Astronomy › Section W · Life in the universe › Topic W.3
The search for extraterrestrial intelligence
If anyone out there has built radio transmitters or lasers, we might detect their technology across many light-years. The search for extraterrestrial intelligence, SETI, has found no confirmed signal yet, and a simple equation shows why the answer depends on questions nobody can yet settle.
Travel or talk?
Finding microbes, the goal of Searching for life beyond Earth, would be momentous, but many people asking whether we are alone mean beings with technology. There are two ways to make contact: travel, or exchange messages. Friends on opposite sides of the world would rather send an email than fly to meet, because messages are fast and cheap. Across interstellar distances that difference becomes enormous.
Worked example: the cost of going
1. Voyager 1, one of the fastest objects leaving the solar system, travels at about 17 km/s. The nearest star is 4.24 light-years (ly) away, \(4.01 \times 10^{16}\) m. Time: \(\frac{4.01 \times 10^{16}}{1.7 \times 10^4} = 2.36 \times 10^{12}\) s, about 75,000 years. 2. To arrive within a human lifetime, a ship needs a good fraction of the speed of light. Assume a 10,000-tonne (\(10^7\) kg) crewed ship at one tenth of light speed, \(3.0 \times 10^7\) m/s. Its kinetic energy is \(\frac{1}{2}mv^2 = 0.5(10^7)(3.0 \times 10^7)^2 = 4.5 \times 10^{21}\) J. 3. Humanity uses roughly \(6 \times 10^{20}\) J a year, so that is about 7.5 years of all the world's energy, before counting fuel, braking or the trip home. 4. Check: travel is slow or ruinously expensive; light is neither.
What about UFOs?
Many people sincerely report unexplained lights or objects in the sky, and they deserve investigation. Most turn out to have ordinary causes: bright planets, meteors, satellites, balloons, aircraft, drones or camera effects. A few stay unexplained, usually because the data are too poor. No sighting has ever left physical evidence shown in a laboratory to be of non-Earth origin. A NASA independent study team in 2023 and a 2024 report by the US Defense Department's office for unidentified anomalous phenomena both found no evidence of extraterrestrial technology. Given the cost of interstellar travel, astronomers see no good reason to think visitors are here.
Why radio?
Electromagnetic waves travel at the fastest possible speed, and radio is the natural choice for messages: it is cheap to generate, passes through interstellar dust and through planetary atmospheres like ours, and the galaxy is relatively quiet at some frequencies. In 1959 the physicists Giuseppe Cocconi and Philip Morrison suggested listening near the 21-cm line of hydrogen, at 1420 MHz, a frequency any radio astronomer would know. The band between about 1 and 10 GHz is especially quiet. Part of it, between the hydrogen line and lines of the hydroxyl molecule near 1.6 GHz, is nicknamed the water hole, since hydrogen and hydroxyl together make water.
Radio searches so far
In 1960 Frank Drake's Project Ozma used a 26-metre dish at Green Bank, West Virginia, to listen to two nearby Sun-like stars, Tau Ceti and Epsilon Eridani, and heard nothing. In 1977 Ohio State University's Big Ear telescope recorded a strong narrowband burst, the Wow! signal, but it never repeated. Modern searches, such as the SETI Institute's Allen Telescope Array and Breakthrough Listen, launched in 2015 with $100 million over ten years, scan millions of channels at once. In 2020 Breakthrough Listen reported a candidate from the direction of Proxima Centauri, BLC1, which later analysis showed was human radio interference. As of 2026, no confirmed signal has been found.
The cosmic haystack
Searchers must guess, or cover, many unknowns: which star, which frequency, how narrow the channel, how strong the signal, whether it is steady or flashes like a lighthouse, how it drifts in frequency, and how it is coded. This is the cosmic haystack problem. Leakage from our own television and radar would be detectable with today's telescopes only from the nearest stars, so most searches look for deliberate beacons. Because we have had radio for only about a century, any civilisation we hear from is likely to be far older and more advanced, which is why most scientists favour listening before shouting.
The Drake equation
At the first SETI conference, at Green Bank in 1961, Drake set out the problem as a chain of factors. The number of civilisations in the galaxy that we could detect now is
Here \(R_*\) is the rate at which suitable stars form each year, \(f_p\) the fraction of stars with planets, \(n_e\) the number of habitable planets per such system, \(f_l\) the fraction of those where life arises, \(f_i\) the fraction that develop intelligence, \(f_c\) the fraction that produce detectable technology, and \(L\) the average number of years they stay detectable. Exoplanet surveys now tell us \(f_p\) is close to 1. The last four factors are pure guesses.
Worked example: two sets of guesses
The values below are illustrative assumptions, not measurements. Take \(R_* = 2\) per year, \(f_p = 1\) and \(n_e = 0.2\). Case A, optimistic: \(f_l = 1\), \(f_i = 0.1\), \(f_c = 0.1\), \(L = 10{,}000\) years. Then \(N = 2 \times 1 \times 0.2 \times 1 \times 0.1 \times 0.1 \times 10{,}000 = 40\). Case B, cautious: \(f_l = 0.01\), \(f_i = 0.01\), \(f_c = 0.1\), \(L = 1{,}000\) years. Then \(N = 2 \times 1 \times 0.2 \times 0.01 \times 0.01 \times 0.1 \times 1{,}000 = 0.004\), meaning we would very likely be alone. Check: the answers differ by a factor of 10,000. Notice that \(N\) is directly proportional to \(L\): long-lived civilisations matter most.
Worked example: how far to the nearest?
Assume \(N\) civilisations spread evenly over the galaxy's disc, treated as a flat circle 100,000 ly across. Each then has an area \(A/N\) to itself, so the typical spacing is \(d \approx \sqrt{A/N}\). 1. Disc area: \(A = \pi(50{,}000)^2 = 7.85 \times 10^9\ \mathrm{ly^2}\). 2. For case A, \(N = 40\): \(d = \sqrt{\frac{7.85 \times 10^9}{40}} = 14{,}000\) ly. A question and its answer would take about 28,000 years. 3. If instead \(N = 1{,}000{,}000\): \(d = 89\) ly, close enough for a conversation over a couple of centuries. 4. Check: more civilisations means closer neighbours, but the spacing shrinks only as the square root of \(N\).
Beyond radio, and should we transmit?
Optical SETI hunts for laser pulses lasting billionths of a second, which could briefly outshine a star in one direction. Other technosignatures include infrared waste heat from vast structures around a star, industrial gases in exoplanet atmospheres, and probes. Humans have sent a few messages: plaques on Pioneer 10 and 11, golden records on the Voyagers launched in 1977, and the 1974 Arecibo radio message aimed at the globular cluster M13, about 25,000 ly away. Whether to send more is debated, and nobody has agreed who should speak for Earth.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, assuming interstellar travel is just a matter of better rockets; the energy cost is staggering. Second, treating unexplained sightings as evidence of visitors; unexplained means unidentified, not alien. Third, reading the Drake equation as a calculation of the answer; most factors are guesses, so it organises our ignorance. Fourth, forgetting that \(N\) depends directly on lifetime \(L\). Fifth, saying the Wow! signal or BLC1 proved anything; neither was confirmed, and BLC1 was interference.
Key takeaways
Travel between stars is slow or enormously costly, so SETI looks for messages. Radio is cheap, crosses dust and atmospheres, and is quiet between 1 and 10 GHz, including the water hole. Searches from Project Ozma (1960) to Breakthrough Listen have found no confirmed signal; Wow! (1977) never repeated and BLC1 was interference. The Drake equation, \(N = R_* f_p n_e f_l f_i f_c L\), breaks the question into factors; illustrative guesses give anything from 0.004 to 40 or more. Typical spacing is about \(\sqrt{A/N}\). Laser pulses, infrared waste heat and atmospheric pollutants are other technosignatures.
Flashcards
Flashcard
The search for extraterrestrial intelligence
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
Using N = R* fp ne fl fi fc L with R* = 2 per year, fp = 1, ne = 0.1, fl = 0.5, fi = 0.1, fc = 0.2 and L = 10,000 years, what is N?
Question 2 of 5
Why do most SETI searches use radio waves?
Question 3 of 5
If 1,000 civilisations were spread evenly over a disc 100,000 light-years across, about how far apart would neighbours be?
Question 4 of 5
What is the status of the Wow! signal and the BLC1 candidate?
Question 5 of 5
At 17 km/s, roughly how long would a probe take to reach a star 8.6 light-years away?
