Anthropology › Section T · Anthropology on the ground › Topic T.2

Why anthropology matters

Anthropology's breadth, its values and its habit of listening before judging make it unusually useful for a connected world. This topic gathers the course's threads into a case for why the discipline matters now.

When listening saved lives

During the West African Ebola epidemic of 2014 to 2016, which the World Health Organization recorded as causing more than 28,000 cases and 11,000 deaths, funerals became a major route of infection, because families traditionally wash and touch the bodies of loved ones. Early response teams removed bodies in sealed bags, sometimes without ceremony, and some communities hid the sick and the dead. Anthropologists helped explain why: a proper burial was a duty to the dead and to the living. Protocols for safe and dignified burials, introduced from late 2014, built in family participation and religious rites. Understanding culture turned out to be part of medicine.

A uniquely wide lens

Anthropology brings together what other disciplines usually split apart. It studies humans as evolving organisms and as makers of meaning; it covers the deep past and the present; it compares societies across the whole world. It treats people not as passive objects but as actors who interpret, argue and change their circumstances. Few modern problems are simple. Cutting carbon emissions, for instance, means changing how people eat, travel, build and heat their homes, all of which are cultural as well as technical. A discipline built on holism is well placed to see such problems whole.

Anthropological values

Underneath the methods lie a set of values that run through this course. First, every culture is worth understanding and none is a mere stage on the way to another. Second, diversity, biological, cultural and linguistic, is valuable in itself and as a store of solutions. Third, change over time is normal; no culture is frozen. Fourth, cultural relativism: understand before judging. Fifth, the dignity of every human being. These values were hard won: Western bias in assumptions about humanity showed how much damage the opposite assumptions caused.

Diversity as adaptation

Human diversity is largely a record of adaptation. Biologically, many Tibetan highlanders carry a variant of a gene called EPAS1 that helps them live with low oxygen; a 2014 study traced it to interbreeding with Denisovans, as explained in Tracking genomes: the human story. In 2018 researchers found that Bajau sea nomads of Southeast Asia, who free-dive for food, have unusually large spleens, an adaptation for long dives. Culturally, every society has invented its own tools, crops, clothing and rules for its setting. There is no single right way to live; there are many solutions tuned to local conditions.

The human capacity to change

People adapt on several time scales. Over generations, natural selection changes gene frequencies. Within a lifetime, the body acclimatises, as when a lowland visitor's breathing and blood adjust over weeks at altitude. Fastest of all, culture changes: new tools, foods, beliefs and institutions can spread within a few years. This layered flexibility is why humans live in deserts, the Arctic and even orbiting space stations, and why they have rebuilt communities after wars, epidemics and slavery. Anthropology studies this capacity, and reminds us that today's problems are also open to change.

Records that cannot be replaced

Anthropological field notes, recordings, photographs and collections preserve knowledge that might otherwise vanish. Texts in Kwak'wala recorded by Franz Boas and his collaborator George Hunt, of Tlingit and English parentage, who grew up among the Kwakwaka'wakw, are used today by Kwakwaka'wakw people in language and cultural work. Such records also raise questions about who owns and controls them. The CARE Principles for Indigenous Data Governance, published by the Global Indigenous Data Alliance in 2019, state that Indigenous peoples should benefit from and control data about themselves. Collections, museums, and repatriation takes up these questions for objects and remains.

Relativism 2.0

Cultural relativism is the value anthropologists defend most often, and the one most often debated. In a 2008 article, the anthropologist Michael F. Brown proposed a modest, updated version he called cultural relativism 2.0. It does not claim that every practice is equally good. Instead it asks people to hold back a verdict for a moment, to hear others out before talking, and to take in a wide view before settling on a narrow one. As Cross-cultural comparison and cultural relativism showed, this is relativism as a method. Brown's version is a habit anyone can practise, in a laboratory, an office or a family argument.

Worked example: a quiet new colleague

A manager in Chicago thinks a new engineer, recently arrived from abroad, is evasive because he avoids eye contact and never disagrees in meetings. Apply relativism 2.0. 1. Pause: note the judgement, "evasive", and hold it. 2. Listen: in a private chat, the engineer explains that in his previous workplaces, looking a senior person in the eye or contradicting them in public could seem disrespectful. 3. Widen: other team members also say they find open debate in meetings hard. 4. Act: the manager adds written comments and small-group discussions. 5. Result: more ideas reach the team. 6. Check: understanding came first, and the manager's goals stayed the same.

Worked example: the Ebola burials

Analyse the first card. 1. Biomedical view: contact with bodies spreads the virus, so remove bodies fast. 2. Community view: an improper burial dishonours the dead and may bring misfortune, so families resisted. 3. Anthropological insight: the problem was not ignorance but a clash between two sets of reasonable priorities. 4. Solution: burial teams included families and religious leaders, allowed prayers and safe rites, and explained each step. 5. Outcome: communities cooperated more readily, and the anthropologist Paul Richards argued in 2016 that local people's own changes to their practices helped end the epidemic. 6. Lesson: culture is part of the solution, not merely an obstacle.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, thinking anthropology matters only for studying distant peoples: its methods work in hospitals, offices and families at home. Second, reading relativism 2.0 as approval of everything: it is a pause, not a verdict. Third, seeing culture only as an obstacle to science, when the Ebola response shows it can be part of the solution. Fourth, treating diversity as decoration rather than a store of adaptations. Fifth, assuming collected records belong only to researchers: communities have strong claims to control them.

Key takeaways

Anthropology matters because it combines biology, past and present, and comparison, and treats people as active agents. Its values include the worth of every culture, diversity, normal change, cultural relativism and human dignity. Human diversity records adaptation, from EPAS1 in Tibetan highlanders to the Bajau's large spleens. Humans adapt through genes, acclimatisation and, fastest, culture. Anthropological records are irreplaceable, and the CARE Principles (2019) back Indigenous control of data. Michael Brown's relativism 2.0 (2008) asks us to pause, hear others out and widen our view. In the Ebola epidemic (2014 to 2016), cultural understanding helped make burials safe.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Ebola epidemic, 2014-2016

West African outbreak with more than 28,000 cases and 11,000 deaths

Funerals were a route of infection.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

Why did early Ebola burial teams meet resistance in some communities?

Question 2 of 5

Which of these is an example of acclimatisation rather than genetic adaptation?

Question 3 of 5

What does Michael Brown's relativism 2.0 ask people to do?

Question 4 of 5

What do the CARE Principles for Indigenous Data Governance (2019) state?

Question 5 of 5

In the quiet-colleague example, what did applying relativism 2.0 change?

← Previous topicNext topic →