Accounting › Section E · Merchandising transactions › Topic E.4

Recording sales, returns, and discounts

A sale is rarely the end of the story: customers send goods back, ask for price cuts on damaged items and pay early to earn a discount. Recording each step properly turns gross sales into the net sales figure a merchandiser actually keeps.

Two entries for every sale

Under a perpetual system each sale of merchandise is recorded twice. The first entry records the revenue at selling price: debit Cash or Accounts Receivable, credit Sales. The second records the cost at what the goods cost the seller: debit Cost of Goods Sold, credit Inventory, the asset account for merchandise on hand. The difference between the two amounts is the gross profit on that sale. A periodic system records only the first entry, as "Perpetual versus periodic inventory systems" explains. This topic follows the seller's side of the events that "Recording merchandise purchases" covered for the buyer. In the entries, Accounts Receivable is shortened to Accts Receivable and Sales Returns and Allowances to Sales Ret. and Allow.

Contra-revenue accounts

Returns, allowances and early-payment discounts all reduce revenue, but the seller does not debit Sales directly. Instead it uses contra-revenue accounts: Sales Returns and Allowances, and Sales Discounts. These have normal debit balances and are subtracted from Sales on the income statement: net sales equal gross sales minus sales returns and allowances minus sales discounts. Keeping them separate preserves the original sales figure and shows managers how much revenue is lost to returns and discounts, which can signal product quality problems or overly generous terms. Some companies keep returns and allowances in two separate accounts for the same reason. Both accounts are temporary and are closed with the expenses at year end.

Worked example: a credit sale

On 4 June 2026, Thistlecombe Paper Supply Inc. sells 200 cases of copy paper at $38 a case to a school district on account, terms 2/10, n/30, invoice dated 4 June. Each case cost Thistlecombe $22. 1. Record the revenue, 200 × $38 = $7,600:

\begin{array}{lrr}\text{Account}&\text{Debit}&\text{Credit}\\\hline\text{Accts Receivable}&7{,}600&\\\quad\text{Sales}&&7{,}600\end{array}

2. Record the cost, 200 × $22 = $4,400:

\begin{array}{lrr}\text{Account}&\text{Debit}&\text{Credit}\\\hline\text{Cost of Goods Sold}&4{,}400&\\\quad\text{Inventory}&&4{,}400\end{array}

3. Check: gross profit on the sale so far is $7,600 − $4,400 = $3,200.

Worked example: a return and an allowance

1. On 7 June the customer returns 15 cases it did not need. They are undamaged, so Thistlecombe can resell them. Reverse the revenue at selling price, 15 × $38 = $570:

\begin{array}{lrr}\text{Account}&\text{Debit}&\text{Credit}\\\hline\text{Sales Ret. and Allow.}&570&\\\quad\text{Accts Receivable}&&570\end{array}

2. Put the cases back into stock at cost, 15 × $22 = $330:

\begin{array}{lrr}\text{Account}&\text{Debit}&\text{Credit}\\\hline\text{Inventory}&330&\\\quad\text{Cost of Goods Sold}&&330\end{array}

3. On 9 JuneThistlecombe grants a $130 allowance for water-stained cases the customer keeps. No goods come back, so a single entry does it: a $130 debit to the contra-revenue account and a matching $130 credit to the customer's receivable. 4. Check: the customer now owes $7,600 − $570 − $130 = $6,900.

Returned goods that cannot be resold

The second entry for a return depends on the condition of the goods. If they can be sold again, as Thistlecombe's spare cases could, they go back into Inventory at their original cost and Cost of Goods Sold is reduced. If they are damaged beyond sale, no inventory is restored, because there is no longer an asset; the cost stays in Cost of Goods Sold or is moved to a separate loss account, depending on the company's policy. If goods have some scrap value, they are restored at that lower value. An allowance never needs a cost entry, because the customer keeps the goods and nothing returns to stock. If the customer had already paid, the seller would credit Cash for any refund instead of Accounts Receivable.

Worked example: collecting within the discount period

The discount period runs 10 days from the 4 June invoice date, to 14 June. The customer pays on 13 June. 1. Discount: 2% × $6,900 = $138, based on the balance after the return and allowance. 2. Cash received: $6,900 − $138 = $6,762. 3. Record it; Accounts Receivable is cleared in full:

\begin{array}{lrr}\text{Account}&\text{Debit}&\text{Credit}\\\hline\text{Cash}&6{,}762&\\\text{Sales Discounts}&138&\\\quad\text{Accts Receivable}&&6{,}900\end{array}

4. Summarise: net sales are $7,600 − $570 − $130 − $138 = $6,762; cost of goods sold is $4,400 − $330 = $4,070; gross profit is $6,762 − $4,070 = $2,692. Had the customer paid on 25 June, outside the discount period, Thistlecombe would debit Cash and credit Accounts Receivable for $6,900.

Sales tax is not revenue

Many US states and cities require sellers to collect sales tax from customers on retail sales. That money belongs to the government, so the seller records it as a liability, Sales Tax Payable, until it is paid over. Suppose a Thistlecombe store sells a printer for $500 cash and, assuming a 7% sales tax rate for illustration, collects $35 of tax. Rates and rules vary by place.

\begin{array}{lrr}\text{Account}&\text{Debit}&\text{Credit}\\\hline\text{Cash}&535&\\\quad\text{Sales}&&500\\\quad\text{Sales Tax Payable}&&35\end{array}

When Thistlecombe sends the tax to the state, it debits Sales Tax Payable and credits Cash. Trade discounts are also kept out of the accounts: a sale is recorded at the price agreed after any trade discount.

Estimating returns and discounts

The entries in this topic record each return and discount when it happens, which is how introductory courses usually present them. The US revenue standard, ASC 606, adds a refinement for companies whose customers are expected to return goods or take discounts in significant amounts. Such a company recognises revenue only for the amount it expects to keep, recording a refund liability for expected returns and an asset for the goods it expects to get back. If the estimates prove right, total revenue over time is the same; estimating moves the effect into the period of the sale. The wider rules for timing revenue are the subject of "The revenue recognition principle". The double entry for each event, as shown here, stays the foundation.

Common mistakes to avoid

1. Forgetting the cost entry, for a sale or for a resaleable return. Under a perpetual system each one has two parts. 2. Restoring returned goods at selling price; they go back at cost. 3. Debiting Sales directly for a return instead of Sales Returns and Allowances. 4. Calculating the discount on the original invoice rather than on the balance after returns and allowances: 2% of $6,900, not of $7,600. 5. Recording sales tax as revenue. 6. Making a cost entry for an allowance. The customer keeps the goods, so nothing returns to inventory. 7. Treating Sales Discounts as an expense; it is a contra-revenue account that reduces net sales.

Key takeaways

A perpetual sale needs a revenue entry at selling price and a cost entry moving the goods from Inventory to Cost of Goods Sold. Returns and allowances are debited to Sales Returns and Allowances; a resaleable return also restores inventory at cost and reduces Cost of Goods Sold, while an allowance needs no cost entry. A customer paying within the discount period is credited for the full receivable, with the discount debited to Sales Discounts. Both contra-revenue accounts have debit balances, and net sales equal gross sales minus returns and allowances minus discounts. Sales tax collected is a liability, not revenue.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Perpetual credit sale

Debit Accounts Receivable, credit Sales; debit COGS, credit Inventory

Thistlecombe: $7,600 at price, $4,400 at cost.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

Under a perpetual system, goods costing $900 are sold on account for $1,500. Which pair of entries is correct?

Question 2 of 5

A customer returns undamaged goods sold for $400 that cost $250, before paying. What is the second entry, for the cost?

Question 3 of 5

A $5,000 sale on terms 2/10, n/30 is followed by a $1,000 return. The customer pays within the discount period. How much cash does the seller receive?

Question 4 of 5

Gross sales are $90,000, sales returns and allowances $3,500 and sales discounts $1,200. What are net sales?

Question 5 of 5

A store sells goods for $200 cash and collects $12 of sales tax. How is the $12 recorded?

← Previous topicNext topic →