Accounting › Section R · Job order and process costing › Topic R.1
Job order versus process costing
Every manufacturer must work out what each product costs, both to set prices and to value its inventory. How it does that depends on what it makes: one-of-a-kind jobs call for job order costing, and streams of identical units call for process costing.
Why product costs matter
A cabinet maker quoting for a kitchen and a brewery pricing beer for a supermarket need the same number: what the product costs to make. Product costs feed the selling price, the value of inventory on the balance sheet and the cost of goods sold. Measuring them is the job of cost accounting. Every manufacturer works with the same three ingredients, direct materials, direct labour and manufacturing overhead, introduced in "Merchandising, manufacturing, and service costs". What differs is how costs are collected and divided among the units made. The two traditional systems are job order costing and process costing, and a firm picks the one that fits how it actually produces.
Job order costing
Job order costing traces costs to each individual job: one custom product, or a batch made to one customer's order. Each job gets a job cost sheet, a record that collects the direct materials, direct labour and overhead charged to it. When the job is finished, the sheet shows its total cost, and dividing by the units in the job gives a unit cost. The system suits work where each order differs and costs are easy to trace: custom furniture, house building, ship repair, film production, printing runs, and professional work such as audits or legal cases. Because every job is costed separately, managers can compare each job's cost with its price.
Process costing
Process costing is used when a company makes large numbers of identical units in a continuous flow, such as paint, breakfast cereal, cement, candles or petrol. Tracing the exact flour in one box of cereal would be impossible and pointless, so costs are collected by process or department instead. Each department keeps its own work in process record. At the end of the period its costs are divided by the units it produced to give an average cost per unit, summarised in a production cost report. Because units are often partly finished at month end, output is measured in equivalent units, explained in "Equivalent units in the first process".
Prime and conversion costs
Both systems use the two groupings defined in "Merchandising, manufacturing, and service costs": prime costs (direct materials plus direct labour) and conversion costs (direct labour plus manufacturing overhead). Each system leans on a different pair. Job order costing leans on prime costs, which requisitions and time records charge to specific jobs, while overhead reaches each job through a rate. Process costing usually works with materials and conversion costs, because in an automated plant direct labour is small and, like overhead, is added gradually as units move through a department. Selling and administrative costs are period costs, expensed when incurred under either system.
The two systems side by side
Five differences sum up the choice. Products: custom and distinct, against uniform and mass-produced. Where costs collect: on each job, against in each department. Work in process records: a job cost sheet for every unfinished job, against one work in process account per production department. Key report: the job cost sheet, against the production cost report. Unit cost: a job's total cost divided by its units, against a department's period costs divided by its equivalent units. The flow of costs from materials through work in process to finished goods and then to the expense when goods are sold is the same in both; only the records inside work in process change.
Worked example: choosing a system
Which system suits each business? 1. Brackenridge Cabinetry builds kitchens to each customer's measurements. Every kitchen uses different materials and hours, and the costs are easy to trace to the order: job order costing. 2. Ashdown Candle Works pours thousands of identical jar candles a day through a pouring department and a packaging department. No candle differs from the next: process costing. 3. A firm overhauling aircraft engines treats each engine as a separate order with its own parts and hours: job order costing. 4. A water bottler fills the same 500 ml bottle all day: process costing. 5. The test: does the customer, specification or cost differ from one order to the next? If yes, cost each job; if no, average over the process.
Worked example: a unit cost each way
1. Brackenridge's job cost sheet for Job 288, four oak bookcases, shows direct materials of $1,940, 36 direct labour hours at $25 ($900) and overhead of $30 per labour hour ($1,080). 2. The job's total cost is \(1{,}940 + 900 + 1{,}080 = 3{,}920\), so each bookcase cost \(3{,}920 \div 4 = 980\), or $980. 3. In a month when every candle started was also finished, Ashdown's pouring department incurred $49,500 of costs and made 11,000 candles. 4. The average is \(49{,}500 \div 11{,}000 = 4.50\), or $4.50 per candle. 5. The bookcase cost belongs to that job alone. The candle cost is an average: some candles used slightly more wax, but the difference is not worth tracking.
Hybrid systems and the cost of detail
Many firms combine the systems, an approach often called hybrid or operation costing. A car maker mass-produces engines and body panels, which suits process costing, but fits each car with the options one buyer ordered, which suits job order costing. A furniture factory may make standard frames in volume, then upholster each sofa in the customer's fabric. The choice also weighs cost against benefit: recording every requisition and labour hour by job gives more detail but costs more to run. Where the detail would not change a decision, process costing is cheaper. Automation changes the allocation base more than the system: it shrinks direct labour, so overhead is often applied on machine hours instead, but the product's uniformity still decides the system.
Service businesses use both too
An accounting firm, a law practice, a vehicle repair shop or a hospital treating individual patients uses job order costing: each client or case is a job, and labour is usually the largest cost, with little direct material. Services that are uniform and repeated thousands of times suit process-style averaging. A payroll-processing centre that spends $84,000 in a month and issues 120,000 payslips has an average cost of \(84{,}000 \div 120{,}000 = 0.70\), or 70 cents per payslip, which helps it price its service. Job costing in service firms is covered in "Job order journal entries and service settings".
Common mistakes to avoid
First, choosing a system by industry label rather than by how the product is made: a bakery making identical loaves needs process costing, but one baking custom wedding cakes needs job order costing. Second, adding prime and conversion costs together, which counts direct labour twice. Third, assuming process costing has a single work in process account; it has one per production department. Fourth, thinking job order costing is only for factories. Fifth, believing a firm must use one system for everything. Sixth, treating selling and administrative costs as product costs.
Key takeaways
Job order costing traces direct materials, direct labour and overhead to each distinct job on a job cost sheet; it suits custom products and client services. Process costing collects costs by department and averages them over identical units, reported on a production cost report. Prime costs are direct materials plus direct labour; conversion costs are direct labour plus overhead. Both systems move costs from materials to work in process, finished goods and cost of goods sold. Hybrid systems combine the two, weighing the value of detail against its cost.
Flashcards
Flashcard
Measuring and reporting the cost of products and services
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
Which business is best suited to job order costing?
Question 2 of 5
An automated plant's month shows direct materials of $18,000, direct labour of $6,000 and manufacturing overhead of $21,000. What are the conversion costs?
Question 3 of 5
How does process costing hold its work in process records?
Question 4 of 5
A job of six custom desks has direct materials of $2,700, direct labour of $1,500 and overhead of $1,800. What is the cost per desk?
Question 5 of 5
Why might a car maker use a hybrid costing system?
