Accounting › Section P · Managerial accounting and cost behavior › Topic P.1
Managerial versus financial accounting
Annual financial statements tell outsiders how a business did, but managers have to decide what to do next week. This topic shows how managerial accounting supports the three core jobs of management and sets out, point by point, how it differs from financial accounting.
From the annual report to the shop floor
The first half of this course built the financial statements: periodic, rule-bound reports for investors, lenders and regulators. "Why accounting matters: financial and managerial" introduced the second branch in outline. Now we take it further. A manager choosing a price, a supplier or a staffing level needs figures that are detailed, current and aimed at one decision, and a yearly income statement covering the whole company rarely gives that. Managerial accounting is the process of identifying, measuring, analysing and communicating financial and nonfinancial information to people inside an organisation, so that they can plan, control and evaluate its operations. Every section from here to the end of the course develops one of its tools.
Planning: deciding where to go
Planning is setting goals and choosing the steps that will reach them. It usually starts from a mission statement, a short statement of what the organisation exists to do. Goals are the broad results it wants over time, such as a larger market share; objectives are the specific, measurable targets that show progress towards a goal, such as 8% more customers by December. Strategic planning sets priorities and allocates resources over several years. Operating plans translate the strategy into this year's actions, and the budget, covered in "How and why managers budget", turns those actions into expected revenues, costs and staff numbers.
Controlling: keeping the plan on track
Controlling is the day-to-day work of carrying out the plan and coordinating people and resources so that their activities add up to the goals. Managerial accounting supplies the measures that make control possible. Some are financial, such as cost per unit or spending against budget. Some are operational, such as defect rates, delivery times or machine downtime. Others are physical safeguards, such as passwords, locked stores and security tags, which the internal-control topics in the financial half described. A measure is only useful for control if it arrives quickly enough for someone to act on it, so control reports are often weekly or even daily.
Evaluating: did it work?
Evaluating compares actual results with the plan, explains the gaps and decides what to change. A gap between actual and planned results is called a variance; the budgeting and standard-cost sections show how to measure variances precisely and how to separate those managers can control from those they cannot. Evaluation does not end the process. Its findings feed the next round of planning: a target may prove unrealistic, a method may need changing, or a success may deserve wider use. Planning, controlling and evaluating therefore form a continuous cycle, and managerial accounting supports every stage of it.
Worked example: one goal through the cycle
Wexcombe Couriers, a fictional bicycle courier firm, made 90,000 deliveries last year and 6.0% arrived late. 1. Plan: the owners set an objective of no more than 3.0% late this year and budget $6.20 of cost per delivery, including new route-planning software. 2. Control: a weekly report shows each rider's late deliveries and the firm's cost per delivery, so supervisors can move riders to busy districts as problems appear. 3. Evaluate the first quarter: 1,080 of 24,000 deliveries were late, which is 4.5%. Costs were $151,200, or \(151{,}200 \div 24{,}000 = 6.30\) dollars per delivery. 4. Interpret: lateness is falling but is still above target, and cost is 10 cents over budget because of overtime. 5. Act: the plan for the next quarter adds two part-time riders at peak hours, and the cycle continues.
How the branches differ: users, reports, timing
Seven differences are worth knowing. First, users: financial reports serve stockholders, lenders and regulators outside the organisation, while managerial reports serve managers and staff inside it. Second, types of reports: financial accounting produces a standard set of statements prepared under US GAAP, while managerial accounting produces whatever helps, such as budgets, product cost reports, route or store profitability and forecasts. Third, frequency: financial statements appear quarterly or yearly, while managerial reports appear whenever a decision needs them, from hourly sales dashboards to a single study for one investment. Timeliness often matters more than perfect precision: a good estimate today can be worth more than an exact figure next month.
How the branches differ: purpose, focus, nature, checks
Fourth, purpose: financial accounting reports what has happened so outsiders can judge the organisation, while managerial accounting is used to decide what to do next, so much of it is forecasts and what-if analysis. Fifth, focus: financial statements cover the organisation as a whole, while managerial reports often zoom in on one product, department, customer group or decision. Sixth, nature of the information: financial statements are almost entirely in dollars, while managerial reports freely mix dollars with nonfinancial measures such as hours, defect counts and customer satisfaction. Seventh, verification: public companies' annual statements are audited by independent auditors, while internal reports are checked, if at all, by the organisation's own staff. One limit applies to both: information is worth producing only if its benefit exceeds its cost.
Worked example: two views of one year
Wexcombe's financial statements show revenue of $1,140,000, expenses of $1,062,000 and net income of $78,000. That is all an outside lender needs. The managers ask a different question: which services earn the money? The accountant splits revenue and the costs each service causes directly:
1. Documents earn $110,000 and parcels $90,000 before shared costs. 2. Medical samples lose $12,000. 3. Check: $110,000 + $90,000 − $12,000 = $188,000, less $110,000 of shared costs such as rent and the owners' salaries, gives $78,000, matching the income statement. 4. The report raises a question rather than answering it: whether to reprice or drop medical deliveries is analysed in "Keeping or dropping a segment".
Common mistakes to avoid
First, assuming managerial reports must follow GAAP; GAAP governs reports for outsiders, and an internal report may use any method that helps a decision, as long as users understand it. Second, treating managerial accounting as forecasting only; control and evaluation rely on detailed records of what actually happened. Third, ignoring nonfinancial measures; Wexcombe's late-delivery rate explained its overtime cost before the dollars did. Fourth, demanding precision that arrives too late to use. Fifth, thinking the two branches use separate data; both draw on the same underlying records, organised differently for different users.
Key takeaways
Managerial accounting provides financial and nonfinancial information to people inside an organisation. It supports the three core jobs of management: planning (mission, goals, objectives and budgets), controlling (coordinating daily activity using timely measures) and evaluating (comparing actual results with the plan and acting on variances), which repeat as a cycle. It differs from financial accounting in users, types of reports, frequency, purpose, focus, the nature of its information and how it is verified. Internal reports are flexible, often forward-looking and detailed by product or department, and they are worth producing only when their benefit exceeds their cost.
Flashcards
Flashcard
Financial and nonfinancial information for people inside an organisation
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
A café owner compares this week's actual food cost with the budget and finds it 4% too high, then changes a supplier. Which management job does the comparison and change mainly represent?
Question 2 of 5
Which statement correctly contrasts the two branches?
Question 3 of 5
In the first quarter, a courier firm made 24,000 deliveries, 1,080 of them late, at a total cost of $151,200. What were its late rate and cost per delivery?
Question 4 of 5
Which of these is an objective rather than a goal?
Question 5 of 5
A manager wants a rough cost estimate for a bid due tomorrow, but an exact figure would take three weeks. What does managerial accounting suggest?
