Accounting › Section H · Accounting for receivables › Topic H.5
Revenue recognition on long-term projects
A bridge, a ship or a custom software system can take years to deliver. If the builder waited until handover to report any revenue, its income statements would show long droughts and sudden floods. ASC 606 instead lets most such projects earn revenue as the work progresses.
The problem with waiting
Imagine a builder with one three-year contract to construct a school. If revenue were recognised only on completion, the first two income statements would show wages, materials and equipment costs but almost no revenue, and the third would show the whole contract price at once. Users would see two years of apparent losses and one year of spectacular profit, even though the builder worked steadily throughout. That picture tells investors and lenders very little. The revenue recognition principle, applied through step 5 of the five-step model in "The revenue recognition principle", offers a better answer when the customer gains control of the work as it goes along.
When revenue is recognised over time
ASC 606 recognises revenue over time if any one of three conditions holds. First, the customer receives and uses the benefit as the seller performs, as with a multi-year maintenance or cleaning contract. Second, the seller's work creates or enhances an asset the customer controls while it is being built, such as a building on the customer's own land. Third, the asset has no alternative use to the seller, because it is built to the customer's specification, and the seller has an enforceable right to payment for work completed to date. Most construction, shipbuilding and custom engineering contracts meet the second or third condition.
Measuring progress
Once revenue is recognised over time, the seller needs a measure of how much of the job is done. Output methods look at what has been delivered to the customer: units completed, milestones reached or surveys of work performed. Input methods look at the seller's own efforts: labour hours, machine hours or, most commonly, costs incurred. The cost-to-cost method sets
Costs that do not reflect progress, such as materials delivered to the site but not yet installed, are left out of the fraction. Revenue to date is then the contract price times the progress.
Worked example: cost-to-cost
Redfern Builders signs a $12,000,000 contract for a school, with estimated total costs of $9,000,000. Costs are $2,700,000 in year 1, $4,500,000 in year 2 and $1,800,000 in year 3, and the estimate never changes. 1. Year 1: progress \(2.7 \div 9.0 = 30\%\); revenue \(0.30 \times 12{,}000{,}000 = 3{,}600{,}000\); gross profit \(3{,}600{,}000 - 2{,}700{,}000 = 900{,}000\). 2. Year 2: cumulative costs $7,200,000, so progress is 80% and cumulative revenue $9,600,000; subtract year 1 to get revenue of $6,000,000 and gross profit of $1,500,000. 3. Year 3: the remaining $2,400,000 of revenue, with gross profit of $600,000. 4. Check: total gross profit is $900,000 + $1,500,000 + $600,000 = $3,000,000, the contract price less total costs.
Worked example: a revised estimate
Now suppose that during year 2 Redfern revises its estimated total costs to $9,600,000, because steel prices rose. Year 1 is not restated; the change is a change in estimate, handled by a cumulative catch-up. 1. Year 2 progress: \(7{,}200{,}000 \div 9{,}600{,}000 = 75\%\). 2. Cumulative revenue: \(0.75 \times 12{,}000{,}000 = 9{,}000{,}000\), so year 2 revenue is \(9{,}000{,}000 - 3{,}600{,}000\) = $5,400,000. 3. Year 2 gross profit: $5,400,000 − $4,500,000 = $900,000. 4. Year 3: revenue $3,000,000, costs $2,400,000, gross profit $600,000. 5. Check: $900,000 + $900,000 + $600,000 = $2,400,000, which is $12,000,000 − $9,600,000.
Loss contracts and uncertain estimates
If a revised estimate shows that a contract will lose money overall, the whole expected loss is recognised immediately, not spread over the remaining work. Had Redfern's year 2 estimate risen to $12,500,000, the contract would lose $500,000 in total, and year 2 would report a loss of $1,400,000: the $500,000 overall loss plus the reversal of the $900,000 profit already reported in year 1. A different rule applies when progress cannot yet be measured reliably but the seller expects to recover its costs. Then it recognises revenue equal to the costs incurred, showing zero profit, until a reasonable measure becomes available.
Billing, contract assets and contract liabilities
Revenue recognised and amounts billed rarely match. The contract usually sets billing dates or milestones, while revenue follows progress. When revenue recognised to date exceeds the amounts billed, the seller reports a contract asset, a right to payment that is not yet a billable receivable. When billings or advance payments exceed revenue recognised, it reports a contract liability, much like unearned revenue. Suppose Redfern billed $3,000,000 in year 1. It recognised $3,600,000 of revenue, so it reports a $600,000 contract asset; once an amount becomes billable, it moves to Accounts Receivable.
Older methods you may still meet
Some textbooks and older statements describe the completed-contract method, which deferred all revenue and expense to the end of a project when estimates were unreliable. ASC 606 dropped it as a named method. A contract that meets none of the over-time conditions is recognised at the point in time when control passes, often at completion, which can look similar. The installment method, once used for real estate sales with doubtful collection, has also largely gone: under ASC 606 collectibility is tested in step 1, and if it is not probable, cash received is generally held as a liability rather than recognised as revenue. Under IFRS 15 the rules are essentially the same.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, applying this period's progress percentage to the full contract price and calling the result this period's revenue; that gives cumulative revenue, so subtract what earlier periods reported. Second, restating earlier years after a change in estimate instead of using a cumulative catch-up. Third, spreading an expected loss over the remaining years; the full loss is recognised at once. Fourth, counting uninstalled materials as progress. Fifth, confusing a contract asset, earned but not yet billed, with a contract liability, billed or paid but not yet earned.
Key takeaways
Long-term contracts usually earn revenue over time, because the customer benefits as work is done, controls the asset as it is built, or the asset has no alternative use and the seller has a right to payment. Progress is measured by output methods or input methods, most often cost-to-cost: costs to date over estimated total costs. Cumulative revenue is progress times the contract price; this period's revenue is the change in that figure. Revised estimates use a cumulative catch-up, expected losses are recognised in full at once, and gaps between billing and revenue create contract assets or liabilities.
Flashcards
Flashcard
The customer receives the benefit as the seller performs
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
A $5,000,000 contract has estimated total costs of $4,000,000. Costs to date are $1,000,000. Using cost-to-cost, how much revenue has been earned to date?
Question 2 of 5
A contract was 40% complete at the end of year 1 and 70% complete at the end of year 2. The price is $10,000,000. What revenue is recognised in year 2?
Question 3 of 5
Midway through a contract, revised estimates show it will lose $300,000 overall. Earlier years reported $200,000 of profit on it. What loss is reported this year?
Question 4 of 5
By year-end a builder has recognised $2,500,000 of revenue on a contract but has billed the customer only $2,100,000. What does it report?
Question 5 of 5
Which contract most clearly earns revenue over time under ASC 606?
