Astronomy › Section S · The Milky Way › Topic S.5

Stellar populations and how the galaxy formed

The stars of the Milky Way are a fossil record. Their ages, their heavy-element content and the shapes of their orbits reveal how the galaxy was assembled: partly by the collapse of a great cloud of gas, and partly by swallowing smaller galaxies, a process still going on today.

Two kinds of stars

During the Second World War, the German-born astronomer Walter Baade was barred from war research in the United States, so he had long nights on the 100-inch telescope at Mount Wilson, helped by the blacked-out skies of Los Angeles. In 1944 he resolved individual stars in the central bulge of the Andromeda Galaxy and its companions. He noticed that their brightest stars were red giants, like those of globular clusters, while the brightest stars in spiral arms were hot and blue. He named the arm stars population I and the bulge, halo and cluster stars population II. The labels turned out to sort stars by age, composition and orbit as well as colour.

Population I

Population I stars live in the disc, especially the thin disc, and follow nearly circular orbits in its plane, moving together at high speed around the centre. They include the luminous blue O and B stars of the spiral arms, young open clusters and the gas and dust they form from, but also older stars: the Sun, about 4.6 billion years old, is population I, and some members are around 10 billion years old. Astronomers call every element heavier than helium a metal. In population I stars metals make up roughly 1 to 4% of the mass, around the Sun's share of about 1.3 to 1.5%.

Population II

Population II stars are old, typically 11 to 13 billion years, and poor in metals, often with less than a hundredth of the Sun's share. They include halo stars, globular cluster members and many RR Lyrae variables. Their orbits are long, tilted ellipses in every orientation, so they plunge through the disc at high speed relative to the Sun but are usually found well away from its plane. A few are extreme: in 2014 astronomers reported a halo star with less than a ten-millionth of the Sun's iron. Hypothetical population III stars, the very first generation made of almost pure hydrogen and helium, have not been confirmed, though possible signs have been reported in very distant galaxies.

Why older stars have fewer metals

The Big Bang made almost only hydrogen and helium. Every heavier element was forged inside stars and spread into space by stellar winds and supernovae, as The life cycle of cosmic material described. Each new generation of stars forms from gas a little richer in metals than the last. The first stars were born from nearly pristine gas, so the oldest survivors have the fewest metals, while young disc stars formed from gas recycled many times. Astronomers measure this with the iron ratio

[\mathrm{Fe/H}] = \log_{10}\frac{(\mathrm{Fe/H})_{\text{star}}}{(\mathrm{Fe/H})_{\text{Sun}}}

so the Sun has \([\mathrm{Fe/H}] = 0\).

Worked example: reading the iron ratio

1. A halo star has one hundredth of the Sun's iron-to-hydrogen ratio. Its value is \(\log_{10}(0.01) = -2.0\). 2. A globular cluster has \([\mathrm{Fe/H}] = -1.5\). Its iron share relative to the Sun is \(10^{-1.5} = 0.032\), about one thirtieth. 3. The record-holding star with under a ten-millionth of the Sun's iron has \([\mathrm{Fe/H}]\) below \(\log_{10}(10^{-7}) = -7\). 4. A young disc star with \([\mathrm{Fe/H}] = +0.2\) has \(10^{0.2} = 1.6\) times the Sun's share. 5. Check: each step of 1 in the ratio is a factor of 10, so negative values mean metal-poor stars, usually old ones.

The real world is messier

Two neat populations are a useful start but an oversimplification. The thick disc is intermediate in age, metals and orbits. The central bulge is old, mostly over 10 billion years, yet its stars are about as metal-rich as the Sun. A likely reason is that star formation in the crowded young bulge was fast and furious: the first massive stars exploded within a few million years and enriched the gas before most bulge stars formed. The Small Magellanic Cloud shows the opposite. Even its young stars are metal-poor, because it forms stars slowly and its weak gravity lets supernova-heated gas escape. A star's metals depend on how much recycling its region had done, not on its age alone.

Model one: a collapsing cloud

In 1962 Olin Eggen, Donald Lynden-Bell and Allan Sandage proposed that the galaxy formed from the rapid collapse of a single huge, slowly rotating gas cloud. The halo stars and globular clusters formed first, while the cloud was still roughly spherical, so they kept their random, tilted orbits. The remaining gas, already enriched by those first stars, collapsed into a spinning disc, just as a collapsing cloud forms a disc around a young star, and later generations of metal-richer stars formed there. This explains the halo's shape and old age and the disc's flatness, rotation and higher metals. It does not explain why halo clusters have a spread of ages and orbits.

Model two: built by mergers

In 1978 Leonard Searle and Robert Zinn suggested that the outer halo was gathered from many small fragments over billions of years. The evidence for this has become overwhelming. In 1994 Rodrigo Ibata, Gerry Gilmore and Mike Irwin found the Sagittarius dwarf galaxy being torn apart on the far side of the galactic centre; the globular cluster M54 appears to be its core. Long streams of stars stripped from dwarf galaxies and clusters loop through the halo. In 2018 Gaia data revealed debris from a sizeable galaxy, Gaia-Enceladus or the Gaia Sausage, that merged roughly 8 to 11 billion years ago, supplying much of the inner halo and perhaps stirring up the thick disc. Today's view combines both models.

Worked example: when might Andromeda arrive?

The Andromeda Galaxy is about 2.5 million ly away and approaching at about 110 km/s. Estimate the crossing time, assuming a straight head-on path at constant speed. 1. Distance: \(2.5 \times 10^6 \times 9.46 \times 10^{15} = 2.37 \times 10^{22}\) m. 2. Time: \(t = \frac{d}{v} = \frac{2.37 \times 10^{22}}{1.10 \times 10^5} = 2.15 \times 10^{17}\) s. 3. Convert: \(\frac{2.15 \times 10^{17}}{3.156 \times 10^7} = 6.8 \times 10^9\) years. 4. Check the assumptions: mutual gravity would speed the approach, and any sideways motion could make the galaxies miss on a first pass. A 2025 study using Hubble and Gaia data put the chance of a merger within 10 billion years at only about 50%, so the future is uncertain.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, assuming population I means young; the Sun and some 10-billion-year-old disc stars belong to it. Second, thinking metals means only iron or industrial metals; astronomers call every element heavier than helium a metal. Third, reading \([\mathrm{Fe/H}] = -2\) as twice as poor; it is a hundred times poorer. Fourth, assuming age alone sets a star's metals, which the bulge and Small Magellanic Cloud disprove. Fifth, treating collapse and mergers as rival answers; the evidence supports both.

Key takeaways

Baade (1944) split stars into population I, disc stars on circular orbits with roughly 1 to 4% metals, and population II, old halo and globular cluster stars on tilted orbits with far fewer metals. Each generation enriches the gas, so older stars are usually metal-poorer, measured by [Fe/H], a base-10 logarithm relative to the Sun. The bulge is old but metal-rich, the Small Magellanic Cloud young but metal-poor. The galaxy formed partly by collapse (Eggen, Lynden-Bell and Sandage, 1962) and partly by mergers (Searle and Zinn, 1978), confirmed by the Sagittarius dwarf, stellar streams and Gaia-Enceladus. An Andromeda merger is possible but uncertain.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Walter Baade, 1944

Defined stellar populations I and II

Wartime dark skies over Mount Wilson.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

A star has one thousandth of the Sun's iron-to-hydrogen ratio. What is its [Fe/H]?

Question 2 of 5

Why are the oldest stars in the galaxy poor in elements heavier than helium?

Question 3 of 5

Which of these is a population I star?

Question 4 of 5

Which observation most directly supports the idea that the Milky Way grew by swallowing smaller galaxies?

Question 5 of 5

Ignoring gravity and sideways motion, how long would Andromeda take to cover 2.5 million light-years at 110 km/s?

← Previous topicNext topic →