Anthropology › Section C · The culture concept › Topic C.2

Culture as shared meaning

A twitch of the eyelid and a deliberate wink can look identical, yet one is biology and the other is a message. Culture lives in that difference: in the meanings people learn and share about what they and others do.

Twitch or wink?

Imagine two people whose right eyelids close quickly at the same moment. For one it is an involuntary twitch. For the other it is a wink, a signal to a friend that a joke is under way. A camera could not tell them apart, yet the difference matters enormously to anyone watching. The philosopher Gilbert Ryle used this puzzle, and the American anthropologist Clifford Geertz made it famous in his book The Interpretation of Cultures (1973). The wink carries meaning only because people have learned a shared code. Geertz argued that this web of shared meaning is what culture is.

Tylor's classic definition

The British anthropologist Edward Burnett Tylor offered the first widely used definition in Primitive Culture (1871): culture is "that complex whole which includes knowledge, belief, art, morals, law, custom, and any other capabilities and habits acquired by man as a member of society." Two parts of it still matter. "Complex whole" stresses that the pieces fit together. "Acquired" stresses that culture is learned. Tylor's "man" reflects the usage of his time, and his ranking of societies from lower to higher is rejected today, as Modes of cultural analysis explains.

Learned, not inborn

Anthropologists separate innate behaviour, which people are born able to do, from acquired behaviour, which they must learn. Blinking, sneezing, feeling hunger and falling asleep are innate. Winking, saying "bless you" after a sneeze, eating at set mealtimes and sleeping on a mattress rather than a mat are acquired. Culture is the acquired side, passed from older to younger members of a group rather than through genes. This process of learning one's culture is called enculturation. A baby adopted at birth into a family on another continent grows up with that family's language, tastes and habits, not those of its birth parents.

Two routes of enculturation

Some culture is taught on purpose. Schools teach spelling and arithmetic, religious communities teach prayers and moral rules, and coaches teach the rules of a sport. Far more is picked up without anyone planning to teach it. Children notice how adults lower their voices in a place of worship, how far apart people stand in a queue, and which jokes are allowed at the dinner table. They copy, get corrected, and copy again. By adulthood most people follow thousands of such unspoken rules that they could not easily list.

Meaning must be shared

A private gesture that only you understand is not yet culture. A wink works because both people know what a wink means, and that knowledge is public, held in common by a group. Geertz stressed that culture is public in this sense: meanings exist between people, not just inside individual heads. Sharing is never perfect. Individuals interpret signs differently, and a wink on a date may mean something other than a wink in a business meeting. Shared meaning is what makes social life readable, even when people disagree about what something means.

Symbols and their arbitrary meanings

A symbol is anything, such as a word, colour, gesture or object, whose meaning is set by convention rather than by nature. Because the link is arbitrary, it has to be learned and can differ between groups. White has long been worn by brides in much of Europe and the Americas, while in parts of East and South Asia it has traditionally been a colour of mourning. A thumbs-up signals approval in the United States but has been an insult in parts of West Africa and the Middle East. The capacity to create and read symbols underlies language, art, law and religion.

Culture shapes biology

Even bodily needs are met in cultural ways. All humans must eat, but culture decides what counts as food: grasshoppers are a prized snack in parts of Mexico and Uganda but are rarely eaten in Britain. All humans must sleep, but in much of the world infants sleep beside their mothers, while giving a baby its own room is common mainly in some Western countries and is unusual in world terms. Culture also shapes the body itself, through diet, posture, tattooing and exercise. Anthropologists call this interweaving of biology and culture a biocultural process.

Worked example: thick description

Geertz called rich interpretation of meaning thick description. Describe one eyelid movement thinly and thickly. 1. Thin: the right eyelid closed briefly. 2. Twitch: no message, no audience. 3. Wink: a deliberate signal to a chosen person that something is a secret or a joke. 4. Parody: a third person exaggerates the wink to mock the winker, a message about a message. 5. Rehearsal: someone practises a parody in a mirror. 6. Check: the physical act is the same each time; only the shared meanings differ, and an observer must learn them to understand what is happening.

Worked example: is it culture?

Sort the parts of an ordinary evening. 1. Feeling hungry: innate, a biological signal. 2. Eating rice with chopsticks, a fork or the right hand: acquired, learned by watching family. 3. Waiting for the eldest person to start eating: acquired and shared, a rule about respect. 4. Yawning: innate. 5. Saying you are tired so guests take the hint and leave: acquired, a learned meaning others must recognise. 6. Check: ask two questions of each item, whether it had to be learned and whether others share its meaning. If both answers are yes, it is culture.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, calling every human behaviour cultural: blinking and hunger are innate, though culture shapes how people respond to them. Second, forgetting the sharing test: a private habit is not culture until others recognise its meaning. Third, assuming symbols have natural meanings, when their meanings are set by convention. Fourth, treating Tylor's 1871 definition as wholly current: its "complex whole" endures, but its evolutionary ranking does not. Fifth, thinking enculturation happens only in school, when most culture is absorbed unplanned.

Key takeaways

Culture is learned and shared meaning: a wink differs from a twitch only because people share a code, as Ryle and Geertz (1973) showed. Tylor (1871) defined culture as a complex whole acquired as a member of society. Innate behaviour is biological; acquired behaviour, passed on by enculturation, is cultural. Enculturation is partly deliberate but mostly unplanned. Symbols have arbitrary, learned meanings. Culture shapes how biological needs such as eating and sleeping are met. Thick description interprets actions through their shared meanings.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Twitch versus wink

The same movement, one involuntary, one a shared signal

Ryle's puzzle, made famous by Geertz (1973).

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

A wink and an involuntary twitch can look physically identical. According to Geertz, what makes the wink cultural?

Question 2 of 5

Which of these is an innate behaviour rather than an acquired one?

Question 3 of 5

Which part of Tylor's 1871 definition do anthropologists still find most useful?

Question 4 of 5

A child learns, without anyone explaining it, to lower her voice inside a place of worship. This is an example of:

Question 5 of 5

White is worn by brides in much of Europe but has traditionally marked mourning in parts of East Asia. What does this show about symbols?

← Previous topicNext topic →