Accounting › Section Q · Cost-volume-profit analysis › Topic Q.1

Contribution margin

Every sale first pays for the costs it causes, and whatever is left over goes towards rent, salaries and profit. That leftover is the contribution margin, the single most useful number in cost-volume-profit analysis.

Why managers sort costs by behaviour

A manager asking "what happens to profit if we sell 50 more units?" cannot get the answer from an ordinary income statement, because cost of goods sold and operating expenses each mix costs that rise with volume and costs that do not. Cost-volume-profit (CVP) analysis starts by re-sorting every cost by behaviour, as in Variable, fixed, and mixed costs. Variable costs move in total with units sold; fixed costs stay the same in total within the relevant range. Once costs are sorted this way, one figure, the contribution margin, links volume to profit.

Contribution margin per unit

Contribution margin per unit is the selling price minus all variable costs per unit, manufacturing and non-manufacturing alike:

\text{CM per unit} = \text{Price} - \text{VC per unit}

Quillmoor Kayaks sells a touring kayak for $800. Each kayak uses $350 of materials and $90 of direct labour, and the salesperson earns a $40 commission, so variable cost is $480 per kayak. The contribution margin is $320. Each extra kayak sold adds $320 towards fixed costs, and once fixed costs are covered, every further $320 is profit.

The contribution margin ratio

The same idea can be stated per sales dollar. The contribution margin ratio is the contribution margin divided by the selling price (or total contribution margin divided by total sales):

\text{CM ratio} = \frac{\text{CM per unit}}{\text{Price}}

For Quillmoor, \(320 \div 800 = 40\%\). Its complement, the variable cost ratio, is \(480 \div 800 = 60\%\), and the two always add to 100%. The ratio is handy when a business sells many items or only knows its sales in dollars: every extra $1 of sales adds 40 cents of contribution margin.

Total contribution margin and the contribution format

Total contribution margin is total sales minus total variable costs, or units sold times the margin per unit. Managers usually see it on a contribution format income statement, an internal report laid out by behaviour:

\begin{array}{l} \text{Sales} \\ -\ \text{Variable costs} \\ = \text{Contribution margin} \\ -\ \text{Fixed costs} \\ = \text{Operating income} \end{array}

Income taxes are left out, so the bottom line is operating income. This format is not used in published financial statements, but it makes the effect of a change in volume visible at a glance.

Worked example: Quillmoor's April and May

Quillmoor's fixed costs are $96,000 a month. It sold 350 kayaks in April and 400 in May. 1. April: sales \(350 \times 800 = 280{,}000\); variable costs \(350 \times 480 = 168{,}000\); contribution margin 112,000; less fixed costs 96,000 gives operating income of $16,000. 2. May: sales 320,000; variable costs 192,000; contribution margin 128,000; operating income $32,000. 3. Check by margin: 50 more kayaks times $320 is $16,000, exactly the rise in income. 4. Check by ratio: $40,000 more sales times 40% is also $16,000. A 14% rise in units doubled operating income, because fixed costs did not move.

Contribution format versus traditional format

The traditional, or functional, income statement used for external reporting groups costs by function: cost of goods sold, then selling and administrative expenses, as in Multi-step and simple income statements. Its key subtotal is gross profit, sales minus cost of goods sold. Cost of goods sold includes fixed manufacturing overhead, and operating expenses include variable selling costs such as commissions, so neither subtotal tells you how profit responds to volume. The contribution format moves every variable cost above the line and every fixed cost below it. When production equals sales, both formats show the same operating income; only the arrangement differs.

Worked example: recasting a traditional statement

Quillmoor's $96,000 of fixed costs is $60,000 of factory overhead and $36,000 of selling and administrative cost. Rebuild April (350 kayaks, all produced that month) in traditional form. 1. Cost of goods sold: manufacturing variable cost \(350 \times 440 = 154{,}000\) plus fixed overhead 60,000 gives 214,000. 2. Gross profit: \(280{,}000 - 214{,}000 = 66{,}000\). 3. Operating expenses: commissions \(350 \times 40 = 14{,}000\) plus 36,000 fixed gives 50,000. 4. Operating income: \(66{,}000 - 50{,}000 = 16{,}000\), matching the contribution statement. Gross profit of $66,000 and contribution margin of $112,000 are different numbers answering different questions.

Comparing products and services

Every product or service has its own margin. Quillmoor's recreational kayak sells for $500 with variable costs of $350, a margin of $150 and a ratio of 30%, so a touring kayak contributes more both per unit and per sales dollar. Services work the same way. A dog-grooming salon charging $60 a visit, with $21 of variable cost for shampoo, towels, card fees and the groomer's per-visit pay, earns $39 per visit, a 65% ratio. When capacity is limited, the margin per unit of the scarce resource matters more than the margin per unit, as Decisions under constrained resources explains.

Cost structure and the relevant range

The mix of fixed and variable costs is called cost structure, and it is changing. Self-checkout lanes, robots and online ordering replace hourly labour (variable) with equipment and software (largely fixed). That raises the contribution margin per unit but also raises fixed costs that must be paid even in a slow month. All contribution margin figures assume the relevant range: a constant price, constant variable cost per unit and unchanged fixed costs. If Quillmoor needed a second workshop to build 600 kayaks, its fixed costs would step up and the earlier figures would no longer hold.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, leaving variable selling costs, such as commissions or shipping, out of variable cost: contribution margin subtracts all variable costs, not just manufacturing ones. Second, treating gross profit and contribution margin as the same thing. Third, dividing the margin by variable cost instead of price when computing the ratio. Fourth, spreading fixed costs over units and calling the result a variable cost: $96,000 over 400 kayaks is $240 each only at 400 units. Fifth, applying the figures far outside the relevant range, where prices and costs no longer behave as assumed.

Key takeaways

Contribution margin per unit is price minus all variable costs per unit; it is the amount each unit adds towards fixed costs and then profit. The contribution margin ratio is that margin divided by price, and with the variable cost ratio it sums to 100%. Total contribution margin equals units times margin per unit, or sales times the ratio. The contribution format income statement subtracts variable costs, then fixed costs, so the effect of volume is easy to see. Gross profit is a different, function-based subtotal. All results assume the relevant range.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Contribution margin per unit

Selling price − variable cost per unit

Quillmoor: 800 − 480 = $320.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

A lamp sells for $120. Its variable manufacturing cost is $54 per unit and the sales commission is $6 per unit. What is the contribution margin per unit?

Question 2 of 5

A product sells for $250 and has variable costs of $175 per unit. What is its contribution margin ratio?

Question 3 of 5

A firm's contribution margin is $18 per unit. Sales rise from 1,200 to 1,500 units with no change in fixed costs. By how much does operating income rise?

Question 4 of 5

Which subtotal appears on a contribution format income statement but not on a traditional one?

Question 5 of 5

A shop's contribution margin ratio is 35%. If sales rise by $20,000 and fixed costs stay the same, what happens to operating income?

← Previous topicNext topic →