Accounting › Section K · Current liabilities › Topic K.2
Contingent liabilities
A lawsuit not yet decided or a warranty not yet claimed may or may not cost the company money. US GAAP sorts such uncertain obligations by how likely they are and whether they can be measured, and that sorting decides whether they are recorded, disclosed or left out.
Debts that might happen
Some obligations hang on events that have not happened yet. A customer has sued, but the court has not ruled. Products have been sold with a two-year warranty, but no one knows which will break. A company has guaranteed a supplier's bank loan, which matters only if the supplier defaults. Ignoring these would make the balance sheet look healthier than it is; recording every possible claim in full would make it look far worse. The US GAAP rules for loss contingencies, in the codification topic ASC 450, find the middle path.
What a contingency is
A contingency is an existing condition whose outcome is uncertain and will be settled by a future event. The condition must already exist at the balance sheet date: the product was already sold, or the accident already happened. A loss contingency could lead to a liability or a loss; a gain contingency could lead to an asset or a gain, such as a lawsuit the company itself has filed. The two are treated unequally on purpose. Loss contingencies may be recorded before they are settled, but gain contingencies are not recognised until they are realised, though they may be disclosed with care not to mislead.
Three levels of likelihood
ASC 450 uses three labels for how likely a loss is. Probable means the future event is likely to occur. Reasonably possible means the chance is more than remote but less than likely. Remote means the chance is slight. The standard gives no percentages, and the judgement is made by management, usually with advice from lawyers and auditors, using everything known up to the date the statements are issued. The second question is measurement: can the amount of the loss be reasonably estimated, either as a single figure or as a range?
Record, disclose or ignore
Combining the two questions gives four treatments. If a loss is probable and can be reasonably estimated, accrue it: debit a loss or expense and credit a liability, and disclose its nature in the notes where needed. If it is probable but cannot be estimated, do not accrue; disclose it in the notes, saying that an estimate cannot be made. If it is reasonably possible, disclose it, with an estimate or range where one exists, but do not accrue. If it is remote, neither accrue nor disclose. One exception: guarantees of others' debts are usually disclosed even when a loss is remote.
Measuring a probable loss
When a probable loss can be estimated as a range, accrue the best estimate within that range. If no amount in the range is a better estimate than any other, accrue the minimum of the range, and disclose that losses could be higher. This minimum rule surprises many students, who expect the midpoint, but US GAAP prefers the one figure the company is confident it will at least have to pay. As facts change, the estimate is updated each period, and the change goes to the income statement of the period in which the estimate changed.
Worked example: a lawsuit
Dalton Freight is sued after a crash involving one of its trucks. At year end, its lawyers say a loss is probable and likely to fall between $400,000 and $1,000,000, with no figure in between more likely than another. 1. Probable and estimable, so accrue. 2. No best estimate within the range, so accrue the minimum, $400,000. 3. Entry:
4. Disclose the case and that the loss may be up to \(1{,}000{,}000 - 400{,}000 = 600{,}000\) higher. 5. Contrast: if the lawyers named $700,000 as the most likely outcome, Dalton would accrue $700,000.
Warranties
A standard warranty that promises a product will work as described is the most common accrued contingency. Any one item may never need repair, but across thousands of sales, experience shows that some claims are probable and gives a reasonable estimate of their cost. The expected cost is recorded in the same period as the sales, matching the expense with the revenue it relates to. Later repairs do not create new expense: they use up the liability. A separately priced extended warranty is different; it is a service the customer buys, recorded as unearned revenue and earned over the coverage period.
Worked example: dishwasher warranties
Brookfield Appliances sells 2,000 dishwashers in 2026 with a two-year warranty. Past data show 4% need a repair, at an average cost of $150. 1. Expected repairs: \(2{,}000 \times 0.04 = 80\) units. 2. Estimated cost: \(80 \times 150 = 12{,}000\). 3. 31 December 2026: debit Warranty Expense $12,000, credit Warranty Liability $12,000. 4. In 2027, repairs on these units cost $7,400 in cash: debit Warranty Liability $7,400, credit Cash $7,400. No expense is recorded in 2027 for these repairs. 5. The remaining $4,600 covers claims expected in 2028. If actual claims run well above or below estimates, the rate used for future sales is revised.
Disclosure in practice
Notes on contingencies explain what the matter is, its likely timing and, where possible, an estimate or range of the possible loss. Suppose a regulator opens an inquiry into Dalton's safety records, and its lawyers judge a fine reasonably possible but not probable. Dalton records nothing, but its notes describe the inquiry and give the range of possible fines if one can be estimated. Readers can then weigh a risk that the balance sheet itself does not show. Leaving out a disclosure that a reasonable investor would want is a reporting failure even when no entry was required.
IFRS: provisions
IFRS, in IAS 37, uses different words. A recognised obligation of uncertain timing or amount is a provision, and the term contingent liability is kept for items that are disclosed but not recognised. A provision is recognised when an outflow is probable, which IFRS defines as more likely than not, a lower bar than many practitioners apply to the US term "probable". Measurement differs too: a provision is the best estimate, and where a range of outcomes is equally likely the midpoint is used rather than the minimum. Provisions are discounted to present value when the effect is material.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, accruing a reasonably possible loss; it is disclosed only. Second, ignoring a probable loss because it cannot be measured; it still must be disclosed. Third, under US GAAP, accruing the midpoint of a range when no amount is a better estimate; the minimum is accrued. Fourth, recording a gain contingency, such as damages the company hopes to win, before it is realised. Fifth, expensing warranty repairs when they are made instead of estimating the cost in the period of sale. Sixth, assuming IFRS and US GAAP give the same answer for the same lawsuit.
Key takeaways
A contingency is an existing condition whose outcome depends on a future event. Under ASC 450, loss contingencies are probable, reasonably possible or remote. Probable and reasonably estimable losses are accrued; probable but unmeasurable and reasonably possible losses are disclosed; remote ones are neither. Accrue the best estimate in a range, or the minimum if no amount is more likely. Standard warranties are estimated and expensed in the period of sale, and later repairs reduce Warranty Liability. Gain contingencies are not recognised until realised. IFRS provisions use "more likely than not" and the midpoint of an equally likely range.
Flashcards
Flashcard
Existing condition whose outcome depends on a future event
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
A customer has sued a company. Its lawyers say a loss is probable but cannot estimate the amount at all. Under US GAAP, what should the company do?
Question 2 of 5
Under US GAAP, a probable loss is estimated to fall between $200,000 and $500,000, with no amount in the range more likely than another. How much is accrued?
Question 3 of 5
A company sells 5,000 heaters at $300 each with a one-year warranty. Experience shows 3% need repair at an average cost of $80. What warranty expense is recorded in the year of sale?
Question 4 of 5
A competitor threatens to sue, but the company's lawyers judge the chance of any loss to be remote. Under US GAAP, what is required?
Question 5 of 5
Under IFRS, a provision's outcomes are equally likely anywhere between $100,000 and $300,000, and discounting is immaterial. What amount is recognised?
