Astronomy › Section L · Analysing starlight and the stellar census › Topic L.8
The H-R diagram
Plot stars by temperature and luminosity and they do not scatter at random: they gather into a long diagonal band and a few distinct groups. This single graph, the Hertzsprung–Russell diagram, sorts stars by size and mass and became the key to understanding how stars live and die.
Looking for patterns
The earlier topics in this section showed how to measure a star's properties: temperature from its colour or spectrum, luminosity from its apparent brightness and distance, radius from eclipses or the radiation laws, mass from binary orbits, and composition and motion from spectral lines. A list of measurements is only a start. Science advances when measurements reveal relationships, and the most productive relationship in all of stellar astronomy appears when two of these properties, temperature and luminosity, are plotted against each other for many stars.
Hertzsprung and Russell
Two astronomers found the pattern independently. Around 1911 the Danish astronomer Ejnar Hertzsprung plotted the brightness of stars in the Pleiades and Hyades clusters, whose members are all at nearly the same distance, against their colours. In 1913 and 1914 the American Henry Norris Russell plotted the luminosities of nearby stars of known distance against their spectral classes. Both saw that the stars were not spread evenly but crowded into a few regions. The resulting graph is named after both: the Hertzsprung–Russell, or H-R, diagram.
Reading the axes
The vertical axis shows luminosity, in solar luminosities or as absolute magnitude, with the most luminous stars at the top. Because luminosities range from below a ten-thousandth to about a million times the Sun's, the axis is logarithmic: each step up multiplies by the same factor. The horizontal axis shows surface temperature, or equivalently spectral class or colour index, and it runs backwards: the hottest stars, class O, are on the left and the coolest, class M, on the right. This convention comes from the order of the spectral classes, and it trips up many readers.
The main sequence
About 90% of stars in an H-R diagram fall along a band running diagonally from the upper left, hot and very luminous, to the lower right, cool and faint. This band is the main sequence, and the Sun lies near its middle. All main-sequence stars are doing the same job: fusing hydrogen into helium in their cores. Along the band, hotter stars are more luminous. These are the stars that earlier topics called dwarfs, luminosity class V, a name that means ordinary rather than tiny; the Sun is a G2 V main-sequence star.
A sequence of masses
Why do hydrogen-fusing stars spread along a line? Models show that a stable star's structure is set almost entirely by its mass and composition. A more massive star squeezes its core harder, making it hotter and its fusion faster, so it shines more brightly and has a hotter surface. Roughly: a B0 star has about 18 solar masses, 31,000 K and 45,000 solar luminosities; an A0 star about 2.2, 9,700 K and 38; the Sun 1, 5,770 K and 1; a K5 star about 0.7, 4,400 K and 0.17; an M5 star about 0.16, 3,000 K and 0.003. The main sequence is a sequence of masses, matching the mass–luminosity relation of 'Measuring stellar masses'.
Giants and supergiants
Some stars lie above the main sequence, at the upper right: cool, red or orange, yet very luminous. Each square metre of a cool surface emits little, since \(\sigma T^4\) is small, so such stars can be luminous only by having an enormous surface area. They are giants (luminosity class III), such as Arcturus at about 25 solar radii, and supergiants (class I), such as Betelgeuse at hundreds of solar radii. Because \(L = 4\pi R^2 \sigma T^4\), lines of equal radius can be drawn across the diagram, and a star's position therefore also tells us its size.
White dwarfs
In the lower left lie stars that are hot, white or bluish, yet very dim. A hot surface emits strongly, so their low luminosity means a tiny area: these white dwarfs are about the size of Earth. The best known is Sirius B. In 1844 Friedrich Bessel inferred an unseen companion from a wobble in the motion of Sirius, and in 1862 Alvan Graham Clark first saw it through a new telescope. Sirius B has about the Sun's mass packed into a sphere smaller than Earth. Later topics show that white dwarfs are the exposed cores of stars that have finished fusing.
Worked example: placing a star
A star has a surface temperature of 4,000 K and a luminosity of 200 solar luminosities. Where does it sit on the H-R diagram? 1. Temperature: 4,000 K is cooler than the Sun, so the star is right of the Sun, among K and M types. 2. Radius: \(\frac{R}{R_\odot} = \sqrt{200} \times \left(\frac{5770}{4000}\right)^2 = 14.1 \times 2.08 = 29.4\). 3. A main-sequence star this cool emits only about a tenth of the Sun's luminosity, so at 200 the star lies far above the main sequence. 4. Conclusion: it is a giant of about 29 solar radii, in the upper right region, as its large radius confirms.
Worked example: the density of a white dwarf
A white dwarf has 0.6 solar masses and Earth's radius, \(6.37 \times 10^6\) m. Find its mean density. 1. Mass: \(0.6 \times 1.99 \times 10^{30} = 1.19 \times 10^{30}\) kg. 2. Volume: \(\frac{4}{3}\pi (6.37 \times 10^6)^3 = 1.08 \times 10^{21}\) m³. 3. Density: \(\frac{1.19 \times 10^{30}}{1.08 \times 10^{21}} = 1.1 \times 10^9\) kg per cubic metre, about a million times the density of water. 4. A 5-millilitre teaspoonful would have a mass of about 5,500 kg. 5. Check: the Sun's mean density is only about 1,400 kg per cubic metre, so squeezing a large share of its mass into Earth's volume must raise the density enormously.
Why 90% are on the main sequence
An H-R diagram is a snapshot of stars caught at different moments in their lives. If you photographed a city at random times of day and found about a third of its people asleep, you could conclude that people spend about a third of their lives asleep. In the same way, about 90% of stars being on the main sequence shows that stars spend about 90% of their lives there, fusing hydrogen in their cores. Giants, supergiants and white dwarfs are later, shorter or fainter stages. The sample matters too: as 'A stellar census' showed, a diagram of the brightest-looking stars is crowded with rare luminous giants.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, reading the temperature axis the wrong way: temperature increases to the left. Second, thinking giants are hot because they are luminous: most giants are cool, and they are luminous because they are huge. Third, thinking white dwarfs are cool because they are dim: they are hot and dim because they are tiny. Fourth, believing stars slide along the main sequence as they age: a star's position there is set mainly by its mass. Fifth, assuming every star near the Sun's spectral type is like the Sun: a G-type giant is far larger.
Key takeaways
The H-R diagram plots luminosity (up) against surface temperature (increasing to the left), and was found independently by Hertzsprung and Russell in the 1910s. About 90% of stars lie on the main sequence, where they fuse hydrogen in their cores; it is a sequence of mass, from hot, massive, luminous stars at the upper left to cool, low-mass stars at the lower right. Cool but luminous giants and supergiants lie at the upper right; hot but dim, Earth-sized white dwarfs at the lower left. Since L = 4πR²σT⁴, position also gives radius.
Flashcards
Flashcard
A plot of stars' luminosity against surface temperature
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
On a standard H-R diagram, where are stars that are very hot but have low luminosity found?
Question 2 of 5
A star is cooler than the Sun but 1,000 times as luminous. What kind of star is it, and where is it on the H-R diagram?
Question 3 of 5
Moving along the main sequence from the lower right to the upper left, which property of the stars mainly increases?
Question 4 of 5
About 90% of stars lie on the main sequence. What does this suggest about stellar lives?
Question 5 of 5
A star has the Sun's temperature but 100 times its luminosity. What is its radius?
