Anthropology › Section O · Anthropology of media › Topic O.7
Broadcasting modernity and national identity
Governments and development agencies have long used radio and television to teach, unite and modernise their citizens. Anthropologists study what these broadcasts were meant to do, and what audiences actually did with them.
Broadcasting from the top down
Community stations are one face of broadcasting. Another is top-down: radio and television produced by governments or development organisations to reach particular goals, such as literacy, health, national unity or loyalty to the state. Here programme-makers decide what audiences need to hear. This topic follows that model through schools on the air, national television, soap operas and religious drama. Throughout, anthropologists ask the same two questions they ask of any media: what were the producers trying to achieve, and how did the people watching and listening respond in the settings where they actually lived?
Lessons by radio
Radio can teach children who live far from schools or teachers. A method called interactive radio instruction began with a mathematics project in Nicaragua in the mid-1970s, supported by the US Agency for International Development (USAID). Broadcast lessons paused so children could answer aloud, while a classroom helper guided them. In the 1980s a USAID-funded project in the Dominican Republic brought radio lessons in reading, mathematics and other subjects to children in isolated mountain areas, who gathered at community learning centres with printed worksheets. Over time, local groups and the national government helped fund it, and similar programmes spread to other countries.
Broadcasting the new nation
In most countries outside western Europe and the United States, radio and television were first built by the state, partly because local business lacked the capital to start stations. After independence, many African governments of the 1960s used national broadcasting corporations to address diverse, scattered populations as one national audience; Ghana, for example, launched its national television service in 1965. Programmes carried speeches, national news, music and drama designed to build a shared identity across ethnic and regional lines. As the topic News media, the public sphere, and nationalism showed, such media help people imagine themselves as members of one nation.
Worked example: folktales on Ghanaian television
The communication scholar Carla Heath (1996) analysed Ghanaian children's television, including a programme called By the Fireside. 1. Format: schoolchildren in African-print clothing sang, danced and exchanged riddles with adult storytellers against a painted village backdrop. 2. Content: the children acted out folktales and then discussed their morals. 3. Link to the present: the lessons were applied to contemporary problems, such as corruption, conflict and juvenile delinquency. 4. Mix: an old oral form was carried by a modern medium, in a studio, for a national audience. 5. Conclusion: Heath argues such programmes promoted a modern citizenship rooted in local moral traditions rather than one copied from the West.
Soap operas with a purpose
Serial dramas reach huge audiences, which makes them attractive tools for social goals. In Mexico in the 1970s the producer Miguel Sabido created telenovelas, such as Ven conmigo (1975), that wove messages about adult literacy and family planning into melodrama. This entertainment-education approach spread widely. South Africa's Soul City, launched in 1994, used television and radio drama to address health issues, including HIV. Such programmes assume viewers learn by identifying with characters who change. Anthropologists caution that viewers do not always identify with the characters producers intend, and that their responses depend on gender, class, age and personal circumstances.
Television drama in Egypt
The anthropologist Lila Abu-Lughod studied Egyptian television serials, gathering her research in Dramas of Nationhood (2005). Egypt's educated elites, who wrote and produced much state television, saw drama as a means of uplift: cultivating virtuous, modern citizens among women, young people and rural viewers. One popular serial, Hilmiyya Nights, which began in the late 1980s, followed residents of an old Cairo neighbourhood from the 1940s, under King Farouk, to about 1990. Unlike many American soap operas, centred on private romance, its characters' lives were bound up with national events. Characters who strayed after money, sex or power usually learned to put the nation first.
Worked example: what viewers took from Hilmiyya Nights
Abu-Lughod asked how women actually watched the serial, interviewing women she knew in Cairo and in a village in Upper Egypt. 1. Intended message: national unity and responsible citizenship. 2. Observation: many women loved the show but said little about its lessons on citizenship. 3. Identification: some were drawn to the scheming female characters who pursued money and pleasure, rather than to the virtuous ones. 4. Context: their responses reflected their own lives, including poverty, family pressures and limited choices. 5. Conclusion: the producers' project of uplift reached viewers only partly; audiences took pleasure and meaning on their own terms, which is why reception must be studied directly.
Epic serials in India
The anthropologist Purnima Mankekar, in Screening Culture, Viewing Politics (1999), studied serials on India's state broadcaster, Doordarshan, analysing production, texts and, above all, reception among middle-class women in Delhi. She argues that state television promoted an ideal of Indian womanhood implicitly coded as Hindu, north Indian, middle-class and upper-caste. Two enormously popular serials were the Ramayan (1987 to 1988) and the Mahabharat (1988 to 1990), based on Hindu epics. Viewers discussed Sita, the devoted, self-sacrificing wife, and Draupadi, publicly humiliated after her husband's loss at dice and furious at the injustice, relating each to their own lives. Airing amid rising Hindu nationalism, the serials also became part of nationalist politics.
Religious modernities on screen
In Western thought modernity is often equated with secularism, but broadcasting frequently carries religion into modern forms. The anthropologist Katrien Pype (2012) studied Pentecostal television melodramas in Kinshasa, Democratic Republic of the Congo. Their plots often feature witchcraft and deliverance by a pastor, framed as part of a spiritual battle between God and the devil. Some viewers reported feeling the drama's spiritual forces in their own bodies and treated these reactions as meaningful. In Cairo, Charles Hirschkind (2006) showed how listening to recorded Islamic sermons on cassette helped people cultivate piety and ethical sensibilities in daily life.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, assuming top-down broadcasts work as intended: audiences often take different meanings and pleasures from them. Second, treating national broadcasting as neutral, when it often promotes one version of the nation, such as a Hindu, middle-class ideal. Third, equating modernity with secularism, when media also carry modern religious experience. Fourth, dismissing soap operas as trivial entertainment; they are major arenas for debating gender, morality and citizenship. Fifth, assuming tradition and modernity cannot mix, when folktales on television show them combined.
Key takeaways
Governments and development agencies use broadcasting from the top down, from interactive radio instruction (Nicaragua, mid-1970s; Dominican Republic, 1980s) to national television in newly independent states. Heath (1996) showed Ghanaian children's television rooting modern citizenship in folktales. Entertainment-education, from Sabido's telenovelas to Soul City, uses drama for social goals. Abu-Lughod found Egyptian women enjoying Hilmiyya Nights on their own terms, and Mankekar showed Indian epic serials shaping ideals of womanhood and nationalist politics. Pype and Hirschkind show broadcasting and recordings carrying modern religious experience.
Flashcards
Flashcard
Radio and television made by states or agencies to reach set goals
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
What distinguishes top-down broadcasting from community radio?
Question 2 of 5
According to Carla Heath, what did Ghanaian children's programmes such as By the Fireside promote?
Question 3 of 5
What did Lila Abu-Lughod find when she asked women how they watched Hilmiyya Nights?
Question 4 of 5
In Mankekar's analysis, what ideal of womanhood did Indian state television implicitly promote?
Question 5 of 5
What does Katrien Pype's research in Kinshasa challenge?
