American Government › Section N · State and local government › Topic N.4
State legislative term limits
In sixteen states, voters cannot keep re-electing a popular legislator without a break: after a set number of years, the law shows the member the door. This topic traces how term limits spread, how they work, and what researchers have found about their effects.
What term limits are
A term limit caps how long a person may hold an elected office. The best-known example is the presidency: since the Twenty-second Amendment (1951), no one may be elected president more than twice. Most governors face limits too. For state legislators, 16 states impose them, according to the National Conference of State Legislatures (NCSL). Members of Congress, by contrast, have no limits. In U.S. Term Limits, Inc. v. Thornton (1995), the Supreme Court ruled 5-4 that states may not add to the qualifications for Congress listed in the Constitution, so an Arkansas limit on its members of Congress was invalid. Only a constitutional amendment could impose congressional limits.
A movement of the 1990s
Term limits for state legislators began in 1990, when voters in California, Colorado and Oklahoma approved them through citizen initiatives, which let voters put a law or constitutional amendment on the ballot by petition. A large wave followed in 1992, when limits passed in many more states, including Arizona, Florida, Michigan, Missouri, Montana, Ohio and South Dakota. Most adoptions came by initiative rather than by legislators limiting themselves. In all, 22 states adopted legislative limits. Nebraska added them in 2000, and after a long pause North Dakota voters approved them in 2022, making it the most recent state to do so.
Repeals and court rulings
Six of those 22 states no longer have limits. In two, the legislature itself repealed them: Idaho in 2002 and Utah in 2003. In four, the state supreme court struck them down: Massachusetts in 1997, Washington in 1998, Oregon in 2002 and Wyoming in 2004. In Massachusetts, Washington and Wyoming the limits had been passed as ordinary statutes, and the courts held that changing the qualifications for office required a constitutional amendment. In Oregon, the court found that the 1992 initiative broke the state's rule that separate constitutional changes must be put to voters as separate questions. That leaves 16 term-limited states.
Consecutive and lifetime limits
Limits come in two main types. Under a consecutive limit, a member may serve only a set number of years in a row in a chamber, most commonly eight. After reaching the limit, the member must sit out, usually for a term or more, and can then run again, starting the count afresh. Colorado, Florida and Ohio use eight-year consecutive limits for each chamber. Under a lifetime limit, once the years are used up the member can never serve in that body again. Oklahoma and California allow 12 years in total, in either or both chambers, while Missouri and North Dakota allow eight years in each chamber for life.
Worked example: a career under consecutive limits
Follow a legislator in a state with eight-year consecutive limits in each chamber and two-year house terms. 1. She wins a house seat in 2010 and is re-elected three times, serving 2011 to 2018: four terms, eight years, so she is now term-limited in the house. 2. She runs for an open senate seat in 2018 and serves two four-year terms, to 2026. 3. She is now limited in the senate too. 4. She sits out, then wins the house seat again in 2028, and her eight-year house count restarts. 5. Compare a lifetime limit of eight years per chamber: after step 3 she could never return. 6. Conclusion: consecutive limits force breaks; lifetime limits end legislative careers.
Adjusting the limits
Several states have kept limits but changed their length, usually to allow longer service in one chamber. California's Proposition 28 (2012) replaced six years in the assembly plus eight in the senate with a 12-year total in either chamber. Michigan's Proposal 1 (2022) made the same kind of change, replacing six house years and eight senate years with 12 years in total. Arkansas has also lengthened its limits since 1992. Not every attempt succeeds: Nebraska voters rejected a move from two consecutive four-year terms to three in 2012, by about 65% to 35%.
Worked example: Michigan before and after 2022
Compare the longest possible service for a Michigan legislator under each rule. 1. Old rule: three two-year house terms (6 years) plus two four-year senate terms (8 years), for life. 2. Maximum total: 6 + 8 = 14 years, but no more than 6 in the house. 3. New rule: 12 years in total, in either chamber or both. 4. Maximum total: 12 years, two fewer than before. 5. Maximum in the house: 12 years, six more than before, so a member can now stay long enough to build expertise and seniority there. 6. Conclusion: the change slightly shortened total careers but lengthened service in a single chamber, which supporters said would strengthen experience and opponents said weakened the limits.
The case for term limits
Supporters made several arguments. Limits would bring new people and fresh ideas into legislatures and end careers built on staying in office. Members who cannot run forever might spend less time fundraising and campaigning and more time making good policy. Limits would also open seats regularly, since incumbents usually win when they run, and supporters hoped this would draw more women, members of minority groups and people from varied occupations into politics, increase competition and let newer members rise to leadership. Polls have long shown broad public support for term limits, across both parties.
What research has found
Political scientists have studied term-limited states for three decades. Limits did raise turnover: seats open on schedule. But studies comparing limited and unlimited states found no significant rise in the share of women or minority legislators, partly because women and minority incumbents are forced out too. Members arrive with less experience and leave before mastering complex subjects such as budgets, and legislative leaders serve shorter spells. Several studies, including work by Thad Kousser, found that power shifted towards governors and agency officials, and that newer members leaned more on staff and lobbyists for information. Supporters reply that these costs are worth paying to prevent entrenched careers.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, term limits do not apply to Congress: U.S. Term Limits, Inc. v. Thornton (1995) blocked states from imposing them. Second, a consecutive limit is not a lifetime ban; the member may return after a break. Third, the six repeals did not all happen the same way: two legislatures repealed limits and four state supreme courts struck them down. Fourth, research has not found that term limits significantly increased the number of women or minority legislators. Fifth, the most common limit is eight years per chamber, not eight years in total.
Key takeaways
Term limits cap service in office. Starting with California, Colorado and Oklahoma in 1990, 22 states adopted legislative limits, mostly by citizen initiative; six later lost them, by legislative repeal (Idaho, Utah) or court ruling (Massachusetts, Washington, Oregon, Wyoming), leaving 16, with North Dakota the latest in 2022. Limits are consecutive or lifetime, most often eight years per chamber, and states such as California and Michigan have moved to 12-year totals. Supporters seek fresh faces and less careerism; research finds more turnover but no significant gain in diversity, less experience and more power for governors, agencies and lobbyists.
Flashcards
Flashcard
A cap on how long a person may hold an elected office
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
Why can no state impose term limits on its members of Congress?
Question 2 of 5
In a state with an eight-year consecutive limit in the house, a member has served eight years in a row there. What may she do?
Question 3 of 5
How did the six states that no longer have legislative term limits lose them?
Question 4 of 5
Under Michigan's 2022 change, what is the longest a legislator may now serve in the state house?
Question 5 of 5
Supporters hoped term limits would bring more women and minority members into legislatures. What has research found?
