American Government › Section A · Government and civic engagement › Topic A.2
Who governs? Elitism, pluralism, and tradeoffs
Americans can vote, petition, lobby and sue, yet many suspect that a powerful few really call the shots. Political scientists have argued about this for decades, and the evidence they weigh shows how policy actually gets made.
A long-running argument
The American system offers an unusual number of doors into government: city councils, state legislatures, governors, federal agencies, courts and Congress. Many people see that as proof that ordinary citizens and the groups they join can shape what government does. Others look at who actually holds office and who funds campaigns, and conclude that a small, wealthy minority decides the big questions. These two readings are known as elite theory and pluralist theory. A third view, the tradeoffs perspective, argues that real policy usually comes out of compromises among both elites and wider groups.
Elite theory
Elite theory holds that political power is concentrated in a small group of people. Its best-known American statement is The Power Elite, published in 1956 by the sociologist C. Wright Mills. Mills argued that the leaders of large corporations, the military and the national executive branch formed an interlocking circle, moving between top posts and sharing similar schooling and outlooks. In this view, major decisions about war, the economy and spending are made at the top, and elections and interest groups mostly settle secondary matters. Some earlier European writers went further, arguing that every large organisation ends up run by a few.
The evidence elitists cite
Supporters of elite theory point first to who governs. Members of Congress and presidents are, on average, far wealthier and more highly educated than the voters they represent, and many attended a small set of selective universities. They also point to money: campaigns depend on large donors, and well-funded groups can hire many lobbyists. A widely discussed 2014 study by Martin Gilens and Benjamin Page examined about 1,800 policy questions from 1981 to 2002. It found that when the preferences of affluent citizens and organised business differed from those of the median citizen, outcomes tended to follow the affluent.
Pluralist theory
Pluralist theory holds that power is spread among many competing groups rather than held by one elite. In Who Governs?, published in 1961, the political scientist Robert Dahl studied decisions in New Haven, Connecticut, on urban redevelopment, public schools and party nominations. He found different people and groups influential in different areas, with no single ruling circle. Pluralists argue that people with shared interests organise into groups, such as unions, business associations and environmental organisations, and that politicians seeking votes respond to them. Federalism and the separation of powers create many access points, so a group that loses in one place can try another.
Critics of both views
Each theory has drawn criticism. Critics of pluralism note that interests do not organise equally: the political scientist E. E. Schattschneider argued in 1960 that the group system is tilted towards the better-off and better-educated. Peter Bachrach and Morton Baratz argued in 1962 that power includes keeping issues off the agenda altogether, so studying visible decisions can miss it. Critics of elite theory reply that elites often disagree with one another, and several scholars responding to Gilens and Page found that the affluent and the middle class usually want similar policies, so ordinary citizens often get their way anyway.
Worked example: testing the theories on one case
A city council votes on whether to give $200 million in public money towards a new sports stadium. 1. Identify the actors: the team's owners, construction firms, unions, taxpayer groups and neighbourhood residents. 2. Elitist prediction: owners and business leaders get the subsidy, whatever most residents think. 3. Pluralist prediction: the outcome reflects the balance of organised groups, and residents can win if they mobilise. 4. Evidence to gather: public opinion polls, who lobbied and gave money, and how the final deal changed. 5. Conclusion: a smaller subsidy with a community benefits clause would point to bargaining among both sides, the pattern the tradeoffs perspective expects.
The tradeoffs perspective
The tradeoffs perspective treats policy less as a tug-of-war won by one side and more as a long series of compromises. Government balances competing goods, such as liberty and security, or jobs and environmental protection, and competing groups, including both elites and broad publics. Since the founding, for example, Americans have bargained over how much power should sit with the national government and how much with the states. During the COVID-19 pandemic of 2020, most rules on masks, school closures and business openings were set by state and local governments, and Americans disagreed over whether national rules would have been better.
Tradeoffs between rights
Many tradeoffs involve rights that collide. The First Amendment protects speech, and the Fourteenth Amendment extends that protection against state governments. In 2007, Massachusetts created a 35-foot buffer zone around entrances to clinics that provide abortions. Supporters said it protected patients from harassment; opponents, including people who wanted to counsel women quietly on the pavement, said it silenced them. In McCullen v. Coakley in 2014, the Supreme Court unanimously struck the law down, finding it restricted more speech than necessary. Other tradeoffs set privacy against security, such as limits on government surveillance of phone and email records.
Worked example: a legislator's tradeoff
A member of the House represents a coastal district where a company wants to drill for offshore oil. 1. Constituents who favour it: workers who expect jobs and lower energy prices. 2. Constituents who oppose it: people whose incomes depend on fishing and tourism, and residents worried about spills. 3. Party pressure: the member's party leaders may favour one side for national reasons. 4. Timing: House members face election every two years, so local opinion weighs heavily. 5. Likely result: a compromise, such as drilling farther offshore with stricter safety rules. 6. Check: no group gets everything, which is the tradeoffs view in miniature.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, treating elite theory as a conspiracy claim: Mills described shared backgrounds and positions, not a secret plot. Second, assuming pluralism means every group has equal influence; even pluralists accept that resources differ. Third, reading one study as final proof; the Gilens and Page findings are contested, and scholars still debate them. Fourth, thinking the theories are only about national politics: Dahl's study was of one city. Fifth, assuming a compromise means both sides were equally powerful; a deal can still lean heavily towards one party.
Key takeaways
Elite theory, associated with C. Wright Mills, argues that a small circle of business, military and political leaders holds real power. Pluralist theory, associated with Robert Dahl, argues that power is shared among competing groups using the system's many access points. Critics say pluralism overlooks unequal organisation and agenda control, while defenders of pluralism note that elites disagree and often share majority preferences. The tradeoffs perspective sees policy as continual compromise among competing values and interests, from state and national power to clashes between rights.
Flashcards
Flashcard
Political power is concentrated in a small group
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
Which statement best summarises pluralist theory?
Question 2 of 5
C. Wright Mills's book The Power Elite is the classic statement of which view?
Question 3 of 5
Bachrach and Baratz criticised pluralist studies for missing which form of power?
Question 4 of 5
A city gives a stadium a smaller subsidy than the owners wanted and adds a community benefits clause after residents organise. Which perspective does this outcome fit best?
Question 5 of 5
What did the 2014 study by Gilens and Page report?
