American Government › Section O · The bureaucracy › Topic O.2

Toward a merit-based civil service

For half a century, losing an election could cost a federal clerk a job. A president's murder helped change that. This topic follows the shift from patronage to merit, and the continuing argument over how far career officials should be shielded from the politicians they serve.

A shot in a railway station

On 2 July 1881, four months into his presidency, James Garfield was shot in a Washington railway station by Charles Guiteau, a disappointed office seeker who thought his campaign support had earned him a diplomatic post. Garfield died in September. The murder dramatised what reformers had long argued: the spoils system, described in the topic "Bureaucracy and public administration", filled government with people chosen for loyalty rather than ability. Reformers demanded that federal jobs be awarded by merit: competence shown in fair, open competition.

The Pendleton Act of 1883

In January 1883 President Chester Arthur, himself once a beneficiary of patronage, signed the Pendleton Civil Service Reform Act. It had three key parts. First, covered jobs would be filled through open, competitive examinations testing ability for the work. Second, covered employees could not be fired or demoted for political reasons, including refusing to give money to a party. Third, it created a three-member Civil Service Commission, with no more than two members from one party, to run the system. At first it covered only about a tenth of federal jobs, but it let presidents extend coverage by order, and they did, so that most federal jobs were under the merit system within a few decades.

Worked example: why reform passed in 1883

Analyse the causes of the Pendleton Act as a chain. 1. Long-term cause: scandals and inefficiency under the spoils system, notably in the 1870s, built a reform movement among journalists and professionals. 2. Trigger: Garfield's assassination in 1881 made patronage look deadly as well as corrupt. 3. Political pressure: in the 1882 midterm elections Republicans, seen as the party of patronage, lost heavily in the House. 4. Self-interest: outgoing officeholders wanted to protect their appointees from the next party in power. 5. Result: Congress passed the act with support from both parties. 6. Lesson: reform needed an idea, a shock and politicians' self-interest.

Keeping politics out

Later laws widened the separation between civil servants and party politics. The Lloyd-La Follette Act (1912) protected employees' right to petition Congress and to join organisations, such as unions, that did not strike. The Hatch Act (1939) barred federal employees from using their authority to influence elections, from soliciting political donations and from active campaigning; a 1993 amendment allowed more political activity off duty, though not on the job. Federal employees may not strike, and when about 11,000 air traffic controllers did so in 1981, President Reagan dismissed them. Collective bargaining for federal unions began under an executive order of President Kennedy in 1962.

The Civil Service Reform Act of 1978

By the 1970s, many believed the merit system had become slow and rigid. President Jimmy Carter's Civil Service Reform Act of 1978 abolished the Civil Service Commission and split its work. The Office of Personnel Management (OPM) runs federal human resources: hiring rules, pay and benefits. The Merit Systems Protection Board (MSPB) hears employees' appeals against firings and other serious actions and protects merit principles. The Federal Labor Relations Authority oversees relations with unions. The act also created the Senior Executive Service and protections for whistleblowers.

Three kinds of federal job

Most civilian federal jobs fall into three groups. The competitive service, the largest, follows OPM's full merit rules: jobs are advertised publicly, applicants are ranked on their qualifications and the best qualified are hired. The excepted service is exempt from some of those rules, because an agency such as the FBI or the CIA runs its own hiring system, or because jobs such as attorneys are hard to fill through standard procedures. The Senior Executive Service covers top career managers just below political appointees, chosen for leadership skills. Above them sit roughly 4,000 political appointees, who serve at the president's pleasure.

How merit hiring works

Federal jobs are advertised on USAJOBS, a website run by OPM. Each announcement lists the duties and the qualifications needed, often as knowledge, skills and abilities. Applicants are assessed on education, experience and, for some jobs, tests: candidates for the Foreign Service take a written exam, and air traffic controllers must pass an aptitude test. Under the Veterans' Preference Act of 1944 and later laws, eligible military veterans receive extra credit in competitive hiring, so a preference can lift a veteran above other qualified candidates. The goal throughout is that the person hired is the best qualified, not the best connected.

The General Schedule

Most white-collar civil servants are paid on the General Schedule (GS), a pay table with 15 grades, set by the difficulty and responsibility of the job, and 10 steps within each grade. New employees usually start at step 1 of their grade. With acceptable performance, they move up a step after one year at each of steps 1 to 3, after two years at each of steps 4 to 6 and after three years at each of steps 7 to 9. Promotion to a higher grade brings larger rises. In 2026, after a 1% increase, base pay ran from $22,584 at GS-1 step 1 to $164,301 at GS-15 step 10, before extra locality pay for high-cost areas.

Worked example: a GS-7 career

Take a new analyst hired at GS-7 in 2026 and assume no promotion and no new pay increases. 1. Starting pay at step 1: $43,106. 2. Top of the grade at step 10: $56,039. 3. Difference: $56,039 minus $43,106 is $12,933. 4. As a percentage: $12,933 ÷ $43,106 is about 30%. 5. Time to reach step 10: three one-year waits (steps 1 to 4), three two-year waits (steps 4 to 7) and three three-year waits (steps 7 to 10), 3 + 6 + 9 = 18 years. 6. Conclusion: steps reward long service, but most pay growth in a federal career comes from promotion to higher grades.

Merit's trade-offs today

Merit produces experienced specialists who serve the law, not a party; critics say its protections shield poor performers and let career staff resist elected leaders. In 2020 President Trump created Schedule F for policy-influencing career jobs, removing many firing protections; President Biden revoked it in 2021. In 2025 Trump restored the idea, and in 2026 OPM finalised a rule for a category called Schedule Policy/Career, which it estimated could cover about 50,000 positions. Supporters say it makes the bureaucracy answer to voters; critics say it reopens the door to patronage. Lawsuits followed.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, the Pendleton Act did not create a merit system for every federal job at once; it covered about a tenth at first. Second, the Civil Service Commission no longer exists: the 1978 act replaced it with OPM and the MSPB. Third, the Hatch Act limits partisan activity by federal employees; it does not stop them voting or holding private political views. Fourth, the excepted service is not exempt from merit; it is exempt from some standard competitive hiring procedures. Fifth, on the General Schedule, grades reflect the job's level and steps reflect time and performance within it.

Key takeaways

Garfield's assassination in 1881 helped pass the Pendleton Act of 1883, which introduced competitive exams, banned political firings and created a bipartisan Civil Service Commission; coverage grew from about 10% of jobs. The Hatch Act (1939) limits partisan activity, and the 1978 reform act replaced the commission with OPM, the MSPB and the FLRA. Jobs fall into the competitive service, the excepted service and the Senior Executive Service, with about 4,000 political appointees above. Pay follows the General Schedule's 15 grades and 10 steps. Schedule F and Schedule Policy/Career renewed the debate over protection versus responsiveness.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Merit system

Filling government jobs by demonstrated competence in open competition

The opposite of patronage.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

Which was a provision of the Pendleton Act of 1883?

Question 2 of 5

What did the Civil Service Reform Act of 1978 do?

Question 3 of 5

On the 2026 General Schedule, GS-5 step 1 paid $34,799 and step 10 paid $45,239. By about what percentage does pay rise across the grade?

Question 4 of 5

A federal scientist campaigns for a candidate at a weekend rally, but never at work or using an official title. Which law sets the limits on such activity?

Question 5 of 5

What is the main argument made by supporters of Schedule F and Schedule Policy/Career?

← Previous topicNext topic →