Accounting › Section J · Long-term assets › Topic J.4
Impairment, natural resources, and other special issues
Estimates turn out wrong, assets are sold early, demand collapses and quarries are emptied. This topic covers what happens to long-term assets after the purchase: revised estimates, disposals, impairment, depletion, and investments in other companies.
When the plan changes
Every depreciation schedule rests on estimates of useful life and residual value made on the day an asset is bought. Over time those estimates meet reality. A machine lasts longer than expected, a truck is sold after three years, a factory's product falls out of fashion, an oil field yields less than the geologists predicted. Each situation has its own rule. Most share one principle: the accounting looks forward, adjusting the current and future years, and leaves the statements of past years alone unless they contained an actual error.
Revising life or residual value
A change in useful life or residual value is a change in accounting estimate, and it is applied prospectively. Earlier depreciation is not restated. Instead, the remaining book value, less the new residual value, is spread over the remaining useful life:
where BV is the current book value. Upgrades that extend an asset's life, such as a rebuilt engine, are handled the same way: add the capital expenditure to book value, then spread the new total over the new remaining life.
Worked example: a longer life
Pellham Bakery bought an oven for $90,000 with a residual value of $10,000 and an eight-year life, and has charged straight-line depreciation of $10,000 a year. After three years, it concludes the oven will last ten years in total and be worth only $4,000 at the end. 1. Accumulated depreciation so far: \(3 \times 10{,}000 = 30{,}000\). 2. Book value: \(90{,}000 - 30{,}000 = 60{,}000\). 3. Remaining life: \(10 - 3 = 7\) years. 4. New charge: \((60{,}000 - 4{,}000) \div 7 = 8{,}000\) a year. 5. Check: after seven more years, accumulated depreciation is \(30{,}000 + 56{,}000 = 86{,}000\), leaving exactly the $4,000 residual.
Selling or scrapping an asset
When an asset leaves the business, three steps follow. First, record depreciation up to the disposal date, so the book value is current. Second, remove both the asset's cost and its accumulated depreciation from the accounts. Third, compare the cash received with the book value. Proceeds above book value give a gain on disposal; proceeds below book value give a loss. Scrapping an asset for nothing produces a loss equal to its remaining book value. Gains and losses on disposal are reported on the income statement, usually outside operating revenue.
Worked example: selling a truck
Pellham's delivery truck cost $48,000 and is depreciated at $6,000 a year. On 1 January, accumulated depreciation was $30,000. The truck is sold on 30 June for $14,500. 1. Half a year's depreciation: \(6{,}000 \times \frac{6}{12} = 3{,}000\), so accumulated depreciation (Accum. Depreciation in the entry) becomes $33,000. 2. Book value: \(48{,}000 - 33{,}000 = 15{,}000\). 3. Result: \(14{,}500 - 15{,}000 = -500\), a loss of $500. 4. Sale entry:
5. Check: debits and credits both total $48,000.
Impairment of long-lived assets
An asset is impaired when its carrying amount can no longer be recovered. Warning signs include physical damage, obsolescence, a sharp fall in demand or market price, and operating losses. Under US GAAP, an asset used in operations is tested in two steps. Step 1, recoverability: if the carrying amount exceeds the total undiscounted future cash flows the asset is expected to produce, it is impaired. Step 2, measurement: the impairment loss is the carrying amount minus fair value. The written-down amount becomes the new cost basis, and the loss cannot be reversed later. Under IFRS, there is one step against the recoverable amount, and reversals are allowed, except for goodwill.
Worked example: a bottling line
Cresswell Drinks' bottling line cost $3,600,000 and has accumulated depreciation of $1,200,000. After a major customer leaves, the line is expected to generate $1,900,000 of undiscounted cash flows, and its fair value is $1,500,000. 1. Carrying amount: \(3{,}600{,}000 - 1{,}200{,}000 = 2{,}400{,}000\). 2. Recoverability: $1,900,000 is less than $2,400,000, so the line is impaired. 3. Loss: \(2{,}400{,}000 - 1{,}500{,}000 = 900{,}000\). 4. Entry: debit Impairment Loss $900,000; credit Accumulated Depreciation $900,000, though some companies credit the asset account directly. 5. Contrast: had the undiscounted cash flows been $2,600,000, step 1 would pass and no loss would be recorded, even with fair value at $1,500,000.
Natural resources and depletion
Timber stands, mineral deposits and oil and gas reserves are natural resources: assets consumed physically as they are extracted. They are recorded at the cost of acquiring and developing them, and that cost, less any residual value such as the land's worth afterwards, is allocated by depletion, which works like units-of-production. The depletion rate is the depletable cost divided by the estimated total units. Depletion is first added to the cost of the extracted inventory and becomes Cost of Goods Sold only when that inventory is sold. Equipment that cannot be moved from the site is often depreciated over the resource's life.
Worked example: a gravel quarry
Redstone Aggregates buys a quarry for $5,300,000 and spends $700,000 preparing it. Once emptied, the land will be worth $400,000. The quarry should yield 2,800,000 tons. This year it extracts 350,000 tons and sells 300,000. 1. Depletable cost: 5,300,000 + 700,000 − 400,000 = 5,600,000. 2. Rate: \(5{,}600{,}000 \div 2{,}800{,}000 = 2.00\) dollars per ton. 3. Depletion: \(350{,}000 \times 2.00 = 700{,}000\), debited to Inventory and credited to Accumulated Depletion. 4. Of that, \(300{,}000 \times 2.00 = 600{,}000\) reaches Cost of Goods Sold this year, and $100,000 stays in ending inventory.
Investments in other companies
A company may also hold shares in another company, and the accounting depends on how much influence the shares bring. With a small holding, typically under 20% of the voting shares, the investment is measured at fair value, and for most equity securities changes in fair value go through net income. With significant influence, usually 20% to 50%, the equity method applies: the investor records its share of the investee's profit as income and reduces the investment by dividends received. With control, normally over 50%, the investor consolidates, combining the subsidiary's statements with its own. The percentages are guides; actual influence decides.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, restating past depreciation after a change in estimate; changes in estimate are applied prospectively. Second, computing a disposal gain or loss before updating depreciation to the sale date. Third, removing only the net book value instead of both cost and accumulated depreciation. Fourth, using fair value in the US GAAP recoverability step; step 1 uses undiscounted cash flows, and fair value is used only to measure the loss. Fifth, reversing a US GAAP impairment loss when values recover. Sixth, sending all depletion straight to expense when some of the extracted resource is still unsold.
Key takeaways
Revised lives and residual values are applied prospectively: (book value − new residual) ÷ remaining life. On disposal, update depreciation, remove cost and accumulated depreciation, and record a gain or loss equal to proceeds minus book value. Under US GAAP, a long-lived asset is impaired when its carrying amount exceeds undiscounted future cash flows, and the loss is carrying amount minus fair value, never reversed; IFRS uses one step and allows reversals. Natural resources are depleted per unit extracted, with depletion flowing through inventory. Investments are measured at fair value, by the equity method or by consolidation, depending on influence.
Flashcards
Flashcard
Applied prospectively; past years are not restated
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
Equipment cost $50,000 with a $5,000 residual value and a nine-year life, depreciated straight-line. After four years, the company decides it has three years left and a residual value of $3,000. What is the new annual depreciation?
Question 2 of 5
Equipment with a cost of $40,000 and accumulated depreciation of $26,000, already updated to today, is sold for $11,000. What is the result?
Question 3 of 5
Under US GAAP, a machine has a carrying amount of $800,000, expected undiscounted future cash flows of $860,000 and a fair value of $650,000. What impairment loss is recorded?
Question 4 of 5
A mine cost $3,000,000 and will leave land worth $200,000. It holds an estimated 1,400,000 tons. This year 180,000 tons are extracted and 150,000 tons sold. What is total depletion for the year?
Question 5 of 5
A company buys 35% of another company's voting shares and gains significant influence over it. How does it account for the investment?
