Astronomy › Section U · Evolution and distribution of galaxies › Topic U.5

Formation and evolution of galaxies and structure

The young universe was astonishingly smooth, yet today it is full of galaxies, clusters, filaments and voids. The leading explanation can be summed up in three words: dark matter, gravity and time.

From smooth to lumpy

The cosmic microwave background shows that about 380,000 years after the Big Bang, the density of the universe varied from place to place by only about one part in 100,000. Today matter is concentrated into galaxies millions of times denser than average, separated by voids. Explaining how a nearly featureless universe became so clumpy is the central problem of this topic. The answer favoured by most cosmologists is that tiny initial differences in density were amplified by gravity over billions of years, with dark matter doing most of the early work. The topics "The cosmic microwave background" and "Inflation and the anthropic principle" discuss where those first differences came from.

Gravity amplifies small differences

Picture a region slightly denser than average. At first it expands along with the universe, but its extra gravity slows its expansion and draws in matter from around it, so it becomes denser still. If the inward pull is strong enough, the region stops expanding and collapses. Meanwhile slightly emptier regions expand faster and empty further, becoming voids. Collapse is rarely even: a lump usually falls in fastest along one direction, forming a flattened sheet, then along a second, forming a filament. Where filaments meet, dense nodes grow into clusters. This is how the cosmic web of sheets, filaments and voids takes shape.

Why dark matter is needed

Before about 380,000 years after the Big Bang, ordinary matter was a hot plasma tightly coupled to light. Radiation pressure kept it from clumping, and it rang with sound waves that left a faint imprint still seen in the distribution of galaxies. Dark matter does not interact with light, so its clumps could start growing earlier. When ordinary matter was finally released, it fell into the dark matter clumps already waiting. Without this head start, the tiny ripples in ordinary matter would not have grown into galaxies in the time available, as the next example shows.

Worked example: can the ripples grow in time?

In the simplest model, while matter dominates, a small density contrast grows in proportion to the size of the universe. Since then the universe has grown by a factor of about 1,100. 1. Ordinary matter alone: a contrast of \(1 \times 10^{-5}\) grows to about \(1 \times 10^{-5} \times 1100 = 0.011\), only about 1%. 2. A clump needs a contrast of roughly 1 before it collapses, so ordinary matter alone falls short by a factor of about 100. 3. Dark matter clumps that had already grown to about \(1 \times 10^{-3}\) reach about \(1 \times 10^{-3} \times 1100 \approx 1\), enough to collapse. 4. Check: the real growth is somewhat less, because dark energy slows it lately, which makes the case for dark matter even stronger.

Bottom-up growth

Whether small or large structures form first depends on the dark matter. Fast-moving hot dark matter would smear out small lumps, so huge structures would form first and break up, a top-down picture. Slow-moving cold dark matter lets small lumps survive, so small objects form first and merge into larger ones, a bottom-up or hierarchical picture. Observations favour the second. The first objects to collapse were about the size of dwarf galaxies or globular clusters, a few per cent of the way through cosmic history. They merged to build galaxies; galaxies gathered into groups, groups into clusters. Clusters are still assembling today, pulling in galaxies and gas along filaments.

Worked example: denser clumps collapse first

A cloud with no pressure support collapses under its own gravity in about the free-fall time,

t = \sqrt{\frac{3\pi}{32\,G\rho}}

where \(\rho\) is its density. Compare a cloud of density \(1 \times 10^{-23}\) kg/m³ with one 100 times denser. 1. First cloud: \(t = \sqrt{\frac{3\pi}{32 \times 6.67 \times 10^{-11} \times 10^{-23}}} = 2.1 \times 10^{16}\) s. 2. In years: \(\frac{2.1 \times 10^{16}}{3.156 \times 10^{7}} \approx 6.7 \times 10^{8}\), about 670 million years. 3. The denser cloud: \(t\) varies as \(\frac{1}{\sqrt{\rho}}\), so it is \(\sqrt{100} = 10\) times shorter, about 67 million years. 4. Check: the densest seeds collapse first, which is why the oldest star systems formed in the densest regions.

How elliptical galaxies formed

Astronomers once debated two pictures for giant ellipticals: a single rapid collapse of one huge cloud, or the merging of many smaller galaxies that had already made stars. The evidence suggests both happened. Some massive galaxies and quasars existed less than a billion years after the Big Bang, which fits early, rapid collapse. Yet mature giant ellipticals were rare until the universe was about 6 billion years old, which fits growth by mergers. Most ellipticals had converted their gas to stars by the time the universe was a few billion years old and have formed few stars since, so they are often called "red and dead".

How spirals formed

Spiral galaxies have a two-stage history. Their bulges and halos hold old stars and formed early, much like small ellipticals. Their discs formed later, as gas that still had rotation settled into a flat, spinning layer and kept making stars; in the Milky Way, disc stars are younger on average than those in the bulge and halo. Spirals still contain gas and dust, but their star formation is now several times slower than it was 8 billion years ago. Hubble once guessed that ellipticals evolve into spirals. The evidence points the other way: merging spirals can become an elliptical, and the Milky Way is still adding small galaxies to its halo.

Testing the picture

Theorists test these ideas with huge computer simulations that start from the smooth early universe, add dark matter, ordinary matter and dark energy in measured amounts, and let gravity act for 13.8 billion years. A mixture of about 5% ordinary matter, 27% cold dark matter and 68% dark energy reproduces the cosmic web, the numbers of clusters and many properties of galaxies. Some puzzles remain. Webb has found more bright galaxies in the first few hundred million years than many models predicted, and the cores and satellite counts of small galaxies do not always match. Many researchers think better models of gas and star formation will resolve these, but the questions are open.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, thinking big structures formed first and broke into galaxies; in the favoured cold dark matter picture, small objects formed first and merged. Second, assuming ordinary matter could clump alone; its early ripples were too small and were held back by radiation. Third, thinking ellipticals turn into spirals; it is more likely the reverse. Fourth, forgetting that the free-fall time falls as density rises, so dense clumps collapse first. Fifth, presenting the model as finished; it explains a great deal, but puzzles from Webb and small galaxies remain.

Key takeaways

The early universe varied in density by only about one part in 100,000. Gravity amplified denser regions into sheets, filaments and clusters, leaving voids. Dark matter, free of radiation pressure, began clumping first, and ordinary matter fell into its clumps. Cold dark matter makes growth bottom-up: small objects formed first and merged into galaxies, groups and clusters. Denser clouds collapse faster, since the free-fall time varies as 1 ÷ √ρ. Giant ellipticals formed early and by mergers; spirals built bulges early and discs later. Simulations with 5% ordinary matter, 27% dark matter and 68% dark energy match much of what we see.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Early density ripples

About one part in 100,000, 380,000 years after the Big Bang

Seen in the cosmic microwave background.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

In the cold dark matter picture favoured by observations, in what order did structures form?

Question 2 of 5

A density ripple of 2 × 10⁻⁵ grows in proportion to the size of the universe, which has grown about 1,100 times since the CMB was released. Roughly what contrast does it reach?

Question 3 of 5

Why could dark matter begin clumping before ordinary matter did?

Question 4 of 5

Cloud B is 25 times denser than cloud A. Using t = √(3π ÷ 32Gρ), how do their collapse times compare?

Question 5 of 5

Which statement about the formation of spiral galaxies matches the evidence?

← Previous topicNext topic →