Anthropology › Section K · Kinship and family › Topic K.3

Reckoning kinship and descent across cultures

Societies differ in how they name relatives and in which ancestors define a person's group. Those two choices, kinship terminology and descent, decide whom people call brother, whom they may marry, and who inherits land, names and titles.

Two questions of reckoning

Kinship reckoning means the way a society maps ego's relatives. It involves two linked questions. The first is terminology: which relatives share a kin term, and which are distinguished? The second is descent: through which parent, or both, does a person trace membership in a group across generations? Following Lewis Henry Morgan, anthropologists group terminologies into a few recurring types. The labels long used for them came from particular peoples, some by outsiders' names, so this course uses the descriptive names and mentions the older labels once.

Lineal terminology

Lineal terminology, formerly labelled "Eskimo" (an outsider's name many Inuit and Yupik people reject), marks off the nuclear family. Mother, father, sister and brother each have their own term, while relatives outside it are lumped: the parents' siblings are all "aunt" or "uncle", and all their children are "cousin", whichever parent links them. English uses this system, as do many Inuit communities. It usually goes with bilateral descent and with societies where nuclear families often live and move on their own, so that obligations beyond the nuclear family are relatively light.

Bifurcate merging terminology

Bifurcate merging terminology, formerly labelled "Iroquois" after the Haudenosaunee, splits (bifurcates) the parents' siblings by sex and merges some with the parents. Ego calls the father's brother by the same term as the father, and the mother's sister by the same term as the mother, while the father's sister and the mother's brother receive distinct terms. Their children follow: parallel cousins, the children of a parent's same-sex sibling, are called brother and sister, while cross cousins, the children of a parent's opposite-sex sibling, get a separate term. This system is widespread and often goes with unilineal descent.

Generational and other systems

Generational terminology, formerly labelled "Hawaiian", distinguishes relatives only by generation and gender. Every relative in ego's generation is a brother or sister, and every relative in the parents' generation is a mother or father. It was widespread in Polynesia, where it supported large, flexible kin groups. Anthropologists also recognise three further types. Sudanese systems are highly descriptive, with separate terms for almost every relative. Omaha systems, found with patrilineal descent, and Crow systems, their matrilineal mirror image, use one term for relatives of different generations within a descent line.

Worked example: cousins, genes and categories

Ego's father's brother's daughter (FBD) and mother's brother's daughter (MBD) are both first cousins. Compare them genetically and socially. 1. Genetics: a first cousin shares a pair of grandparents with ego, giving a coefficient of relationship of \(2 \times (\tfrac{1}{2})^4 = \tfrac{1}{8}\) for both. 2. Terms: under bifurcate merging, FBD is a parallel cousin, called "sister"; MBD is a cross cousin. 3. Descent: in a patrilineal society, FBD belongs to ego's own patrilineage, while MBD belongs to her father's, which is ego's mother's patrilineage, a different group. 4. Marriage: many such societies forbid marriage with parallel cousins and permit or prefer it with cross cousins. 5. Conclusion: identical genetic relatedness, different social categories.

Unilineal descent and descent groups

Unilineal descent traces membership through one line only. In patrilineal, or agnatic, descent, children of both sexes belong to their father's group, but only sons pass membership on. In matrilineal, or uterine, descent, children belong to their mother's group and only daughters pass it on. Patrilineal descent is the more common worldwide, as in many traditional Chinese lineages. A lineage is a descent group whose members can trace their actual links to a known ancestor. A clan claims descent from a common ancestor, sometimes mythical, without tracing every step. Where a whole society divides into two such halves, each is a moiety.

Matrilineal societies

Matrilineal descent does not mean that women rule; that would be matriarchy, a different idea taken up in The power of gender: patriarchy and matriarchy. Often a mother's brother holds authority over his sister's children, a relationship called the avunculate. Matrilineal peoples include the Akan of Ghana, the Minangkabau of West Sumatra, Indonesia, where ancestral houses and land pass through women while men hold lineage titles, and the Diné (Navajo), who traditionally introduce themselves through their mother's clan first. The anthropologist William Adams found in 1983 that Diné families often lived near either spouse's relatives or on their own: rules set ideals and possibilities, not fixed practice.

Cognatic descent

Cognatic descent traces kinship through both men and women. In bilateral descent, common in Europe, North America and much of Southeast Asia, people reckon relatives equally through both parents. There is no lasting descent group; instead each person has a kindred, an ego-centred network of relatives on both sides, which is unique to them and shared fully only with full siblings. In ambilineal descent, people may join a group through either parent, often choosing the line that offers better land or support, and children follow that choice. Ambilineal groups have been documented in parts of Polynesia.

Segmentary lineages

In some societies without a central government, lineages nest inside larger lineages, which nest inside clans. E. E. Evans-Pritchard, in The Nuer (1940), described how groups of the Nuer (who call themselves Naath) of South Sudan that quarrelled at one level could unite at a higher level against outsiders: brothers against cousins, but brothers and cousins together against a more distant lineage. Such segmentary lineage systems can organise defence and dispute settlement without rulers, as Bands and tribes explores. Later anthropologists, including Sharon Hutchinson in the 1990s, showed that Nuer life was more fluid than this tidy model suggests, and that war, money and the state transformed it.

Worked example: who inherits?

A man dies, leaving land, a son, a daughter and a sister's son. Who inherits under different rules? 1. Patrilineal: the land stays in his lineage through his son; his daughter belongs to his lineage but her children will not. 2. Matrilineal: his own children belong to their mother's group, so his heir is often his sister's son, a member of his own matrilineage. 3. Bilateral with partible inheritance: the son and daughter share the land; under primogeniture, as in European aristocracies, the eldest son would take it all. 4. Law can change practice: India's 2005 amendment to its Hindu succession law gave daughters the same rights as sons in ancestral property. 5. Conclusion: the same family produces different heirs under different descent rules.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, equating matrilineal descent with matriarchy. Second, mixing up parallel and cross cousins: parallel cousins come through a parent's same-sex sibling. Third, thinking cross-cousin rules follow genetics: all first cousins are equally related. Fourth, confusing a lineage, with traceable links, and a clan, with assumed ones. Fifth, treating the kindred as a group: it is ego-centred and differs for each person. Sixth, assuming people always follow the ideal rule, as the Diné case shows.

Key takeaways

Kinship reckoning combines terminology and descent. Lineal terminology isolates the nuclear family; bifurcate merging merges the father's brother with the father and the mother's sister with the mother, and separates parallel from cross cousins; generational terminology sorts only by generation and gender; Sudanese, Omaha and Crow systems also occur. Unilineal descent, patrilineal or matrilineal, forms lineages, clans and moieties; matrilineal is not matriarchal. Cognatic descent is bilateral, giving kindreds, or ambilineal. Segmentary lineages, as among the Nuer, unite against outsiders. Descent rules decide inheritance.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Kinship reckoning

How a society classifies relatives and traces descent

Terminology plus descent.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

In a bifurcate merging system, what does ego call the father's brother's son?

Question 2 of 5

In a patrilineal society, which relative belongs to ego's own descent group?

Question 3 of 5

A man in a strongly matrilineal society holds land that passes within the matrilineage. Who is his most likely heir?

Question 4 of 5

Why is a kindred not a descent group?

Question 5 of 5

Parallel and cross first cousins share the same coefficient of relationship. What does this show about rules that let people marry cross cousins but not parallel cousins?

← Previous topicNext topic →