Astronomy › Section I · Giant planets, moons, and rings › Topic I.3

Atmospheres of the giant planets

Everything we see of a giant planet is atmosphere: stacked cloud decks, racing jet streams and storms bigger than Earth that last for centuries. Their weather follows the same physics as ours, under very different conditions.

Reading the gases

Because the giant planets have no solid surfaces, their atmospheres give a fair sample of what they are made of. Sunlight reflected from the clouds carries absorption features, the spectral fingerprints of the gases it passed through. In the early 1930s these features were identified as methane (CH₄) and ammonia (NH₃), and for a time astronomers wondered whether those were the main gases. They are not. Hydrogen and helium dominate, but they leave few features in visible light, so helium's share was only measured well when Voyager recorded far-infrared spectra and the Galileo probe sampled Jupiter's air directly in 1995. By number of molecules, Jupiter's upper atmosphere is about 86% hydrogen and about 13% helium. Saturn's upper atmosphere holds less helium, consistent with helium raining inwards, as described in The giant planets.

Clouds form where gases condense

A cloud forms at the level where a gas becomes cold enough to condense, just as water vapour condenses into Earth's clouds. In a giant planet's troposphere, the lowest layer, temperature and pressure both rise with depth. Different compounds condense at different temperatures, so they form separate decks at different depths. In Jupiter, models and observations point to three main layers: white ammonia-ice clouds at the top, near the 0.5 to 1 bar level, where 1 bar is about Earth's sea-level air pressure; ammonium hydrosulfide (NH₄SH) clouds near 2 bar; and water clouds near 5 bar or deeper. Above the ammonia clouds lies the clear stratosphere, where temperatures climb again because gases absorb solar ultraviolet light.

Worked example: reading a cloud stack

On which giant planet would you expect the visible ammonia clouds to lie deepest, and why does that make the planet look bland? 1. Ammonia condenses where the air falls to roughly 150 K. 2. Saturn is farther from the Sun than Jupiter, so its upper atmosphere is colder; the 150 K level is therefore reached deeper down, where pressure is higher. 3. Saturn's weaker surface gravity also stretches its atmosphere, so each layer is spread over a greater height. 4. Both effects put Saturn's ammonia deck deeper than Jupiter's, under a thicker layer of haze. 5. So Saturn's bands look muted and butterscotch-coloured, while Jupiter's sharper cloud tops show vivid contrasts. 6. On Uranus and Neptune it is colder still: ammonia condenses far below, and the highest clouds are methane ice.

Where the colours come from

Pure ammonia ice is white, so the oranges, browns and reds of Jupiter come from small amounts of other substances, called chromophores (colour carriers). They are thought to be made by photochemistry, chemical reactions driven by sunlight, which also produces a thin hydrocarbon smog high above the clouds. Exactly which compounds colour the Great Red Spot is still uncertain. Uranus and Neptune look blue-green because methane absorbs red light, so the sunlight scattered back to us is mostly blue and green. A 2024 reanalysis found the two are closer in colour than enhanced Voyager images suggested: Neptune is only slightly bluer, because Uranus has a thicker, whiter haze.

Bands, zones and jet streams

Fast rotation stretches giant-planet weather into east-west bands parallel to the equator. On Jupiter the light zones are, in the classic picture, regions of rising gas capped by fresh ammonia clouds, and the darker belts are sinking, drier gas where we see deeper. The Galileo probe happened to fall into one of these dry downdrafts, and found much less water than expected. Beneath the bands blow steady jet streams that alternate in direction with latitude and have barely changed in decades. Wind speeds are measured relative to the interior's rotation. Jupiter's equatorial jet flows east at about 100 m/s. Saturn's reaches roughly 400 to 500 m/s, and Neptune's winds, up to about 2,000 km/h, are the fastest of any planet.

Worked example: a cloud circling Neptune

A cloud near Neptune's equator is carried westward by a wind of about 400 m/s relative to the interior. Neptune's equatorial radius is 24,764 km. How long does the cloud take to lap the planet? 1. Circumference: \(C = 2\pi R = 2\pi \times 24{,}764 = 1.556 \times 10^5\) km. 2. Convert the speed: \(400\ \text{m/s} \times 3.6 = 1440\) km/h. 3. Time: \(t = C / v = 1.556 \times 10^5 / 1440 = 108\) hours. 4. That is about 4.5 days, or roughly 6.7 of Neptune's 16.1-hour days. 5. Check: a strong Earth jet stream, about 70 m/s, is almost 6 times slower, so a cloud carried at that speed would need almost 6 times as long, about 26 days.

Neptune and Uranus: active and quiet

Neptune, despite receiving less sunlight than Uranus, has more visible weather. Its internal heat drives convection, rising and sinking currents of gas, that lifts methane above the main cloud deck to form bright, high cirrus-like streaks. Voyager 2 measured their height from the shadows they cast on the clouds below. Uranus looked almost featureless to Voyager 2 in 1986, under a deep haze, with little internal heat to stir it. Since then, as its seasons have turned, telescopes such as Hubble, Keck and the James Webb Space Telescope have seen bright storms and a hazy polar cap. Uranus's winds still run parallel to its equator, even though its poles spend decades in sunlight or darkness.

Storms that last for centuries

Jupiter's Great Red Spot is a giant anticyclone: a high-pressure storm, rotating counterclockwise in the southern hemisphere, the opposite of a low-pressure hurricane on Earth. It has been watched continuously since at least the 1830s; a 2024 study concluded that a spot seen from 1665 to 1713 was probably a different storm. It has been shrinking: in the late 1800s it was about 40,000 km long, while measurements since 2014 give roughly 14,000 to 16,000 km, still wider than Earth's 12,700 km diameter. Juno found it extends no more than about 500 km deep. Storms on giants last because there is no surface to cause friction, unlike hurricanes that weaken over land. Neptune's Great Dark Spot of 1989 had vanished by 1994, and Hubble has since seen new dark spots come and go. Saturn has a six-sided jet stream circling its north pole, and erupted a planet-encircling storm in 2010 and 2011.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, assuming methane and ammonia are the main gases because they dominate the spectra: hydrogen and helium make up almost all the atmosphere. Second, treating the Great Red Spot like a hurricane: it is a high-pressure storm, and it survives because no surface slows it. Third, thinking cloud colours come from the ammonia itself: pure ammonia ice is white, and the colours are trace compounds. Fourth, quoting wind speeds as absolute: they are measured relative to the planet's interior rotation. Fifth, assuming farther from the Sun means calmer: Neptune is more active than Uranus.

Key takeaways

Giant-planet atmospheres are mainly hydrogen and helium, with methane and ammonia showing strongly in spectra. Clouds form where gases condense; Jupiter has ammonia, ammonium hydrosulfide and water decks, deeper on colder, lower-gravity Saturn. Colours come from trace chromophores; Uranus and Neptune are blue-green because methane absorbs red light. Rapid rotation makes bands and steady jet streams; Neptune has the fastest winds. Without solid surfaces, storms can last centuries: the Great Red Spot is a shrinking, shallow anticyclone. Internal heat makes Neptune more active than Uranus.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Main atmospheric gases

Hydrogen and helium

Jupiter: about 86% H₂ and 13% He by number.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

Methane and ammonia show strongly in the spectra of Jupiter and Saturn. What is the main gas in their atmospheres?

Question 2 of 5

Why are Saturn's ammonia clouds deeper in its atmosphere than Jupiter's?

Question 3 of 5

A wind of 300 m/s carries a cloud around a planet with an equatorial radius of 60,000 km. About how long does one lap take?

Question 4 of 5

Why can Jupiter's Great Red Spot last for centuries when Earth's hurricanes last weeks?

Question 5 of 5

Why do Uranus and Neptune look blue-green?

← Previous topicNext topic →