Anthropology › Section I · Social inequalities › Topic I.4

Studying in: inequities within anthropology

Anthropology studies inequality in other people's lives, but it has also helped produce inequality. Studying in means turning the discipline's tools on itself: its history, its collections, whose knowledge it credits, and how it can do better.

Turning the lens around

In 1972 Laura Nader urged anthropologists to study up: to research the powerful, such as corporations, government agencies and banks, instead of only the poor and colonised. Some anthropologists now add studying in: examining the discipline's own practices, training, collections and assumptions to see how they may reproduce the inequities it describes. This is not a rejection of anthropology. It applies the field's core habits, holism, attention to history and respect for insiders' views, to anthropologists themselves. Throughout, the questions are concrete: who did the work, who got credit, whose bodies and belongings ended up in museums, and who benefits from research.

Critiques from inside and outside

Criticism came from several directions around 1970. In Custer Died for Your Sins (1969), the Standing Rock Sioux scholar Vine Deloria Jr. mocked anthropologists who studied Native communities for their careers while giving little back. The Black anthropologist William S. Willis Jr., in 'Skeletons in the Anthropological Closet' (1972), argued that the discipline had long studied people of colour while staying largely silent about their domination and exploitation by White societies. Talal Asad's edited volume Anthropology and the Colonial Encounter (1973) examined how British social anthropology had developed alongside colonial rule. Together these works pushed the discipline to ask whose interests its research served.

Uncredited collaborators and sidelined scholars

Classic ethnographies often rested on Indigenous and Black experts who received little credit. George Hunt, of Tlingit and English parentage and raised among the Kwakwaka'wakw, recorded and translated a large share of the material Franz Boas published on Kwakwaka'wakw life over some four decades. Ella Deloria, a Yankton Dakota linguist, worked with Boas from the late 1920s on Dakota language and culture, yet never held a secure academic post; her novel Waterlily was published only in 1988, long after her death. Zora Neale Hurston, who studied with Boas, published the folklore collection Mules and Men in 1935, but her anthropology was long overlooked. St. Clair Drake and other Black anthropologists linked scholarship with civil rights work.

Race in anthropology's past and present

Anthropology helped build the race concept. Nineteenth-century physical anthropologists measured skulls to rank races, as the previous topics described. In the twentieth century, Boas and his students argued against racial explanations of culture, and today biological anthropologists lead the case that race is not a biological category. Yet the anthropologist Leith Mullings argued in 2005 that many cultural anthropologists had become 'race avoidant', writing about ethnicity or culture while barely mentioning race or racism, so that racism went unanalysed. Studying in asks why: who chose research topics, who sat on hiring committees, and whose experiences were treated as worth studying.

Human remains in collections

The Philadelphia physician Samuel George Morton collected skulls in the early 1800s and used their measured volumes to rank races in works such as Crania Americana (1839). His collection, now at the University of Pennsylvania Museum and numbering more than 1,300 crania, includes the remains of Indigenous people and of Black Philadelphians, some taken from paupers' graves without consent. In 2021 the Penn Museum apologised for the collection's unethical acquisition and racist use. In 2024 it buried the remains of 19 Black Philadelphians at the historic Eden Cemetery, though some descendant community groups objected that they had not been properly consulted. The case shows that repairing harm involves process, not only outcomes.

Worked example: was the bias in the measurements?

In 1981 the biologist Stephen Jay Gould argued that Morton had unconsciously skewed his skull data to fit his racial rankings. In 2011 a team led by Jason Lewis remeasured about half of Morton's skulls. 1. Their finding: Morton's measurements were mostly accurate, and his errors did not systematically favour his rankings. 2. Critics' reply: other scholars, such as Michael Weisberg (2014), argued that this did not settle whether Morton's analysis and presentation were biased. 3. The deeper point: even accurate measurements were organised by a framework that assumed races were real, ranked units and that skull volume revealed worth. 4. Conclusion: bias can lie in the questions and categories a scientist starts with, not only in the numbers. Studying in looks at both.

The MOVE remains, 1985 to 2021

On 13 May 1985, Philadelphia police dropped a bomb on a house occupied by MOVE, a Black radical organisation. The fire that followed killed 11 people, five of them children, and destroyed some 61 homes. Anthropologists were asked to help identify the remains. In April 2021 news reports revealed that bones believed to belong to one or more of the children had been kept by anthropologists at the Penn Museum, taken to Princeton University and used in an online teaching course, all without the family's knowledge. Both universities apologised, and Penn returned the remains it held to the family that July, though in 2024 it reported finding more remains believed to be a MOVE child's. The Association of Black Anthropologists and allied groups issued a joint statement condemning the discipline's long history of disregard for Black bodies.

Decolonising anthropology

Faye V. Harrison's edited volume Decolonizing Anthropology (first published 1991) called on anthropologists to work for the empowerment of the most dispossessed and to free the discipline from the global inequalities that shaped it. Today this takes several forms. Community-based research lets communities help set questions, methods and uses of findings. Indigenous data sovereignty, summarised in the CARE principles of 2019 (collective benefit, authority to control, responsibility, ethics), holds that Indigenous peoples should govern data about them. Archaeologists such as Maria Franklin and colleagues (2020) have set out ways to make archaeology anti-racist. Return of remains and belongings is covered in 'Collections, museums, and repatriation'.

Worked example: auditing a research plan

A hypothetical graduate student plans to study healing practices in a Native community, then publish a book. Apply studying-in questions. 1. Who sets the agenda? The plan was written before contacting the community, so invite community leaders to shape the questions. 2. Who gives consent, and for what? Seek individual and collective permission, including for recordings and photographs. 3. Who gets credit? Name local experts as collaborators or co-authors if they wish, rather than as anonymous informants. 4. Who controls the data? Agree how recordings will be stored and whether some knowledge is restricted. 5. Who benefits? Plan returns such as reports in accessible form or support for language programmes. 6. Check: each step shifts power towards the community studied.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, studying in is not a claim that anthropology is worthless; it uses the discipline's own methods to improve it. Second, studying up and studying in differ: up looks at powerful institutions, in looks at anthropology itself. Third, accurate data do not guarantee unbiased science, as the Morton debate shows. Fourth, apologies and burials do not end the matter if affected communities are not consulted. Fifth, collaborators such as George Hunt and Ella Deloria were experts, not merely informants.

Key takeaways

Laura Nader urged studying up in 1972; studying in examines anthropology's own practices. Vine Deloria Jr. (1969), William S. Willis Jr. (1972) and Talal Asad's volume (1973) challenged the discipline's colonial and racial foundations. Experts such as George Hunt, Ella Deloria and Zora Neale Hurston were long under-credited, and Leith Mullings warned of race avoidance. The Morton collection and the MOVE remains show harms to Black and Indigenous people inside anthropology's own institutions. Decolonising anthropology, community-based research and Indigenous data sovereignty seek to shift power towards the communities studied.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Studying up

Researching the powerful, such as corporations and government agencies

Laura Nader, 1972.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

How does 'studying in' differ from Laura Nader's 'studying up'?

Question 2 of 5

In 2011 a team remeasured Samuel Morton's skulls and found his measurements mostly accurate. What lesson does the topic draw from this?

Question 3 of 5

Which statement about the MOVE remains is accurate?

Question 4 of 5

A researcher names a local healer as co-author and agrees that some recordings will remain restricted to the community. Which principle is she applying?

Question 5 of 5

What was Vine Deloria Jr.'s main criticism of anthropologists in Custer Died for Your Sins (1969)?

← Previous topicNext topic →