Accounting › Section J · Long-term assets › Topic J.2

Depreciation methods

Once a machine's cost is capitalised, it has to reach the income statement over the years the machine earns revenue. Straight-line, units-of-production and double-declining-balance are three ways to spread that cost, and the choice changes reported profit year by year.

Spreading cost, not tracking value

Depreciation allocates the capitalised cost of a tangible asset to expense over its useful life, in line with the matching principle. It is a cost allocation, not a valuation: a delivery van's book value after two years is simply the cost not yet expensed, and it may be well above or below what the van would fetch at auction. Land is never depreciated, because it is not used up. The topic "Recording deferrals, accruals, and depreciation" showed the basic adjusting entry; this topic compares the methods that set its amount.

The vocabulary

Four estimates and results drive every method. Cost is the capitalised amount. Residual value, also called salvage value, is what the company expects to get for the asset at the end of its use. Useful life is how long, or how much, the company expects to use it, in years or in units such as hours or miles. The depreciable base is cost minus residual value, the total that will be expensed. Each period's entry debits Depreciation Expense and credits Accumulated Depreciation, a contra-asset account. Book value is cost minus accumulated depreciation.

Straight-line

The straight-line method charges the same amount in every full year:

\text{Annual} = \frac{\text{Cost} - \text{Residual}}{\text{Life in years}}

It suits assets that give roughly equal service each year, such as buildings, desks and shelving, and it is the method most US companies report using. Book value falls by the same amount each year, a straight line on a graph, until it reaches the residual value at the end of the useful life.

Units-of-production

When wear depends on use rather than time, the units-of-production method fits better. First find a rate per unit:

\text{Rate} = \frac{\text{Cost} - \text{Residual}}{\text{Total units}}

Then multiply the rate by the units actually used in the period. A truck is measured in miles, a stamping press in parts produced, an aircraft engine in flight hours. A busy year brings more depreciation and a quiet year less, so expense follows the activity that earns revenue. Depreciation stops when book value reaches residual value, even if the asset keeps working.

Worked example: one machine, two methods

Brightwater Cannery buys a sealing machine on 1 January for $64,000, with a residual value of $4,000, a five-year life and expected output of 300,000 batches. 1. Depreciable base: \(64{,}000 - 4{,}000 = 60{,}000\). 2. Straight-line: \(60{,}000 \div 5 = 12{,}000\) a year. 3. Units-of-production rate: \(60{,}000 \div 300{,}000 = 0.20\) dollars per batch. 4. Output by year is 72,000, 81,000, 60,000, 51,000 and 36,000 batches, so depreciation is $14,400, $16,200, $12,000, $10,200 and $7,200. 5. Check: both methods total $60,000 over five years. 6. Year 1 straight-line entry, with Accumulated Depreciation shortened to Accum. Depreciation:

\begin{array}{lrr} \text{Account} & \text{Debit} & \text{Credit} \\ \hline \text{Depreciation Expense} & 12{,}000 & \\ \quad\text{Accum. Depreciation} & & 12{,}000 \end{array}

Double-declining-balance

Double-declining-balance (DDB) is an accelerated method: it charges the most in the first year and less each year after, which suits assets that lose usefulness quickly, such as computers. The rate is twice the straight-line rate, \(2 \div\) useful life, so a five-year asset uses 40% and a four-year asset 50%. Each year, multiply the rate by the book value at the start of that year. Residual value is not subtracted before applying the rate, but it acts as a floor: depreciation may never take book value below residual value, so a year's charge is capped at book value minus residual value.

Worked example: hitting the floor

A courier firm buys sorting equipment for $40,000 with a residual value of $6,000 and a four-year life. 1. DDB rate: \(2 \div 4 = 50\%\). 2. Year 1: \(40{,}000 \times 0.5 = 20{,}000\), leaving book value $20,000. 3. Year 2: \(20{,}000 \times 0.5 = 10{,}000\), leaving $10,000. 4. Year 3: the formula gives $5,000, which would leave $5,000, below the $6,000 floor. So year 3 depreciation is capped at \(10{,}000 - 6{,}000 = 4{,}000\). 5. Year 4: book value already equals residual value, so depreciation is zero. 6. Check: \(20{,}000 + 10{,}000 + 4{,}000 = 34{,}000\), exactly the depreciable base.

Switching to straight-line

With a low or zero residual value, DDB never reaches the target on its own, because it takes a fixed share of a shrinking balance. Many companies therefore switch to straight-line on the remaining depreciable amount in the first year that straight-line gives more. Take $40,000 equipment with no residual value and a five-year life. DDB at 40% gives $16,000, $9,600 and $5,760, leaving book value $8,640 after three years. Year 4 DDB would be $3,456, but straight-line over the two remaining years gives \(8{,}640 \div 2 = 4{,}320\). Switching gives $4,320 in each of years 4 and 5, and book value ends at exactly zero.

Partial years

Assets are rarely bought on the first day of a fiscal year. A common policy is to depreciate by whole months owned. If Brightwater had bought its machine on 1 April, the first year's straight-line charge would be \(12{,}000 \times \frac{9}{12} = 9{,}000\), followed by four full years of $12,000 and $3,000 in a sixth year, still $60,000 in total. Under DDB, the first year takes 9/12 of a full year's charge, and later years apply the rate to the start-of-year book value as usual. Whatever policy a company picks, it must apply it consistently.

Choosing and comparing methods

Over the full life, every method expenses the same depreciable base; only the timing differs. Accelerated methods report lower profit and lower book values early on and higher profit later. Management should choose the method that best matches how the asset's benefits are used up, then disclose it and apply it consistently. Tax depreciation follows separate IRS rules and often differs from the book figures. Under IFRS, two differences stand out: significant components with different lives, such as an aircraft's engines and cabin, must be depreciated separately, and a company may choose to carry a whole class of assets at revalued fair value, which US GAAP does not allow.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, subtracting residual value before applying the DDB rate; the rate goes on full book value, with residual value only as a floor. Second, forgetting the floor and depreciating below residual value. Third, using the original cost instead of the current book value in later DDB years. Fourth, ignoring residual value in straight-line or units-of-production, which overstates every year's expense. Fifth, charging a full year on an asset owned for only part of it. Sixth, treating book value as market value: depreciation tells you nothing reliable about what the asset would sell for.

Key takeaways

Depreciation allocates cost minus residual value over useful life; it is not a valuation, and land is not depreciated. Straight-line: (cost − residual) ÷ years, equal each year. Units-of-production: (cost − residual) ÷ total units, times units used. Double-declining-balance: 2 ÷ life times start-of-year book value, never below residual value; many companies switch to straight-line when that gives more. Each entry debits Depreciation Expense and credits Accumulated Depreciation. Partial years are prorated by months. All methods expense the same total; they differ only in timing.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Depreciation

Allocating a tangible asset's cost to expense over its useful life

A cost allocation, not a market valuation.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

Equipment costs $30,000, has a residual value of $3,000 and a six-year life. What is the annual straight-line depreciation?

Question 2 of 5

A van costs $52,000, has a residual value of $4,000 and is expected to run 200,000 miles over a four-year life. It is driven 35,000 miles this year. What is units-of-production depreciation?

Question 3 of 5

A machine costs $25,000, has a residual value of $2,000 and a five-year life. Using double-declining-balance, what is depreciation in year 2?

Question 4 of 5

Equipment costs $20,000, has a residual value of $4,000 and a four-year life. Under double-declining-balance, depreciation was $10,000 in year 1 and $5,000 in year 2. What is year 3 depreciation?

Question 5 of 5

Which statement about depreciation methods is true?

← Previous topicNext topic →