Astronomy › Section L · Analysing starlight and the stellar census › Topic L.6
Measuring stellar masses
Mass decides how brightly a star shines, how long it lives and how it dies, yet no scale can weigh a star. The answer is to watch two stars orbit each other and let gravity do the weighing.
Weighing a star
Of all a star's properties, mass matters most: later topics show that it largely sets a star's luminosity, its lifetime and its final fate. But mass is also the hardest property to measure. Colour gives temperature and spectra give composition, but nothing in a single star's light reveals directly how much matter it contains. Mass shows itself only through gravity, by its pull on something else. Fortunately, many stars come with a natural test object: a companion star in orbit around them.
Binary stars
A binary star is a pair of stars bound by gravity and orbiting each other. They are common: roughly half of Sun-like stars have at least one companion, most massive stars do, and red dwarfs somewhat less often. Some pairs that look close together on the sky are only chance alignments of stars at very different distances; these are called optical doubles. When a telescope shows both stars of a true binary separately, it is a visual binary. Around 1803 William Herschel showed that the two stars of Castor had shifted around each other, the first clear evidence that gravity works beyond the solar system.
Spectroscopic binaries
Many binaries are too close or too distant for any telescope to separate. Their spectra give them away. As the stars orbit, one approaches us while the other recedes, so their spectral lines are Doppler-shifted in opposite directions: each line splits in two, then the pair merges and splits again, over and over. In 1889 Edward Pickering found this in the star Mizar, and Antonia Maury in the star Beta Aurigae. A graph of each star's radial velocity against time is a radial-velocity curve; its repeat time is the orbital period. If one star is too faint, only the other's lines are seen to swing back and forth.
Both stars orbit the centre of mass
Gravity pulls both stars equally hard, so neither sits still: both orbit their common centre of mass, the balance point between them. Like children balancing on a seesaw, the heavier star sits closer to that point, so
where \(a_1\) and \(a_2\) are each star's distance from the centre of mass. Both stars complete an orbit in the same time, so the star with the smaller orbit also moves more slowly. The ratio of their speeds therefore gives the ratio of their masses: \(v_1 / v_2 = M_2 / M_1\). The more massive star moves less.
Kepler's third law for binary stars
Newton's form of Kepler's third law, met in 'Newton's universal law of gravitation', connects the orbit to the total mass. In convenient units it reads
with masses in solar masses (one solar mass, \(M_\odot\), is about \(1.99 \times 10^{30}\) kg), period \(P\) in years, and \(a\), the semi-major axis of one star's orbit relative to the other, in astronomical units (1 AU is about \(1.496 \times 10^{11}\) m). Check it with the Sun and Earth: a 1-year orbit of 1 AU gives a total of 1 solar mass. The law gives only the sum of the masses; the centre of mass splits it.
Worked example: weighing Alpha Centauri A and B
Alpha Centauri A and B orbit each other with a period of 79.9 years and a semi-major axis of 23.3 AU. Star A's orbit around the centre of mass is 0.457 of the separation. Find both masses. 1. Total mass: \(M_A + M_B = \frac{a^3}{P^2} = \frac{23.3^3}{79.9^2} = \frac{12{,}650}{6384} = 1.98\) solar masses. 2. From \(M_A a_A = M_B a_B\), star B's share of the total equals A's share of the separation: \(M_B = 0.457 \times 1.98 = 0.905\). 3. So \(M_A = 1.98 - 0.905 = 1.08\) solar masses. 4. Check: A, the brighter star, is the heavier and has the smaller orbit, as it should.
Masses from spectroscopic binaries
For a spectroscopic binary the orbit is never seen, but it can be rebuilt. The Doppler effect gives each star's orbital speed, the radial-velocity curve gives the period, and speed times period is the distance travelled in one orbit, the circumference. That gives the orbit's size, and Kepler's law then gives the total mass. One catch remains: Doppler shifts measure only motion along our line of sight. If the orbit is tilted, the true speeds are larger than measured, so the masses found are lower limits. Eclipsing binaries, whose orbits we see nearly edge-on, remove this doubt and give the most reliable stellar masses.
Worked example: an eclipsing pair
Two stars eclipse each other every 10.0 days, so we see the circular orbits edge-on. Their Doppler speeds are 60 km/s and 90 km/s. 1. Orbit radius = speed × period ÷ \(2\pi\), with \(P = 8.64 \times 10^5\) s: \(r_1 = 8.25 \times 10^6\) km and \(r_2 = 1.24 \times 10^7\) km. 2. Separation: \(a = 2.06 \times 10^7\) km, or 0.138 AU. 3. Period in years: \(10.0 / 365.25 = 0.0274\). 4. Total mass: \(\frac{0.138^3}{0.0274^2} = 3.50\) solar masses. 5. Split by the speed ratio, \(M_1 / M_2 = 90/60 = 1.5\): \(M_1 = 2.10\) and \(M_2 = 1.40\) solar masses. 6. Check: the slower star is the heavier one.
The range of stellar masses
Measured masses show that stars span a limited but wide range. The lower limit is about 0.075 to 0.08 solar masses; below it, as 'Spectra of stars and brown dwarfs' explained, objects become brown dwarfs. At the top, stars of 100 solar masses or more exist but are extremely rare. The most massive known, R136a1 in the Large Magellanic Cloud, was estimated in 2022 at about 200 solar masses, revised down from earlier estimates of about 300; such figures come from models of a star's light, not from an orbit, so they are less certain. Most stars, as the stellar census showed, are less massive than the Sun.
The mass–luminosity relation
Once masses were measured for many stars, a pattern appeared. For main-sequence stars, which fuse hydrogen in their cores and make up about 90% of stars, luminosity rises steeply with mass. A useful approximation, in solar units, is
So a star of 2 solar masses is about \(2^4 = 16\) times as luminous as the Sun, and one of 0.5 solar masses only about \(0.5^4 = 0.06\). Reversed, \(M \approx L^{1/4}\): a main-sequence star of 81 solar luminosities has about 3 solar masses. The exponent really varies, from below 3 to about 4, so treat results as estimates. White dwarfs and giants do not follow this relation.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, saying one star orbits a fixed partner: both orbit the centre of mass. Second, getting the mass ratio upside down: the faster-moving star, with the larger orbit, is the lighter one. Third, forgetting units in Kepler's law: a in AU, P in years and masses in solar masses, or the simple form fails. Fourth, thinking Kepler's law gives each mass separately: it gives the total. Fifth, using L ≈ M⁴ for giants or white dwarfs, or treating it as exact.
Key takeaways
Stellar masses come from binary stars: visual binaries are seen as two stars, spectroscopic binaries reveal themselves through Doppler shifts, and eclipsing binaries are seen edge-on. Both stars orbit the centre of mass, with M₁a₁ = M₂a₂, so the heavier star moves more slowly. Kepler's third law, (M₁ + M₂)P² = a³ in solar masses, years and AU, gives the total mass. True stars range from about 0.075 to a few hundred solar masses. For main-sequence stars, L ≈ M⁴ in solar units.
Flashcards
Flashcard
Two stars bound by gravity, orbiting each other
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
Two stars orbit each other with a period of 2.0 years and a semi-major axis of 4.0 AU. What is their total mass?
Question 2 of 5
In a binary, star A moves at 20 km/s and star B at 60 km/s around their centre of mass. What can you conclude about their masses?
Question 3 of 5
Using L ≈ M⁴, about how luminous is a main-sequence star of 3 solar masses?
Question 4 of 5
Why are the masses found from a non-eclipsing spectroscopic binary often only lower limits?
Question 5 of 5
What is the approximate lowest mass a true, hydrogen-fusing star can have?
