American Government › Section K · Congress › Topic K.2

Congressional elections

Every two years voters choose the whole House and a third of the Senate. The rules of those contests, the money behind them and the strong pull of incumbency go a long way towards explaining who sits in Congress and how they behave once there.

An election every two years

Federal law sets congressional Election Day as the Tuesday after the first Monday in November of even-numbered years. All 435 House seats are on the ballot each time, along with about a third of the Senate. Elections held halfway through a president's term are called midterms; the most recent took place on 3 November 2026, and the members chosen will form the 120th Congress, which begins in January 2027 under the Twentieth Amendment.

Who can run, and filling vacancies

A representative must be at least 25, a citizen for seven years and an inhabitant of the state; a senator must be at least 30, a citizen for nine years and an inhabitant of the state. Members need not live in their district, though nearly all do. The Supreme Court ruled in U.S. Term Limits v. Thornton (1995) that states cannot add qualifications, so state-imposed congressional term limits are unconstitutional. When a House seat falls vacant, only a special election can fill it. A Senate vacancy can be filled for a time by the governor's appointment if state law allows, as the Seventeenth Amendment permits.

How chamber design shapes campaigns

House members serve two-year terms in single districts, so they stay close to local concerns and are quickly punished for unpopular votes. A district can be small and fairly uniform, letting a member win by appealing to one dominant group. Senators win statewide, so they must assemble broader coalitions, and their six-year terms let them ride out a short-lived wave of anger. Senate races also draw more money and attention, and they are more often competitive, because a whole state is rarely as one-sided as a carefully drawn district.

The rules on money

Winning a House race now commonly costs millions of dollars. The Federal Election Campaign Act of 1971, strengthened in 1974, required disclosure, capped contributions and created the Federal Election Commission (FEC). Limits rise with inflation: in 2025-2026 an individual could give a candidate $3,500 per election, so $7,000 across a primary and a general election. Most money given directly to candidates comes from individuals, not political action committees (PACs). This regulated hard money differs from soft money, party funds for general purposes, which the McCain-Feingold Act of 2002 barred national parties from raising. In Citizens United v. FEC (2010) the Supreme Court struck down limits on independent spending by corporations and unions, and super PACs followed: they may raise and spend unlimited sums if they do not coordinate with candidates. Supporters call this protected speech; critics say it magnifies wealthy donors.

The incumbency advantage

An incumbent is the current holder of an office. In most House elections since the 1950s, more than 90 percent of incumbents seeking re-election have won, and senators win at slightly lower but still high rates. Incumbents enjoy name recognition, paid staff, free official mail known as franking, and years of casework, helping constituents with problems such as benefits or passports. They also raise far more money, partly because donors back likely winners. In Congress: The Electoral Connection (1974), the political scientist David Mayhew argued that members' behaviour is driven by re-election through advertising, credit claiming for benefits and position taking on issues. Strong challengers often wait for an open seat instead.

Worked example: reading a re-election rate

Suppose 395 House incumbents seek re-election; 4 lose their party primaries and 13 lose in November. 1. Winners: 395 - 4 - 13 = 378. 2. Rate: 378 / 395 is about 95.7 percent. 3. Notice the denominator: members who retire are left out, and some retire because they expect to lose, so the rate flatters incumbents a little. 4. Separate the two kinds of defeat: losses in primaries show pressure from within the party, while November losses show pressure from the other party. 5. Conclusion: a rate near 96 percent is typical, but it measures only those who chose to run.

Safe seats and primaries

A safe seat is one that a party wins so reliably that the November result is barely in doubt. Thanks to party loyalty, where people live and sometimes gerrymandering, many House districts are safe. There the real contest is the primary, in which a party's voters choose its nominee. Primary voters tend to be more committed partisans than general-election voters, so members in safe seats may fear a challenge from the edge of their own party more than defeat by the other party. California and Washington use a top-two primary, in which all candidates appear on one ballot and the two leaders advance, whatever their party.

Midterms and surge and decline

Since the Civil War the president's party has lost House seats in almost every midterm; the clearest exceptions are 1934, 1998 and 2002. In 1960 the political scientist Angus Campbell offered the surge-and-decline theory: the excitement of a presidential race draws in less-engaged voters who lean towards the winner, and when they stay home at the midterm, the president's party falls back. Later researchers proposed other explanations as well. Some see midterms as a referendum on the president's performance, especially the economy. Others argue that some voters deliberately balance power by backing the party out of the White House.

Worked example: tracing a midterm loss

Consider an imagined president elected with high turnout whose approval falls to about 40 percent by the midterm. 1. Turnout effect: occasional voters who supported the president's party in the presidential year are less likely to vote. 2. Referendum effect: dissatisfied voters use the only federal contest available to send a message. 3. Candidate effect: strong challengers enter, while some of the president's party retire rather than face a hard race. 4. Result: the president's party loses seats, most of them in competitive districts. 5. Check against the exceptions: in 1998 and 2002 unusual national moods reversed the usual effects.

Local and national elections

Former Speaker Tip O'Neill is credited with the saying "All politics is local", meaning that voters care most about jobs, roads and services close to home. For much of the twentieth century many voters split their tickets, which let many Southern Democrats keep congressional seats as the region voted Republican for president. Since the 1990s split-ticket voting has declined sharply, and congressional races increasingly track national party loyalty and the president's popularity, a trend called nationalisation. Wave elections, such as Democratic gains in 2006 and Republican gains in 2010, show national tides sweeping many districts at once.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, thinking the whole Senate is elected every two years; only about a third is. Second, believing states can impose term limits on members of Congress; Thornton (1995) forbids it. Third, assuming super PACs may give unlimited money to candidates; they may spend unlimited sums independently but cannot coordinate. Fourth, reading a high re-election rate as proof that voters love Congress; it reflects incumbents' resources, safe seats and strategic retirements. Fifth, assuming the general election always decides a safe seat; the primary usually does.

Key takeaways

The House is elected every two years and about a third of the Senate with it. Age, citizenship and residence rules are fixed by the Constitution, and Thornton (1995) bars state term limits. Campaign money is capped and disclosed under FECA, with $3,500 per candidate per election for individuals in 2025-2026, but Citizens United (2010) opened the way for super PACs. Incumbents usually win thanks to recognition, casework, money and safe seats, which shift real competition to primaries. The president's party usually loses seats at midterms, and elections have become more nationalised.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Election Day

Tuesday after the first Monday in November of even years

All House seats and about a third of the Senate.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

A state passes a law limiting its members of the House to three terms. What happens if it is challenged in court?

Question 2 of 5

What can a super PAC legally do?

Question 3 of 5

Of 400 House incumbents seeking re-election, 6 lose primaries and 14 lose in November. What is the re-election rate among those who ran?

Question 4 of 5

According to Angus Campbell's surge-and-decline theory, why does the president's party usually lose seats at the midterm?

Question 5 of 5

In a district that one party wins by 40 points every time, where is the member most likely to face a serious threat?

← Previous topicNext topic →