Accounting › Section I · Inventory › Topic I.1

Inventory valuation methods

When a shop buys identical goods at different prices, someone has to decide which of those costs leave with each sale. The choice of method changes cost of goods sold, gross profit, the inventory on the balance sheet and even the tax bill, without moving a single box.

Same goods, different costs

A kitchenware store buys ten stand mixers in January at $200 each, ten more in March at $220, and twenty in June at $250. The mixers are identical and sit on the same shelf. When a customer buys one, what did it cost the store: $200, $220, $250, or something in between? The answer decides how much of the store's spending becomes cost of goods sold this period and how much stays on the balance sheet as inventory. Accounting does not require the cost assigned to match the physical unit that left the shelf. Instead, the company picks a cost flow assumption and applies it consistently from period to period.

Goods available for sale

Every method starts from the same pool. Beginning inventory plus the period's purchases gives the cost of goods available for sale, and that pool can end up in only two places:

\begin{aligned} \text{Goods available} &= \text{COGS} \\ &\quad + \text{ending inventory} \end{aligned}

A method simply decides how to split the pool. Whatever it does not assign to cost of goods sold stays in ending inventory, so the two always add back to the same total. How and when the split is calculated depends on whether the company keeps a periodic or a perpetual system, as described in "Perpetual versus periodic inventory systems"; this topic uses a single sale so that both systems give the same answers.

What belongs in inventory

Before costing the goods, a company must know which goods it owns. Goods in transit at year-end belong to whoever holds title. Under FOB shipping point, title passes to the buyer when the goods leave the seller, so the buyer counts them; under FOB destination, the seller counts them until they arrive, as covered in "Shipping terms and freight-in". Goods on consignment, placed with a dealer who sells them for a commission, stay in the inventory of the owner, called the consignor. The dealer, called the consignee, leaves them out of its count even though they sit on its floor.

Specific identification and FIFO

Specific identification tracks the actual cost of each unit sold, using serial numbers or tags. It is the natural choice for unique, high-value items such as cars, pianos or fine jewellery, but impractical for thousands of identical units, and it lets a manager influence profit by choosing which unit to hand over. First-in, first-out (FIFO) assumes the oldest units are sold first. Cost of goods sold therefore carries the earliest costs, and ending inventory carries the most recent ones, so the balance sheet figure stays close to current replacement cost. FIFO is permitted under both US GAAP and IFRS.

LIFO and weighted average

Last-in, first-out (LIFO) assumes the newest units are sold first, so cost of goods sold carries the latest costs and ending inventory keeps the oldest, sometimes decades out of date. LIFO is allowed under US GAAP but prohibited under IFRS. US tax law adds the LIFO conformity rule: a company that uses LIFO for its tax return must also use it in its financial statements. The weighted average method gives every unit the same average cost, using the whole pool of goods available:

\text{Average} = \frac{\text{total cost}}{\text{total units}}

It smooths out price swings and, with steady price changes, lands between FIFO and LIFO.

Worked example: one sale, four methods

The kitchenware store's 40 mixers cost $9,200 in total: 10 at $200, 10 at $220 and 20 at $250. In July, after all three purchases, it sells 25 at $400 each, for sales of $10,000. 1. FIFO: COGS \(10(200) + 10(220) + 5(250)\) = $5,450; ending inventory \(15 \times 250 = 3{,}750\). 2. LIFO: COGS \(20(250) + 5(220) = 6{,}100\); ending inventory \(5(220) + 10(200) = 3{,}100\). 3. Weighted average: \(9{,}200 \div 40 = 230\) per unit; COGS \(25 \times 230 = 5{,}750\); ending inventory \(15 \times 230 = 3{,}450\). 4. Specific identification, if the tags show 8, 5 and 12 units from the three lots: COGS $5,700, ending inventory $3,500. 5. Check: each pair adds to $9,200. Gross profit is $4,550 under FIFO, $4,250 under average and $3,900 under LIFO.

Why the choice matters

When purchase prices are rising, FIFO sends the cheaper, older costs to cost of goods sold, giving the highest gross profit and the highest ending inventory. LIFO sends the dearer, newer costs to cost of goods sold, giving the lowest profit and, in the US, a lower tax bill, which is the main reason companies choose it. When prices fall, the rankings reverse. Over the whole life of the business the total cost expensed is the same; the methods differ only in timing. Because the choice changes reported results, the consistency principle requires a company to keep its method from year to year and to justify and disclose any change.

Lower of cost and net realisable value

Inventory may lose value through damage, obsolescence or falling selling prices. Net realisable value (NRV) is the estimated selling price less the costs to complete and sell the goods. Under US GAAP, inventory costed by FIFO or weighted average is reported at the lower of cost and NRV; inventory under LIFO or the retail method still uses an older lower-of-cost-or-market test. The write-down is recognised as an expense at once, usually within cost of goods sold. IFRS applies lower of cost and NRV to all inventory and, unlike US GAAP, allows a write-down to be reversed if the value recovers.

Worked example: a write-down

At year-end an appliance store compares cost with NRV for each product line. 1. Blenders: cost $4,000; selling price $4,600 less $300 of selling costs gives NRV $4,300; report $4,000. 2. Juicers: cost $2,500; a newer model has cut the selling price to $2,400, less $200 of costs, so NRV is $2,200; report $2,200. 3. Toasters: cost $1,800; NRV \(2{,}500 - 150 = 2{,}350\); report $1,800. 4. Only the juicers need a write-down, of $300:

\begin{array}{lrr} \text{Account} & \text{Debit} & \text{Credit} \\ \hline \text{Cost of Goods Sold} & 300 & \\ \quad\text{Inventory} & & 300 \end{array}

Check: inventory falls from $8,300 at cost to $8,000.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, believing the cost flow assumption must match the physical flow of goods; a grocer that sells its oldest milk first may still use LIFO. Second, saying LIFO is allowed under IFRS; it is not. Third, computing the weighted average as a simple average of the unit prices ($223.33 for the mixers) instead of total cost over total units ($230). Fourth, counting consignment goods held for others, or leaving out goods shipped FOB shipping point that are in transit to you. Fifth, writing inventory down to selling price instead of to NRV, which also subtracts the costs to complete and sell.

Key takeaways

Goods available for sale are split between cost of goods sold and ending inventory; the method decides the split. Specific identification tracks actual units; FIFO expenses the oldest costs first; LIFO expenses the newest first and is prohibited under IFRS, with a US conformity rule for tax; weighted average uses total cost over total units. In rising prices FIFO gives the highest profit and inventory, LIFO the lowest. Ownership, not location, decides what is counted. Inventory is written down to the lower of cost and net realisable value, and US GAAP forbids reversing the write-down.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Cost flow assumption

A rule for which costs go to COGS and which stay in inventory

Need not match the physical flow.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

A shop has 10 units at $5 and then buys 20 units at $6. It sells 15 units. What is cost of goods sold under FIFO?

Question 2 of 5

Which statement about LIFO is correct?

Question 3 of 5

A furniture maker places sofas with a dealer, who sells them for a commission. At year-end, 12 sofas are on the dealer's floor. Whose inventory includes them?

Question 4 of 5

Inventory costed by FIFO cost $6,000. Its estimated selling price is $6,200 and the costs to sell it are $500. At what amount is it reported?

Question 5 of 5

Purchase prices rose steadily all year. Which method reports the highest ending inventory?

← Previous topicNext topic →