American Government › Section J · Interest groups and lobbying › Topic J.4
Pathways of interest group influence
Interest groups work on every part of government: they help choose who holds office, then lobby legislators, agencies and courts once officials are in place. Following each pathway shows where groups have leverage, and why their real influence is so hard to measure.
Two arenas of influence
Groups try to shape policy in two arenas. In elections, they help candidates who agree with them, hoping for a sympathetic hearing once those candidates take office. In governing, they lobby the officials who write, carry out and interpret the law: Congress and state legislatures, executive agencies and the courts. The scale is large. Disclosure reports filed under federal law, compiled by research groups such as OpenSecrets, show reported federal lobbying spending running to several billion dollars a year, by many thousands of registered lobbyists. Those totals cover only federal lobbying that must be reported, not state lobbying or campaign spending.
Influence in elections
Many groups endorse candidates and publish scorecards rating legislators on votes the group cares about. Groups on the left and the right, on guns, the environment, taxes, labour and business, all issue ratings, which give their members a quick guide at election time. Groups often back incumbents, because incumbents usually win and access to the likely winner is valuable. Some groups support challengers when an incumbent looks vulnerable or hostile, and some hedge by giving to both major candidates in the same race. Groups also mobilise members to volunteer, contact voters and turn out, which can matter as much as money.
PACs and super PACs
A political action committee, or PAC, is an organisation that collects voluntary contributions and gives them to candidates and parties. Corporations and unions cannot give to federal candidates from their own treasuries, but they can sponsor PACs funded by employees or members. A multicandidate PAC may give up to $5,000 per candidate per election and $15,000 a year to a national party committee, and an individual may give a PAC up to $5,000 a year. Super PACs, which emerged after court rulings in 2010, may raise unlimited sums from individuals, corporations and unions, but they may only spend independently and must not coordinate with candidates. The next topic examines the rules.
Worked example: where a PAC gives
A trade association's PAC has $200,000 to give in House races. Trace its likely choices. 1. Committee members first: legislators on the committees that oversee the industry matter most, so they get priority. 2. Incumbents: most incumbents win re-election, so giving to them buys access to likely winners. 3. Allies: members who already vote the industry's way are rewarded to keep them supportive. 4. Hedging: in a close open-seat race, the PAC may give to both candidates. 5. Conclusion: the money follows access and existing agreement more than an attempt to change minds, which is why simple links between donations and votes are misleading.
Lobbying the legislature
Legislators are generalists who vote on hundreds of issues, so they and their staff rely on lobbyists for technical detail, information about other members' positions and the likely reaction back home. These voting cues are a main source of influence. Groups also supply ideas and draft language; at the state level, groups across the political spectrum circulate model bills that legislators can introduce. Lobbyists target carefully. They start with possible sponsors, then members of the relevant committees, since other members often defer to committee experts, and then the floor. Groups also work on the budget, seeking more money for programmes they favour, and they fight to defeat bills that would hurt them.
Lobbying the executive branch
Passing a law is only the start. Agencies write detailed regulations to carry it out, and under the Administrative Procedure Act of 1946 most proposed rules are published in the Federal Register for public comment before they become final. Groups file detailed comments, meet agency staff and sometimes sue to block a rule. They also lobby the president and the Senate over appointments to agencies and boards. The revolving door, the movement of people between government jobs and lobbying or industry posts, gives groups expertise and contacts. Critics link it to the regulatory capture described in the Microeconomics topic Special interest politics; defenders say it brings real knowledge into government.
Lobbying the courts
Courts make policy when they interpret statutes and the Constitution, so groups lobby them too, within strict limits. They can sponsor test cases, choosing plaintiffs and facts to bring an issue before judges; the NAACP Legal Defense Fund's work leading to Brown v. Board of Education in 1954 is a classic example. They file amicus curiae, or friend of the court, briefs offering arguments and evidence. In Obergefell v. Hodges in 2015, which required states to license and recognise same-sex marriages, groups on both sides filed a large number of briefs. And groups campaign over judicial nominations, urging senators to confirm or reject a president's choices.
Worked example: one bill, every branch
Follow a coalition of hospitals pursuing higher payments for rural care. 1. Elections: its PAC supports members of the health committees in both parties. 2. Agenda: lobbyists bring a member data on rural hospital closures and draft bill language. 3. Committee and floor: they brief committee staff, testify at a hearing and supply cues to other members before the vote. 4. Agency: after the law passes, they file comments on the agency's proposed rule setting payment formulas. 5. Courts: if a rule cuts payments, they may sue or file an amicus brief. 6. Conclusion: influence is spread over many stages, and losing at one can be recovered at another.
Why influence is hard to measure
It is tempting to see a donation followed by a friendly vote as proof that money bought the vote. The problem is that groups mostly support officials who already agree with them, so the vote might have been the same without the money. What contributions and lobbying most clearly buy is access: time with officials and their staff to make a case. Researchers try to compare what happens with and without group activity, but real politics rarely offers a clean experiment. Studies find that influence is greatest on narrow, technical and low-visibility issues and weakest on high-profile questions where voters are watching.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, assuming money directly buys votes; groups mostly give to allies, and what is clearest is access. Second, forgetting the executive branch and courts; much influence comes through rulemaking, lawsuits and amicus briefs. Third, confusing PACs with super PACs: PACs give limited amounts to candidates, while super PACs raise unlimited sums but may not coordinate with campaigns. Fourth, treating the yearly lobbying totals as all political spending; it is reported federal lobbying only. Fifth, assuming groups lobby every legislator; they target sponsors and committee members.
Key takeaways
Groups influence elections through endorsements, scorecards, mobilisation and money, often favouring incumbents and committee members. PACs give limited contributions, such as $5,000 per candidate per election; super PACs spend unlimited sums independently. In government, lobbyists supply information and voting cues to legislators, target sponsors and committees, comment on agency rules, move through the revolving door, and use test cases, amicus briefs and nomination campaigns in the courts. Reported federal lobbying runs to several billion dollars a year. Influence is real but hard to measure, because groups mainly back allies and buy access, with most effect on low-visibility issues.
Flashcards
Flashcard
Elections and governing
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
Why do political scientists say it is hard to prove that contributions buy legislators' votes?
Question 2 of 5
Which statement correctly contrasts an ordinary PAC with a super PAC?
Question 3 of 5
An industry group files detailed objections to a proposed rule published in the Federal Register. Which pathway is it using?
Question 4 of 5
A civil rights organisation picks plaintiffs and facts carefully to bring a constitutional challenge before the courts. What is this tactic called?
Question 5 of 5
On which kind of issue do studies find interest group influence tends to be greatest?
