
