Astronomy › Section C · Orbits and gravity › Topic C.5

Gravity with more than two bodies

Kepler's laws treat a planet and the Sun as a lonely pair, but every planet tugs on every other. Following those small extra pulls is hard work, yet it led to one of the great triumphs of science: finding a new planet with pencil and paper.

Beyond a lonely pair

So far we have pictured orbits as two bodies circling each other: the Sun and a planet, or a planet and its moon. For exactly two bodies, Newton's laws give a complete answer, and the orbits are Kepler's ellipses. But the real solar system is crowded. Jupiter pulls on Saturn, Saturn on Uranus, all of them on Earth, and so on. Once a third body joins, there is no general formula that gives the positions for all future times. Mathematicians spent centuries on this three-body problem and showed that, in general, no such neat solution exists. Some three-body systems are even chaotic: a tiny change in the starting positions grows until the long-term future cannot be predicted.

Computing orbits step by step

Without a formula, astronomers compute. Suppose you know where every star in a cluster is and how fast each is moving. For one star, add up the gravitational pulls of all the others to get the total force, then use \(F = ma\) to find its acceleration. Do this for every star. Then advance the clock by a short time step: each star's velocity changes by its acceleration times the step, and its position by its velocity times the step. Repeat thousands or millions of times. Shorter steps give more accurate results but need more computing. Such N-body simulations now follow star clusters, colliding galaxies and even the growth of cosmic structure, with up to billions of particles.

Perturbations: small extra pulls

Within the solar system the problem is easier, because one body dominates. The Sun holds about 99.8% of the solar system's mass, so each planet moves almost on its two-body Kepler ellipse, nudged slightly by the others. These small departures are called perturbations. In the 1700s and 1800s, mathematicians developed clever methods for calculating them and could predict planetary positions with great precision. Perturbations make orbits slowly change their orientation and shape over thousands of years. Today, computers calculate the positions of planets, moons, asteroids and spacecraft with all the significant bodies included, which is how mission planners hit targets billions of kilometres away.

Worked example: how hard does Jupiter pull on Earth?

Jupiter has about \(9.55 \times 10^{-4}\) solar masses. At a typical closest approach it is about 4.2 AU from Earth, while the Sun is 1.0 AU away. Compare their pulls on Earth. 1. By the law of gravitation, force is proportional to \(\frac{M}{R^2}\), and Earth's own mass cancels in the ratio. 2. Ratio: \(\frac{F_J}{F_\odot} = \frac{9.55 \times 10^{-4}}{1} \times \left(\frac{1.0}{4.2}\right)^2 = 5.4 \times 10^{-5}\). 3. Interpret: even when near its closest, Jupiter pulls on Earth only about 1/18,000 as hard as the Sun does. 4. Conclusion: this is why Kepler's two-body laws work so well, and why planetary perturbations are real but small.

Worked example: the Moon's two masters

The Sun has about \(3.33 \times 10^{5}\) times Earth's mass. The Moon is \(3.84 \times 10^{8}\) m from Earth and about \(1.496 \times 10^{11}\) m from the Sun. Which pulls the Moon harder? 1. Ratio of forces: \(\frac{F_\odot}{F_E} = \frac{M_\odot}{M_E} \times \left(\frac{r_{EM}}{r_{SM}}\right)^2\). 2. Substitute: \(3.33 \times 10^{5} \times \left(\frac{3.84 \times 10^{8}}{1.496 \times 10^{11}}\right)^2 = 2.2\). 3. Interpret: the Sun pulls the Moon about twice as hard as Earth does. 4. Why it stays with Earth: the Sun pulls Earth and Moon almost equally, so both orbit the Sun together, and the Moon circles Earth within that shared motion. The Sun's extra tug makes the Moon's orbit wobble, which is why precise lunar prediction was so difficult.

Uranus misbehaves

On 13 March 1781, the musician and amateur astronomer William Herschel found a faint object that moved against the stars: the planet Uranus, the first discovered with a telescope. Astronomers soon found that it had been recorded as a star in earlier observations, back to 1690. By 1790 its orbit had been computed, including the perturbations from Jupiter and Saturn. Yet over the following decades Uranus drifted away from its predicted path. By the 1840s the error was roughly 2 arcminutes, barely visible to the eye but far larger than the observational errors. Either Newton's law failed at great distances, or something unseen was pulling on Uranus.

Predicting an unseen planet

Two mathematicians, working independently, assumed an unseen planet beyond Uranus and calculated what mass and orbit it would need to produce the drift. This is the many-body problem run backwards: from the perturbation, find the perturber. In England, John Couch Adams worked on it from 1843 and gave a predicted position to the Astronomer Royal, George Airy, in 1845, but no prompt search followed. In France, Urbain Le Verrier published his own prediction in 1846. Its close agreement with Adams's prompted a search at Cambridge Observatory, where James Challis recorded the planet without recognising it, because he did not compare his observations quickly enough.

The discovery of Neptune

Le Verrier wrote to Johann Galle at the Berlin Observatory, who received the letter on 23 September 1846. That night, with the student Heinrich d'Arrest and an up-to-date star chart, Galle found a star-like object that was not on the chart, within about 1° of Le Verrier's position. Its motion soon confirmed it as the eighth planet, Neptune. Credit for the prediction is usually shared between Adams and Le Verrier. The discovery showed that Newton's gravity held out at the edge of the known solar system. Later searches were less successful: a planet proposed inside Mercury's orbit was never found, and the oddity in Mercury's orbit that inspired it was finally explained by Einstein, as the topic General relativity: spacetime and gravity describes.

Special points and families

Three bodies can also share stable patterns. Where the gravity of the Sun and a planet balances the motion of a small body, there are five Lagrange points, where it can keep a fixed position relative to the pair. Two of them, 60° ahead of and behind Jupiter in its orbit, collect thousands of Trojan asteroids. The James Webb Space Telescope, launched in 2021, orbits near the Sun-Earth L2 point, about 1.5 million km beyond Earth on the side away from the Sun, where it stays in step with Earth's year. Gravity assists are another three-body effect: a spacecraft, a planet and the Sun trade a little energy during a flyby.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, assuming the planets ignore each other: they all pull on one another, though weakly compared with the Sun. Second, thinking a three-body orbit can always be written as a neat formula: in general it cannot, so astronomers compute it step by step. Third, assuming the strongest pull decides what orbits what: the Sun pulls the Moon harder than Earth does, yet the Moon orbits Earth because the Sun pulls Earth almost equally. Fourth, crediting Neptune's discovery to luck: it was predicted from Uranus's perturbations. Fifth, forgetting to square the distance when comparing pulls.

Key takeaways

With three or more bodies there is no general formula for the orbits, and some systems are chaotic, so astronomers use step-by-step N-body simulations. In the solar system the Sun dominates, so planets follow Kepler ellipses with small perturbations; Jupiter pulls on Earth only about 1/18,000 as hard as the Sun. Uranus, found by Herschel in 1781, drifted from its predicted path. Adams and Le Verrier independently predicted an outer planet, and Galle found Neptune in 1846 within about 1° of Le Verrier's position. Lagrange points, Trojan asteroids and gravity assists are other many-body effects.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Three-body problem

Predicting the motion of three mutually attracting bodies

No general formula; some cases are chaotic.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

An asteroid is 2.0 AU from Jupiter and 3.0 AU from the Sun. Jupiter has about 1/1000 of the Sun's mass. About how does Jupiter's pull on the asteroid compare with the Sun's?

Question 2 of 5

How was the planet Neptune first found?

Question 3 of 5

Why do astronomers use step-by-step computer simulations to follow a star cluster's motion?

Question 4 of 5

Why do Kepler's two-body laws describe the planets so well, even though the planets pull on each other?

Question 5 of 5

The Sun pulls on the Moon about twice as hard as Earth does. Why does the Moon still orbit Earth?

← Previous topicNext topic →