Accounting › Section G · Fraud, internal controls, and cash › Topic G.4
Management's responsibility for internal control
Auditors test internal controls, but they do not own them. Management designs, runs and answers for the controls, and in US public companies the chief executive and chief financial officer must put their own names to that responsibility.
Whose job is internal control?
It is tempting to think internal control belongs to the accountants or the auditors. In fact management carries the responsibility: managers decide which risks matter, design and put in place the controls, see that staff follow them, and fix them when they fail. The board oversees management, internal auditors evaluate the controls, and external auditors test those that matter to the financial statements, but as independent outsiders they cannot take over management's duty. The Sarbanes-Oxley Act of 2002 turned it into a personal, signed obligation for executives of US public companies.
Who does what
The board of directors sets expectations and oversees management, usually through its audit committee. For US public companies, Sarbanes-Oxley requires the audit committee to be made up of independent directors, to appoint, pay and oversee the external auditor, and to set up procedures for receiving complaints about accounting, including confidential, anonymous reports from employees. The chief executive officer (CEO) runs the business as a whole and the chief financial officer (CFO) its accounting and finance. Operating managers own the controls in their areas, internal audit gives the board independent assurance, and every employee must follow procedures.
Tone at the top
Controls work only if people believe management means them. Tone at the top is the attitude to ethics and control that senior leaders show through what they say and, above all, what they do. Management sets it with a code of conduct, training, a trusted hotline, fair incentives and consistent discipline, including for senior staff. A chief executive who skips the expense approval process, or a bonus plan that pays only for hitting a profit target, sends a louder message than any policy manual. In COSO's framework this is part of the control environment, the foundation for every other component.
Section 302: executives certify each report
Under Section 302 of the Sarbanes-Oxley Act, the CEO and CFO of a public company must personally certify every quarterly and annual report filed with the SEC. Each certifies that they have reviewed the report, that it contains no untrue statement of a material fact and leaves out nothing that would make it misleading, and that the financial statements fairly present the company's financial condition and results in all material respects. They also certify that they are responsible for the company's disclosure controls and internal controls, have evaluated them, and have told the auditors and the audit committee about significant deficiencies, material weaknesses and any fraud involving management or key control staff.
Section 404: management's annual assessment
Section 404(a) requires management of every public company to include in its annual report a report on internal control over financial reporting. It must state management's responsibility for establishing and maintaining adequate controls, give management's assessment of whether those controls were effective at the end of the fiscal year, and name the framework used, which for most companies is COSO's. Section 404(b) adds an independent auditor's report on internal control over financial reporting, but only for larger public companies, known as accelerated and large accelerated filers; smaller companies are exempt from 404(b) while still bound by 404(a). Management cannot call its controls effective if any material weakness exists.
Ranking control problems
Not every lapse is equally serious, so management ranks problems. A control deficiency exists when a control's design or operation does not let staff prevent or detect misstatements in time during their normal work. A material weakness is a deficiency, or combination of deficiencies, creating a reasonable possibility that a material misstatement of the annual or interim financial statements will not be prevented or detected in time. A significant deficiency sits between the two: less severe than a material weakness, but important enough to deserve the attention of those overseeing financial reporting. Material weaknesses must be disclosed in a public company's annual report on internal control.
Worked example: classifying three problems
Assume Redwater Foods, a public company, judges any misstatement above about $2 million to be material. 1. A supervisor once forgot to initial a $300 expense claim, though every other claim that year was reviewed. This is a control deficiency: the control usually works and the possible error is tiny. 2. Customer credit limits are rarely checked, so bad-debt estimates could be off by around $1 million. Probably a significant deficiency: real, and worth the audit committee's attention, but unlikely to cause a material misstatement. 3. The controller can post any journal entry, of any size, and nobody reviews them. This is likely a material weakness, because a material misstatement could go undetected. Check: severity rises with the possible size and likelihood of misstatement.
Worked example: a CFO before signing
Two days before the annual report is filed, Redwater's CFO learns that internal audit found an unreconciled account holding $3.1 million of unexplained differences. 1. She cannot simply sign; Section 302 makes her personally responsible for what she certifies. 2. She has the account investigated and reconciled, and any misstatement found corrected before filing. 3. Because a $3.1 million unexplained balance exceeds materiality and the reconciliation control plainly failed, she reports it to the audit committee and the external auditor as a likely material weakness. 4. If it is a material weakness at year-end, management's Section 404(a) report must conclude that internal control over financial reporting was not effective, and describe the weakness. Check: disclosure, not silence, protects investors and the CFO.
Backing up the signatures
Executives cannot check every transaction themselves, so they build an evidence trail. Management documents each significant process, from sales to payroll, often in a risk and control matrix linking each risk to the control that addresses it. Staff perform walkthroughs, following a transaction from start to finish to confirm the controls exist, and test samples to see whether the controls operated all year. Managers below the CFO sign sub-certifications for their own areas. Problems are ranked and remediated. Section 906 of the Act adds criminal penalties, including fines and prison terms, for executives who knowingly certify reports that do not comply.
Beyond public companies
Sarbanes-Oxley's certification and Section 404 rules apply to public companies, not to most private businesses. The underlying responsibility is the same everywhere: a small company's owner must still protect its assets and keep reliable records. Banks often require borrowers to supply reviewed or audited statements, private investors ask for sound controls, and not-for-profits answer to donors for how restricted money is spent. Many private organisations adopt COSO's framework voluntarily, scaled to their size.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, saying the external auditor is responsible for a company's internal controls; the auditor tests and reports, but management owns them. Second, mixing up the sections: Section 302 is the CEO and CFO certification of each quarterly and annual report, while Section 404 covers the annual report on internal control over financial reporting. Third, assuming every public company needs an auditor's report under 404(b); smaller companies are exempt from that part. Fourth, calling every lapse a material weakness; the label requires a reasonable possibility of a material misstatement.
Key takeaways
Management designs, runs and fixes internal controls; the board and its audit committee oversee them; internal and external auditors evaluate them. Tone at the top, set by leaders' behaviour, is the foundation. Under Sarbanes-Oxley Section 302, the CEO and CFO certify each quarterly and annual report and their responsibility for controls. Section 404(a) requires management's annual assessment of internal control over financial reporting, usually against COSO; 404(b) adds an auditor's report for larger companies. Problems are ranked as control deficiencies, significant deficiencies and material weaknesses, and any material weakness rules out a conclusion that controls are effective.
Flashcards
Flashcard
Management, overseen by the board of directors
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
Who bears primary responsibility for a company's internal control over financial reporting?
Question 2 of 5
Under Section 302 of the Sarbanes-Oxley Act, who must personally certify each quarterly and annual report?
Question 3 of 5
Which description fits a material weakness in internal control?
Question 4 of 5
What does Section 404(a) of the Sarbanes-Oxley Act require?
Question 5 of 5
At year-end, management identifies a material weakness that has not been fixed. What must its Section 404(a) report conclude?
