Astronomy › Section T · Galaxies and quasars › Topic T.5
The expanding universe
Nearly every galaxy is moving away from us, and the farther it is, the faster it recedes. That simple pattern, Hubble's law, means the universe is expanding, and it turns a galaxy's spectrum into a measure of its distance.
Slipher's surprising spectra
The story began before anyone knew what spiral nebulae were. From 1912, at Lowell Observatory in Arizona, Vesto Slipher photographed their faint spectra, exposures that could take several nights each. Andromeda's lines were blueshifted: it is approaching us at about 300 km/s. But nearly all the other spirals showed redshifts, and some were receding at more than 1,000 km/s, far faster than any star. Slipher announced the pattern in 1914, and by the mid-1920s he had measured about 40 spirals. Using the Doppler effect, the speeds were clear; what they meant was not, because nobody yet knew the spirals' distances.
From theory to law
Theory arrived first. Einstein's general relativity, applied to the whole universe, did not naturally allow a static cosmos, so in 1917 he added a term to hold it still. In 1922 Alexander Friedmann showed that the equations also allow an expanding universe, and in 1927 Georges Lemaître, a Belgian priest and physicist, independently proposed expansion and used Slipher's speeds with rough distances to estimate its rate. In 1929 Edwin Hubble, with distances based partly on Cepheids, published a clear trend of speed rising with distance, and in 1931 he and Milton Humason extended it to speeds near 20,000 km/s. In 2018 the International Astronomical Union recommended calling it the Hubble-Lemaître law.
Hubble's law and the Hubble constant
The law says a galaxy's recession speed is proportional to its distance:
The constant \(H_0\), the Hubble constant, is the expansion rate today. With \(v\) in km/s and \(d\) in megaparsecs, \(H_0\) is about 70 km/s per Mpc, or about 21.5 km/s per million light-years. So a galaxy 100 Mpc away recedes at about 7,000 km/s, and one twice as far at about 14,000 km/s. Hubble's own 1929 value was about 500 km/s per Mpc, too high because his distances were far too small. Once \(H_0\) is known, \(d = v / H_0\) turns a measured speed into a distance.
Redshift and recession speed
Astronomers record a galaxy's redshift \(z\), the fractional stretch of its spectral lines:
For nearby galaxies, with \(z\) below about 0.1, the recession speed is simply \(v \approx cz\), with \(c = 3.00 \times 10^5\) km/s, as in The Doppler effect. For larger redshifts this simple version breaks down, a point taken up in Quasars. Because a single spectrum gives \(z\), Hubble's law lets astronomers find distances to galaxies far beyond the reach of Cepheids or supernovae.
Worked example: distance from a spectrum
In a galaxy's spectrum, the hydrogen-alpha line, at rest 656.3 nm, appears at 671.0 nm. Using \(H_0 = 70\) km/s per Mpc, how far away is it? 1. Redshift: \(z = \frac{671.0 - 656.3}{656.3} = 0.0224\). 2. Speed: \(z\) is small, so \(v \approx cz = (3.00 \times 10^5)(0.0224) = 6{,}720\) km/s. 3. Distance: \(d = \frac{v}{H_0} = \frac{6720}{70} = 96.0\) Mpc. 4. In light-years: \(96.0 \times 3.26 = 313\) million light-years. 5. Check: 7,000 km/s corresponds to 100 Mpc, and 6,720 km/s is slightly less, so 96 Mpc fits. The answer carries the uncertainty in \(H_0\), several percent.
Worked example: no centre needed
Picture galaxies in a row, 10 Mpc apart, and suppose every distance between them grows by 1% in 140 million years. Show that every galaxy sees Hubble's law. 1. From any galaxy, a neighbour 10 Mpc away moves 0.1 Mpc farther, and one 20 Mpc away moves 0.2 Mpc. 2. Speed of the first: \(0.1\ \mathrm{Mpc} = 3.09 \times 10^{18}\) km, and 140 million years is \(4.42 \times 10^{15}\) s, so \(v = 698\) km/s. 3. The second moves twice as far in the same time: 1,397 km/s. 4. Ratio of speed to distance: about 70 km/s per Mpc for both. 5. Conclusion: the same holds whichever galaxy we start from, so uniform expansion gives every observer the same law and singles out no centre.
Space itself stretches
Hubble's law does not mean galaxies are hurtling through space away from us. In general relativity, the space between galaxies is itself stretching and carries them apart, much as dots drawn on a rubber band separate when it is pulled. There is no centre and no edge to the expansion. Light crossing expanding space is stretched along with it, so a galaxy's redshift records how much the universe grew while the light travelled: \(1 + z\) is the factor by which distances have increased. Light with \(z = 1\) set out when the universe was half its present size, measured by the distances between galaxies.
What does not expand
Expansion wins only where gravity is too weak to resist it. Atoms, people, the Earth, the Solar System and the Milky Way do not expand, because forces bind them together. Groups and clusters of galaxies hold together too. Within our Local Group, Andromeda is approaching the Milky Way at about 110 km/s. Galaxies also have individual, or peculiar, motions of a few hundred km/s on top of the expansion. For a galaxy 10 Mpc away, the expansion speed is only about 700 km/s, so a peculiar motion of 300 km/s could throw a Hubble's-law distance off by about 40%. The law is most reliable for galaxies tens of megaparsecs away or more.
A changing rate and the Hubble tension
The Hubble constant is constant across space at any one time, but not over time. In 1998 type Ia supernovae showed that the expansion is speeding up, the subject of What the universe is made of. Running the expansion backwards, \(1/H_0\) is about 14.0 billion years, close to the age of the universe, about 13.8 billion years, as The age of the universe explains. The precise value of \(H_0\) is disputed. Predictions from the cosmic microwave background give about 67, while Cepheids and supernovae give about 73; red-giant-based distances land near 70. This Hubble tension may come from hidden measurement errors or new physics, and it is unresolved.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, thinking Hubble's law puts us at the centre; every observer sees the same pattern. Second, picturing galaxies flying through space from an explosion at one point; space itself expands. Third, believing everything expands, including the Solar System; bound systems do not. Fourth, using Hubble's law for very nearby galaxies, where peculiar motions swamp the expansion. Fifth, mixing units: \(H_0\) in km/s per Mpc needs distances in Mpc. Sixth, using \(v = cz\) for large redshifts. Seventh, quoting \(H_0\) as exactly known; measurements range from about 67 to 73.
Key takeaways
Slipher found from 1912 that most spirals are redshifted. Friedmann and Lemaître showed relativity allows expansion, and Hubble (1929) and Hubble and Humason (1931) found the Hubble-Lemaître law, v = H₀d. H₀ is about 70 km/s per Mpc (about 21.5 km/s per million ly), though measurements disagree, roughly 67 to 73: the Hubble tension. For small redshifts, z = Δλ/λ and v ≈ cz, so d = v/H₀. Space itself stretches, with no centre; 1 + z is the factor by which distances have grown. Bound systems do not expand. The expansion is accelerating, and 1/H₀ is about 14 billion years.
Flashcards
Flashcard
Measured redshifts of spiral nebulae from 1912
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
Taking H₀ = 70 km/s per Mpc, how fast does a galaxy 150 Mpc away recede?
Question 2 of 5
A galaxy recedes at 3,500 km/s. With H₀ = 70 km/s per Mpc, about how far away is it?
Question 3 of 5
Observers in every galaxy see other galaxies receding with speeds proportional to distance. What does this imply?
Question 4 of 5
Which of these is being stretched by the expansion of the universe?
Question 5 of 5
What is the Hubble tension?
