Astronomy › Section T · Galaxies and quasars › Topic T.3
Properties of galaxies
How do you weigh a galaxy you can never visit? Orbits and Doppler shifts give its mass, and comparing that mass with the light it gives off reveals what kinds of stars it holds and how much dark matter hides around it.
Weighing with orbits
Galaxies are weighed the same way as the Sun and the Milky Way: by how fast things orbit them. Newton's law of gravitation, met in Newton's universal law of gravitation, links the speed of an orbit to the mass inside it. For a star or gas cloud moving at speed \(v\) on a circular orbit of radius \(r\), and treating the mass inside as roughly spherical, gravity supplies exactly the pull needed to keep it on that circle, which gives
Here \(M\) is the mass inside the orbit, not the whole galaxy, and \(G = 6.67 \times 10^{-11}\ \mathrm{N\,m^2\,kg^{-2}}\). Faster orbits at the same radius mean more mass inside.
Measuring a spiral's rotation
The orbital speeds come from the Doppler effect. A spiral galaxy seen at an angle has one side of its disc turning towards us and the other away, so spectral lines from one side are blueshifted and from the other redshifted. After correcting for the tilt of the disc, half the difference gives the rotation speed at each distance from the centre. Astronomers use lines from stars and glowing gas in visible light, and the 21-cm line of cold hydrogen, met in The interstellar medium and its gas, which traces gas far beyond the bright disc. Large spirals typically rotate at about 150 to 300 km/s.
Worked example: the mass of a spiral
A gas cloud in the outer disc of a large spiral orbits at 250 km/s, 100,000 light-years from the centre. What mass lies inside its orbit? 1. Convert to SI: \(v = 2.50 \times 10^5\) m/s and \(r = 10^5 \times 9.46 \times 10^{15} = 9.46 \times 10^{20}\) m. 2. Substitute:
3. In solar masses: \(\frac{8.86 \times 10^{41}}{1.99 \times 10^{30}} = 4.45 \times 10^{11}\), about 450 billion Suns. 4. Check: this is similar to estimates of Andromeda's mass within a comparable radius, so the size of the answer is sensible.
Weighing an elliptical
Ellipticals do not rotate as an orderly disc, so there is no single rotation speed to measure. Their stars swarm on orbits in all directions. Each star's light is Doppler shifted by its own motion, some towards red and some towards blue, and the galaxy's combined spectrum shows every line smeared out. This line broadening reveals the spread of stellar speeds, called the velocity dispersion. Since the galaxy is billions of years old and not flying apart, gravity must be strong enough to hold stars moving that fast. Roughly, \(M \approx \sigma^2 R / G\), where \(\sigma\) is the dispersion and \(R\) the galaxy's radius; real analyses add a factor of a few.
A wide range of galaxies
Galaxy properties span huge ranges. Dwarf galaxies may hold only a few million stars and be a few thousand light-years across. Large spirals such as the Milky Way and Andromeda are about 100,000 light-years or more across, with total masses, dark matter included, of roughly a trillion solar masses each; which of the two is heavier is still debated. Giant ellipticals at the centres of galaxy clusters are the largest of all, spanning several hundred thousand light-years and reaching ten trillion solar masses or more. So both the smallest and the largest galaxies known are ellipticals. Luminosities range from under a million to over a hundred billion Suns.
The mass-to-light ratio
A single number summarises what a galaxy is made of: its mass-to-light ratio, the mass in solar masses divided by the luminosity in solar luminosities. The Sun's ratio is 1 by definition. Low-mass stars are dim for their mass: a star of half a solar mass shines at only a few percent of the Sun's luminosity, giving a ratio of roughly 10 or more. Massive stars are the reverse, with ratios far below 1. So a galaxy full of young, massive stars has a low ratio, while one whose bright stars have died, leaving only dim low-mass stars, has a high one. Mass that gives off no light at all raises the ratio further.
Worked example: a mass-to-light ratio
The spiral in the earlier example has \(4.45 \times 10^{11}\) solar masses inside 100,000 light-years, and its stars and gas inside that radius give out \(2.5 \times 10^{10}\) solar luminosities. 1. Ratio: \(\frac{4.45 \times 10^{11}}{2.5 \times 10^{10}} = 17.8\), about 18. 2. Compare: the visible parts of star-forming spirals typically have ratios of a few to about 10, from their mix of stars. 3. Interpret: about 18 solar masses for every solar luminosity is more mass than the visible stars and gas can explain. 4. Conclusion: a large share of the mass inside the orbit is dark, giving off no light we can detect.
Ratios by galaxy type
Measured in their bright inner regions, star-forming spirals and irregulars typically have mass-to-light ratios of roughly 1 to 10, because young, luminous stars add a lot of light for little mass. Ellipticals, made of old stars whose massive members have long since died, have higher ratios, roughly 10 to 20. Colour tells the same story: star-forming galaxies look bluer, and ellipticals redder. But when the outer regions are included, using gas clouds, globular clusters and satellite galaxies that orbit far beyond the visible edge, the ratios can climb to 100 or more. Most of a galaxy's mass lies outside the part that shines.
Dark matter in galaxies
If a galaxy's mass were concentrated where its light is, orbital speeds would fall with distance beyond the bright disc, as the planets' speeds fall with distance from the Sun. Instead, rotation curves of spirals stay roughly flat far out, the same pattern found for the Milky Way in The mass of the galaxy and dark matter. Each galaxy therefore sits inside a large halo of dark matter, which betrays itself only through its gravity. What dark matter is remains unknown: most astronomers think it is an undiscovered kind of particle, but no detector has yet caught one, and a minority explore changes to the law of gravity instead.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, thinking \(M = v^2 r / G\) gives a galaxy's total mass; it gives only the mass inside radius \(r\). Second, forgetting to convert km/s and light-years to m/s and metres before using \(G\) in SI units. Third, using a rotation speed for an elliptical, which has random stellar orbits; its mass comes from line broadening. Fourth, reading a high mass-to-light ratio as proof of many bright stars; it means the opposite, dim stars or dark matter. Fifth, assuming dark matter is ordinary dust or gas; those absorb or emit light we can detect.
Key takeaways
A galaxy's mass inside radius r follows from the orbital speed there: M = v²r/G. Spirals' rotation speeds come from Doppler shifts across the disc, including the 21-cm line of hydrogen; ellipticals' masses come from line broadening by random stellar motions. Galaxies range from dwarfs of a few million stars to giant ellipticals of ten trillion solar masses or more. The mass-to-light ratio is about 1 to 10 in star-forming regions and 10 to 20 in ellipticals' bright parts, but reaches 100 or more for whole galaxies, showing that dark matter halos hold most of their mass.
Flashcards
Flashcard
Mass inside a circular orbit of radius r and speed v
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
Gas orbits a galaxy at 200 km/s, 50,000 light-years from its centre. What mass lies inside the orbit?
Question 2 of 5
A galaxy has a mass of 5 × 10¹¹ solar masses and a luminosity of 2.5 × 10¹⁰ solar luminosities. What is its mass-to-light ratio?
Question 3 of 5
Why do the bright parts of elliptical galaxies have higher mass-to-light ratios than star-forming spirals?
Question 4 of 5
How do astronomers measure the mass of an elliptical galaxy?
Question 5 of 5
Whole galaxies, including their outer regions, have mass-to-light ratios of 100 or more. What does this show?
