Astronomy › Section J · Small bodies and the origin of the solar system › Topic J.2
Comets
A comet is a small, dark lump of ice and dust that spends most of its life frozen far from the Sun. When it swings close, the ice turns to gas and the comet grows a glowing head and tails millions of kilometres long.
Hairy stars
Records of comets reach back thousands of years, and many cultures read them as omens because they appeared without warning. The name comes from a Greek word for long-haired. A photograph can make a comet look like a streaking meteor, but in the real sky the two are very different. A meteor flashes across the sky in a second or two as a grain burns up in our atmosphere. A comet is tens of millions of kilometres or more away and drifts slowly against the stars from night to night, staying visible for weeks or months. Most comets are faint, fuzzy patches seen only through binoculars or telescopes.
Halley and comet orbits
Isaac Newton suggested that comets travel around the Sun on very elongated ellipses. His friend Edmund Halley computed the orbits of 24 comets and, in 1705, noticed that the bright comets of 1531, 1607 and 1682 had nearly the same orbit. He argued they were one comet returning about every 76 years and predicted its return for about 1758. Halley died in 1742, but the comet appeared as forecast and now carries his name. Records show Comet Halley at every return since about 240 BCE, with periods of 74 to 79 years, because the giant planets tug on it. It last passed the Sun in 1986 and is due back in 2061.
Short-period and long-period comets
Comets with periods under about 200 years are short-period comets. Many of them, the Jupiter-family comets, have periods under 20 years because close passes by Jupiter reshaped their orbits; Comet Encke returns every 3.3 years, one of the shortest periods known. Long-period comets take hundreds to millions of years to return, and their orbits are tilted at every angle, not just near the plane of the planets. Comets are named after their discoverers and given a code: P/ for periodic comets, C/ for non-periodic ones. In late 2026, the Minor Planet Center listed about 4,600 comets with known orbits.
Worked example: Halley's orbit
Comet Halley's orbit has a semi-major axis of about 17.8 AU, where 1 AU, the average Earth-Sun distance, is about \(1.496 \times 10^{11}\) m, and its perihelion (closest point to the Sun) is 0.586 AU. Find its period and its aphelion (farthest point). 1. Kepler's third law for orbits of the Sun, as in the topic "The laws of planetary motion", is \(P^2 = a^3\) with \(P\) in years and \(a\) in AU. 2. So \(P = 17.8^{3/2} = 75.1\) years, close to the observed 76. 3. The longest diameter of the ellipse is \(2a = 35.6\) AU, so the aphelion is \(35.6 - 0.586 = 35.0\) AU. 4. Check: Neptune orbits at about 30 AU, so Halley swings out beyond Neptune, as observed.
The nucleus: a dirty snowball
In 1950 the American astronomer Fred Whipple proposed that a comet's heart, its nucleus, is a single solid body a few kilometres across made of water ice and other frozen gases mixed with rocky dust: the dirty snowball model. Spacecraft have confirmed the idea, with one twist: the dirt outweighs the snow in many comets, so some scientists call them icy dirtballs. In 1986 the European probe Giotto photographed Halley's nucleus, a potato-shaped body about 15 km long. It was darker than coal, because a crust of dust and carbon-rich compounds coats the ice. The nucleus is the only permanent part of a comet.
Coma and tails
As a comet nears the Sun, sunlight warms the nucleus and ice sublimates, turning straight from solid to gas. Water ice does this strongly once the surface passes about 200 K, typically near the distance of Mars or a little beyond. Gas streams away at about 1 km/s, carrying dust with it and forming a glowing head, the coma, which can grow larger than Jupiter. Two tails form, and both point away from the Sun. The dust tail is broad, curved and yellowish-white, pushed by the pressure of sunlight. The ion tail is straight and often blue, made of charged gas swept outwards by the solar wind. Leaving the Sun, a comet travels tail first.
Visiting comets
A small fleet met Comet Halley in 1986. In 2004 NASA's Stardust flew through the coma of Comet Wild 2 and caught dust in a very light foam, aerogel, returning it to Earth in 2006. In 2005 Deep Impact fired a 370 kg probe into Comet Tempel 1 to see what lay below the crust. The most detailed study was the European Space Agency's Rosetta, which orbited Comet 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko from 2014 to 2016. Its lander, Philae, touched down on 12 November 2014, bounced and came to rest in shadow, where it worked for about two and a half days. Rosetta showed a nucleus of two lobes about 4 km long, with gas escaping from small active areas.
Worked example: how dense is a comet?
Rosetta's orbit around 67P gave the nucleus a mass of about \(1.0 \times 10^{13}\) kg, and its images gave a volume of about 18.6 km³. Find the density. 1. Convert the volume: 1 km³ \(= 10^9\) m³, so \(V = 1.86 \times 10^{10}\) m³. 2. Density:
3. Compare: water ice is about 920 kg/m³ and rock about 3,000 kg/m³, yet 67P is lighter than either. 4. Interpret: a mix of ice and dust packed solidly would be denser than ice, so the nucleus must be very porous, with roughly 70% empty space. It would float on water.
What comets are made of
Spectra of the coma show water vapour as the main gas, with carbon monoxide, carbon dioxide, methanol, ammonia and many other molecules. Rosetta found simple organic compounds and the amino acid glycine around 67P. It also measured the ratio of heavy hydrogen (deuterium) to ordinary hydrogen in 67P's water and found it about three times higher than in Earth's oceans. So comets like 67P were probably not the main source of Earth's water, although other comets have shown ratios closer to Earth's, and the question is still debated. Bright recent comets include Hyakutake in 1996, Hale-Bopp in 1997, NEOWISE in 2020 and Tsuchinshan-ATLAS in 2024.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, thinking a comet's tail trails behind it along its path: both tails point away from the Sun, so an outbound comet leads with its tail. Second, confusing the coma, a temporary cloud that can be bigger than Jupiter, with the nucleus, a solid body a few kilometres across. Third, expecting a comet to streak across the sky like a meteor; it moves slowly among the stars over weeks. Fourth, mixing up the tails: the curved dust tail is pushed by sunlight, the straight ion tail by the solar wind. Fifth, picturing a nucleus as dense rock or clean ice; it is dark, dusty and porous.
Key takeaways
A comet is a nucleus of ice and dust a few kilometres across, Whipple's dirty snowball. Near the Sun, ice sublimates to form a coma, a curved dust tail pushed by sunlight, and a straight ion tail pushed by the solar wind, both pointing away from the Sun. Halley showed that comets orbit the Sun; Comet Halley returns about every 76 years, with \(P^2 = a^3\) linking period and orbit size. Short-period comets return within about 200 years, many in the Jupiter family. Rosetta found 67P porous, about 538 kg/m³, with water richer in deuterium than Earth's oceans.
Flashcards
Flashcard
Small icy body that grows a coma and tails near the Sun
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
A comet's orbit has a semi-major axis of 9.0 AU. Using P² = a³, what is its orbital period?
Question 2 of 5
A comet is moving away from the Sun after perihelion. Which way do its tails point?
Question 3 of 5
A comet nucleus has a mass of 2.0 × 10¹³ kg and a volume of 50 km³. What is its density?
Question 4 of 5
What did Fred Whipple's 1950 dirty snowball model propose?
Question 5 of 5
What did Rosetta's measurement of deuterium in Comet 67P's water suggest?
