Accounting › Section Z · Sustainability reporting › Topic Z.2

Reporting sustainability: users, initiatives, and the future

Sustainability reports have moved from glossy brochures towards structured disclosures built on published standards, and in some places they are now required by law. This topic covers who reads them, the main frameworks as they stood by late 2026, how greenhouse gas emissions are counted, and what remains unsettled.

Who reads sustainability information

Different users want different things. Investors and lenders want to know how environmental and social matters could affect a company's cash flows, risks and cost of capital. Employees look at working conditions and safety. Customers, including companies choosing suppliers, look at product impacts and supply chains. Governments and regulators use the information to check compliance and shape policy. Local communities care about pollution, water use and jobs. Because these users ask different questions, frameworks differ in what they treat as worth reporting.

Materiality: two directions

Information is material if leaving it out could change the decisions of the people the report is for. Sustainability reporting looks in two directions. Financial materiality looks from the outside in: how sustainability matters, such as water scarcity or carbon rules, affect the company's prospects. Its audience is mainly investors and lenders. Impact materiality looks from the inside out: how the company affects the economy, the environment and people, whether or not that affects its own finances. Double materiality treats a matter as reportable if it is material in either direction. Which view a framework takes explains much of how frameworks differ.

The Global Reporting Initiative

The Global Reporting Initiative (GRI) was founded in Boston in 1997 and published its first reporting guidelines in 2000. In 2016 it replaced its guidelines with the GRI Standards, and a revised set of Universal Standards took effect for reports published from 1 January 2023. Universal Standards apply to every reporter, Sector Standards cover particular industries, and Topic Standards cover subjects such as emissions or water. GRI takes the impact view, asking organisations to report their most significant impacts on the economy, environment and people. Its use is largely voluntary and widespread.

SASB and integrated reporting

The Sustainability Accounting Standards Board (SASB), founded in the United States in 2011, took the financial view. In 2018 it published 77 industry standards, each listing the sustainability topics most likely to matter financially in that industry, such as fuel use for airlines or data security for software firms. The International Integrated Reporting Council (IIRC), formed in 2010, issued a framework in 2013 for integrated reports that explain how a company creates value using six capitals: financial, manufactured, intellectual, human, social and relationship, and natural. In 2021 SASB and the IIRC merged into the Value Reporting Foundation, which joined the IFRS Foundation in 2022.

The ISSB: IFRS S1 and S2

In November 2021 the IFRS Foundation, which oversees IFRS Accounting Standards, created the International Sustainability Standards Board (ISSB). In June 2023 the ISSB issued its first two standards, effective for annual periods beginning on or after 1 January 2024 wherever a jurisdiction adopts them. IFRS S1 sets general requirements for disclosing sustainability-related risks and opportunities useful to investors. IFRS S2 covers climate, including Scope 1, 2 and 3 greenhouse gas emissions. Both are organised around four pillars taken from the Task Force on Climate-related Financial Disclosures (TCFD): governance, strategy, risk management, and metrics and targets. The ISSB now maintains the SASB Standards, and S1 points preparers to them.

The EU Corporate Sustainability Reporting Directive

The European Union adopted the Corporate Sustainability Reporting Directive (CSRD) in December 2022, replacing its earlier non-financial reporting rules. Companies in scope report under European Sustainability Reporting Standards (ESRS), developed by EFRAG; the European Commission adopted the first set in July 2023. ESRS use double materiality, and the reported information must be independently assured to a limited level. The first reports, covering financial year 2024, came in 2025 from the largest companies already reporting under the older rules. In April 2025 the EU postponed the start for later groups by two years. In December 2025 the Parliament and Council agreed a simplification package, Omnibus I, narrowing the scope towards the largest companies (the Commission had proposed more than 1,000 employees), and in July 2026 the Commission adopted simplified ESRS. Check the current rules before relying on any threshold or date.

Counting greenhouse gases: three scopes

Most frameworks measure emissions with the Greenhouse Gas Protocol, which sorts them into three scopes, in tonnes of CO₂e. Scope 1 covers direct emissions from sources the company owns or controls, such as its boilers and vehicles. Scope 2 covers indirect emissions from the electricity, steam, heat or cooling the company buys. Scope 3 covers all other indirect emissions in the value chain, upstream and downstream, such as purchased goods, outsourced transport, business travel, employee commuting and the use of sold products. Scope 3 is often the largest share and the hardest to measure.

Worked example: a greenhouse gas inventory

Northwick Logistics reports these annual emissions, in tonnes of CO₂e: diesel burned in its own trucks 4,200; gas heating in its warehouses 300; purchased electricity 1,100; subcontracted rail freight 2,600; business flights 150; employee commuting 400. Revenue was $90 million, up from $80 million, and last year's Scope 1 and 2 total was 6,100 tonnes. 1. Scope 1: \(4{,}200 + 300 = 4{,}500\). 2. Scope 2: 1,100. 3. Scope 3: \(2{,}600 + 150 + 400 = 3{,}150\). 4. Scope 1 and 2 intensity: \(5{,}600 \div 90 = 62.2\) tonnes per $ million, down from \(6{,}100 \div 80 = 76.3\). 5. Interpret: absolute Scope 1 and 2 emissions fell 8.2%, but intensity fell 18.4%, partly because revenue grew, so reporting both gives the fuller picture.

Worked example: a materiality assessment

Talgarth Apparel dyes fabric in a region prone to drought and buys garments from contract factories. It sorts four matters. 1. Water use at its dye-house: shortages could halt production (financial) and its use strains local supplies (impact), so it is material both ways. 2. Working conditions in supplier factories: these affect workers directly (impact), and buyers or regulators may react (financial), so both. 3. Rising cotton prices from climate-related crop failures: these affect Talgarth's costs (financial), but the company does not cause them, so financial only. 4. Office paper recycling: too small to matter either way, so it is left out. Under double materiality, the first three are reported.

The United States, assurance and what comes next

The United States has no general federal requirement to publish a sustainability report, though many large US companies report voluntarily, often using GRI or SASB, and some states, such as California, have passed their own climate-disclosure laws. The SEC adopted climate-disclosure rules in March 2024, then stayed them while court challenges proceeded, and on 27 March 2025 voted to stop defending them in court; as of the SEC's May 2025 update the rules remained stayed. Open questions include how closely ESRS and ISSB requirements can be aligned, how assurance requirements will develop, how to improve Scope 3 data, and how far digital tagging will make reports machine-readable.

Common mistakes to avoid

Treating all frameworks as interchangeable: GRI centres on impacts, the ISSB and SASB on financial materiality, and ESRS on both. Putting purchased electricity in Scope 1, or a company's own fuel use in Scope 2. Leaving out Scope 3 because it is hard to measure. Reporting only intensity, or only absolute emissions. Assuming a framework is legally required everywhere: the ISSB standards apply only where a jurisdiction adopts them. Quoting reporting dates without checking them, as several have changed since 2023.

Key takeaways

Investors, lenders, employees, customers, regulators and communities read sustainability information for different reasons. Financial materiality looks outside in, impact materiality inside out, and double materiality uses both. GRI (1997; Standards from 2016) is impact-based; SASB (2011) is industry-based and financial, now maintained by the ISSB, whose IFRS S1 and S2 were issued in June 2023. The EU's CSRD requires ESRS reporting with double materiality and assurance; its timetable and scope were revised in 2025 and 2026. Emissions fall into Scopes 1, 2 and 3. Many rules are still changing.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Report users

Investors, lenders, employees, customers, regulators, communities

Each asks different questions.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

A retailer buys electricity from the grid to light its stores. In which scope are the resulting emissions reported?

Question 2 of 5

Which approach treats a matter as reportable if it affects the company's finances or if the company significantly affects people or the environment?

Question 3 of 5

A company emits 2,200 tonnes CO₂e in Scope 1, 800 in Scope 2 and 1,800 in Scope 3, on revenue of $40 million. What is its Scope 1 and 2 intensity?

Question 4 of 5

What do the ISSB's IFRS S1 and S2, issued in June 2023, mainly aim to provide?

Question 5 of 5

A company's emissions rose 5% while its revenue rose 20%. What happened to absolute emissions and to emissions intensity?

← Previous topic