← Back to Psychology

How we explain behaviour

Social psychology studies how we think about, influence, and relate to one another. A starting point is how we explain why people act as they do.

Attribution theory

Fritz Heider's attribution theory (1958) proposed that people explain behaviour by attributing it either to the person's stable traits (a dispositional attribution) or to the situation (a situational attribution). If a classmate is quiet, we might decide they are shy, or notice that they are new and do not yet know anyone.

The fundamental attribution error

When explaining others' behaviour, people tend to overestimate personal traits and underestimate the situation, the fundamental attribution error, identified by Lee Ross (1977). If another driver cuts you off, you may think 'what a reckless person' rather than considering they might be rushing to a hospital. The error is generally stronger in individualist cultures than in collectivist ones.

Actor-observer and self-serving biases

The actor-observer bias is the tendency to explain our own behaviour by situations but others' by their traits. The self-serving bias is the tendency to take credit for successes ('I studied hard') and blame failures on situations ('the test was unfair'). Most people rate themselves as above average on desirable traits, which protects self-esteem.

Attitudes and behaviour

Attitudes are feelings, often based on beliefs, that predispose us to respond in certain ways. Attitudes guide behaviour best when external pressures are minimal, the attitude is specific to the behaviour, and we are aware of it. But behaviour also shapes attitudes: in the foot-in-the-door phenomenon, people who agree to a small request become more likely to agree to a larger one later.

Roles and the Stanford prison study

Taking on a role can change attitudes. In Philip Zimbardo's 1971 Stanford prison study, students randomly assigned as guards behaved harshly towards 'prisoners' and the study was stopped after six days. It has been heavily criticised: guards may have been coached towards harshness and some participants may have played up to expectations, so it is now seen as weaker evidence than once claimed.

Cognitive dissonance

Leon Festinger's cognitive dissonance theory holds that we feel tension when our actions and attitudes conflict, and often reduce it by changing our attitudes. In Festinger and James Carlsmith's 1959 experiment, people paid only $1 to tell others a boring task was enjoyable later rated it more enjoyable than people paid $20, who had a sufficient external justification.

Persuasion

The elaboration likelihood model of Richard Petty and John Cacioppo describes two routes. The central route uses strong arguments and evidence, persuading people who are motivated and able to think carefully, and produces lasting change. The peripheral route relies on cues such as attractiveness, celebrity, or repetition, and produces quicker but weaker change. Advertisers often use both.

Worked example

A student fails a test and says the questions were unfair; when a classmate fails, the same student says the classmate is lazy. This combines the self-serving bias for herself and the fundamental attribution error for her classmate. A fairer explanation for both would consider situations, such as preparation time, and personal factors, such as effort, before reaching conclusions.

Key takeaways

Heider's attribution theory (1958) distinguishes dispositional and situational explanations. The fundamental attribution error (Ross, 1977) overweights traits for others, more strongly in individualist cultures. The actor-observer bias explains our own behaviour by situations; the self-serving bias takes credit for success and blames failure on circumstances. Attitudes guide behaviour under certain conditions, and behaviour shapes attitudes, as in the foot-in-the-door phenomenon. Zimbardo's Stanford prison study (1971) suggested roles change behaviour but is heavily criticised. Festinger's cognitive dissonance theory explains attitude change after conflicting actions ($1 versus $20, 1959). The elaboration likelihood model distinguishes central and peripheral routes to persuasion.

Flashcard

Attribution theory

Explaining behaviour by traits or situations

Heider, 1958.

Check your understanding

In Festinger and Carlsmith's experiment, why did people paid $1 rate the boring task as more enjoyable?

Take the unit quiz

← Previous lesson Next lesson →