Astronomy › Section M · Celestial distances › Topic M.3
Variable stars as distance markers
Parallax runs out within our own galaxy. A class of pulsating stars whose rhythm reveals their true power carried distance measurement to other galaxies, thanks to a discovery by Henrietta Swan Leavitt.
The standard-candle idea
A dim star might be a feeble one nearby or a powerful one far away; its apparent brightness alone cannot tell you which. As The brightness of stars showed, the light we receive follows the inverse-square law:
where \(b\) is the apparent brightness (power per square metre at Earth), \(L\) the luminosity and \(d\) the distance. If some independent clue reveals \(L\), measuring \(b\) gives \(d\). An object of known luminosity used this way is called a standard candle. Certain variable stars turned out to be excellent standard candles, bright enough to see across intergalactic space.
Light curves
A variable star, unlike the steady Sun, changes its brightness noticeably. The record of its brightness against time is its light curve. The brightest point is the maximum, the faintest the minimum, and for a star that repeats regularly, the time from one maximum to the next is the period. Some stars vary because a companion passes in front of them, the eclipsing binaries met in Diameters of stars. Others vary because the star itself changes.
Pulsating stars
A pulsating variable star rhythmically swells and shrinks, rather like a chest breathing. The spectrum shows it: as the surface rushes towards us its lines shift to the blue, and as it falls back they shift to the red, the pattern described in The Doppler effect. The star's colour, and so its surface temperature, changes through each cycle as well, and its luminosity rises and falls with a fixed rhythm. Pulsation is a temporary, unstable stage late in a star's life, when a layer in its outer envelope traps and releases heat like a valve.
Cepheid variables
Cepheids are luminous yellow supergiants named after Delta Cephei, whose variations John Goodricke, a deaf young astronomer in York, discovered in 1784. Delta Cephei brightens quickly and fades more slowly over a period of about 5.4 days. Most classical Cepheids have periods between about 1 and 50 days and luminosities from a few hundred to tens of thousands of times the Sun's, so they can be seen in other galaxies. Polaris, the North Star, is a Cepheid with a period of about 4 days. Its brightness changes have varied noticeably over the past century, a reminder that pulsation is a phase that stars pass through.
Leavitt's discovery
Henrietta Swan Leavitt worked at Harvard College Observatory, one of a team of women who measured photographic plates for low pay. Studying plates of the Small Magellanic Cloud, she found that its brighter-appearing Cepheids always had longer periods; she noted the trend in 1908 and published a clear relation for 25 stars in 1912. Her key insight was that every star in the cloud lies at nearly the same distance from us, so differences in apparent brightness must be differences in true luminosity. This is the period-luminosity relation, now often called the Leavitt law: the longer a Cepheid's period, the more luminous it is.
Calibrating the relation
Leavitt could show that period and luminosity were linked, but not the actual luminosities, because nobody then knew how far away the Small Magellanic Cloud was. Astronomers had to measure the distances of a few Cepheids by other means, first through star clusters and statistics and today through Hubble and Gaia parallaxes. In magnitudes, one widely used calibration is
with \(P\) in days and \(M_V\) the absolute visual magnitude, the magnitude the star would have at 10 parsecs (pc). Comparing it with the apparent magnitude \(m\) gives the distance: \(m - M = 5\log_{10} d - 5\), with \(d\) in parsecs.
Worked example: a Cepheid in a nearby galaxy
A Cepheid in the Small Magellanic Cloud has a period of 10.0 days and an average apparent magnitude of 15.0. How far away is it? 1. Period gives luminosity: \(\log_{10} 10 = 1\), so \(M_V = -2.43(0) - 4.05 = -4.05\). 2. Distance modulus: \(m - M = 15.0 - (-4.05) = 19.05\). 3. Solve:
about 211,000 light-years. 4. Check: published distances to the Small Magellanic Cloud are about 62,000 pc, so one star gets within about 5%. Astronomers average many Cepheids and correct for dust, which dims and reddens starlight.
Worked example: using luminosity directly
A Cepheid's period shows a luminosity of 5,000 solar luminosities, \(L = 5000 \times 3.83 \times 10^{26} = 1.92 \times 10^{30}\) W. Its average measured brightness is \(b = 1.0 \times 10^{-13}\ \mathrm{W\,m^{-2}}\). Find its distance. 1. Rearrange the inverse-square law: \(d = \sqrt{\frac{L}{4\pi b}}\). 2. Substitute:
3. Convert: \(\frac{1.24 \times 10^{21}}{3.09 \times 10^{16}} = 4.0 \times 10^4\) pc, about 130,000 light-years. 4. Check: brightness falls as \(1/d^2\), so a star nine times fainter but with the same period would be three times farther.
RR Lyrae stars
RR Lyrae variables, named after the star RR Lyrae, are older, less massive pulsating stars. Their periods are always under a day, typically about half a day, and their brightness typically changes by a factor of about two. They are far less luminous than Cepheids, but they have one convenient property: they all have nearly the same average luminosity, about 50 times the Sun's, or an absolute magnitude near +0.6. Common in globular clusters and the Milky Way's halo, they map our galaxy and its nearest neighbours. An RR Lyrae star of apparent magnitude 15.6 has \(m - M = 15.0\), so it lies at \(10^{(15.0 + 5)/5} = 10{,}000\) pc.
Cepheids and the galaxies
Cepheids soon reshaped the universe. In 1923 to 1924 Edwin Hubble found Cepheids in the Andromeda Nebula and, in results announced in 1925, showed it lies far outside the Milky Way, settling that such nebulae are separate galaxies. In 1952 Walter Baade showed there are two kinds of Cepheids with different luminosities; correcting the mix-up roughly doubled the distances to other galaxies. Today the Hubble Space Telescope and the James Webb Space Telescope measure Cepheids in galaxies more than 100 million light-years away. They calibrate the supernova distances in The extragalactic distance scale, and they sit at the centre of the debate over the Hubble constant.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, assuming all variable stars follow a period-luminosity relation: eclipsing binaries do not, and Cepheids and RR Lyrae stars follow different rules. Second, reading the relation backwards: a longer period means a more luminous star, not a closer one. Third, using a single brightness instead of the average over a full cycle. Fourth, forgetting the inverse square: a star with the same luminosity but nine times fainter is three times farther, not nine. Fifth, ignoring dust, which dims stars and makes them seem farther than they are.
Key takeaways
A standard candle has a known luminosity L, so its brightness b gives its distance through b = L/(4πd²). A light curve shows a variable star's brightness against time; its repeat time is the period. Pulsating stars change size, temperature and luminosity in a regular rhythm. Leavitt found in the Small Magellanic Cloud (1908, 1912) that longer-period Cepheids are more luminous. Calibrated by parallaxes, this relation measures distances to galaxies over 100 million light-years away. RR Lyrae stars all have about 50 solar luminosities and map our galaxy. Hubble's Cepheids proved Andromeda is a separate galaxy.
Flashcards
Flashcard
An object of known luminosity used to find distance
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
Two Cepheids have the same period, but one appears 9 times fainter than the other. How do their distances compare?
Question 2 of 5
Why was the Small Magellanic Cloud ideal for Leavitt's discovery?
Question 3 of 5
An RR Lyrae star has absolute magnitude +0.6 and apparent magnitude 14.6. How far away is it?
Question 4 of 5
Cepheid A has a period of 30 days and Cepheid B a period of 3 days. What does the period-luminosity relation tell you?
Question 5 of 5
What causes the brightness changes of a pulsating variable star such as a Cepheid?
