American Government › Section H · The media › Topic H.2

The evolution of the media

Every new way of spreading news, from the printing press to the smartphone, has changed who can speak to the public and how politicians reach voters. Tracing that history explains why today's media look the way they do.

New technology, new politics

The previous topic described today's media. This one shows how they developed. A pattern repeats through American history: a new technology lowers the cost of reaching people, a wider audience appears, politicians learn to use the new medium, and standards of journalism shift in response. Printing presses, the telegraph, radio, television, cable and the internet each followed that path. Each also raised the same worries that are heard today: that the new medium was too partisan, too sensational, or too easily used to manipulate the public.

Colonial papers and the party press

Publick Occurrences, printed in Boston in 1690, was shut down by colonial authorities after a single issue. The Boston News-Letter, begun in 1704, became the first continuously published colonial newspaper. In 1735 the New York printer John Peter Zenger was acquitted of seditious libel after his lawyer argued that printing the truth should not be a crime, an early landmark for press freedom. In the 1790s, newspapers became openly partisan. Alexander Hamilton's allies backed the Gazette of the United States, and Thomas Jefferson's supporters the National Gazette. Parties funded friendly printers, and in 1798 the Sedition Act made it a crime to publish false and malicious writing against the government.

The penny press and the wire

In 1833 Benjamin Day launched the New York Sun, sold for one cent. Steam-powered presses made printing cheap, and advertising rather than party money paid the bills, so papers sought the widest possible readership with crime stories and human interest. This penny press loosened the parties' grip on the news. The telegraph, demonstrated by Samuel Morse in 1844, let news travel instantly, and in 1846 New York papers formed the Associated Press to share the cost of gathering it. Historians argue that wire stories, sold to papers of every political stripe, encouraged a plainer, fact-centred style that later fed the ideal of objectivity.

Yellow journalism and the muckrakers

By the 1890s Joseph Pulitzer's New York World and William Randolph Hearst's New York Journal competed with screaming headlines, scandal and cartoons, a style called yellow journalism. Their coverage of Cuba inflamed opinion before the Spanish-American War of 1898, though historians debate how much it caused the war. In 1896 Adolph Ochs bought The New York Times and promoted sober, comprehensive reporting. In the Progressive Era, investigative writers exposed abuses: Ida Tarbell's history of Standard Oil and Upton Sinclair's 1906 novel The Jungle, about meatpacking, helped bring the Pure Food and Drug Act and the Meat Inspection Act. Theodore Roosevelt called such writers muckrakers in 1906.

Radio brings leaders into the home

On 2 November 1920 the Pittsburgh station KDKA broadcast the presidential election returns, often counted as the start of commercial radio. Within two decades most American homes had a set. Franklin Roosevelt mastered the medium: from March 1933 his fireside chats explained policies such as his response to the banking crisis in a calm, conversational tone, speaking to listeners directly rather than through newspaper editors. During the Second World War, the CBS correspondent Edward R. Murrow reported live from London under German bombing, making radio the fastest source of war news. Congress created the Federal Communications Commission in 1934, as the topic on regulating the media explains.

The television age

Television spread rapidly in the 1950s, and by the 1960s the evening newscasts of ABC, CBS and NBC were the main source of national news for most Americans. The first televised general-election presidential debates, between John F. Kennedy and Richard Nixon in 1960, showed that appearance and manner now mattered. Coverage of the Vietnam War brought combat into living rooms, and in February 1968 the CBS anchor Walter Cronkite told viewers he believed the war had reached a stalemate. Coverage of civil rights marches, including violence against protesters, also built national pressure for change. Three networks with similar formats meant most viewers saw much the same news.

Worked example: testing a famous claim

A popular story says radio listeners thought Nixon won the first 1960 debate while television viewers thought Kennedy did. 1. Identify the claim: image, not argument, decided the debate. 2. Find the evidence: the story rests mainly on a few small surveys taken at the time. 3. Judge the evidence: in 1987 the communication scholars David Vancil and Sue Pendell argued that these samples were small and unrepresentative, and that radio listeners may have differed from viewers, for example by living more often in rural areas where Nixon was stronger. 4. Weigh the alternative: other evidence still suggests television helped Kennedy look poised. 5. Conclusion: television mattered, but the neat radio-versus-TV split is weaker than it sounds.

Cable news and talk radio

Cable ended the era of three networks. CNN began 24-hour news in 1980, and both MSNBC and Fox News launched in 1996. With dozens of channels, outlets could narrowcast, aiming at a particular audience rather than everyone, and some built loyal followings with a distinct political viewpoint. Radio changed too. After the Federal Communications Commission abandoned its Fairness Doctrine in 1987, stations no longer had to present contrasting views on controversial issues, and Rush Limbaugh's nationally syndicated show, from 1988, led a wave of mainly conservative political talk radio. Audiences could now choose news that matched their politics.

The internet and social media

In the 1990s newspapers and networks moved online, and new outlets appeared. In 1998 the Drudge Report website broke the story that led to President Bill Clinton's impeachment, showing that a single online publisher could set the national agenda. Blogs, then platforms such as Facebook (2004), YouTube (2005) and Twitter, now X (2006), let anyone publish and let politicians speak to voters without journalists in between. Barack Obama's 2008 campaign used online organising and fundraising on a new scale, and Donald Trump used Twitter to drive news coverage. By 2024, candidates were also courting podcasters and online influencers with large young audiences.

Worked example: comparing two revolutions

Compare the penny press of the 1830s with social media today, cause and effect. 1. Technology: steam presses then, smartphones and platforms now, each cutting the cost of publishing. 2. Business model: advertising replaced party subsidies then; advertising tied to attention funds platforms now. 3. Audience: both reached people who had been left out of political news. 4. Content: both rewarded sensational stories that attract readers. 5. Response: the earlier era produced professional norms such as objectivity; today's debate concerns fact-checking, moderation and platform rules. 6. Conclusion: cheaper publishing widens participation but strains standards, and a new balance takes time.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, thinking a partisan press is new; American newspapers were openly partisan in the 1790s and much of the nineteenth century. Second, assuming objectivity was always the norm; it developed gradually, helped by wire services and professional journalism. Third, treating the radio-versus-TV story of 1960 as proven fact. Fourth, believing cable news began with Fox; CNN launched in 1980. Fifth, assuming each new medium wipes out the old; radio and newspapers survived television, though in changed forms.

Key takeaways

New technologies repeatedly lowered the cost of reaching the public and changed politics. The colonial press, the Zenger case and the partisan papers of the 1790s came first; the penny press (1833) and the Associated Press (1846) shifted papers towards advertising and plainer reporting. Yellow journalism and muckraking followed. Radio brought FDR's fireside chats from 1933; television brought the 1960 debates and Vietnam into homes. Cable (CNN 1980; Fox and MSNBC 1996), talk radio after 1987 and the internet expanded choice and partisanship.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Boston News-Letter, 1704

The first continuously published colonial newspaper

Publick Occurrences (1690) lasted one issue.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

What did the penny press of the 1830s change about American newspapers?

Question 2 of 5

Which pairing of a writer and an exposé is correct?

Question 3 of 5

Why did political talk radio expand after 1987?

Question 4 of 5

Why do scholars doubt the story that radio listeners thought Nixon won the first 1960 debate?

Question 5 of 5

What did the Drudge Report's 1998 scoop show about the internet?

← Previous topicNext topic →