Biology › Section J · Evolution › Topic J.6
Adaptive evolution
Natural selection shapes heritable variation in five recognisable ways, from keeping the average to pushing one extreme or both. Fitness, not strength, decides who wins.
What adaptive evolution is
Natural selection screens every generation. It selects for heritable traits that help their owners survive and reproduce, so those alleles spread, and it selects against harmful alleles, so those decline. That shifting of allele frequencies, generation after generation, is adaptive evolution. The word adaptive matters: selection is the only evolutionary force that consistently improves the fit between a population and its environment. Drift and gene flow, covered earlier, change frequencies too — but randomly, with no regard for usefulness.
Selection acts on organisms, not alleles
Selection judges whole individuals. An animal might carry a genotype that would make it extraordinarily fertile — but if it also carries an allele that kills it before reproductive age, the fertility allele dies with it and never reaches the next generation. There is no way for selection to save a good allele from a bad individual carrying it. A related idea: what counts is not surviving or being strong, but contributing to the next generation's gene pool. That contribution is an organism's evolutionary, or Darwinian, fitness, and scientists measure it in the field by counting offspring. Because one individual's success only matters compared with the rest of the population, biologists work with relative fitness.
Worked example: Calculating relative fitness
In a population, parents of genotype AA raise on average 12 offspring to adulthood, Aa parents raise 6, and aa parents raise 0. 1. Start from the raw contributions: 12, 6, and 0 offspring. 2. Divide each by the largest value, 12, so the best genotype scores 1.0. 3. The relative fitnesses are therefore AA = 1.0, Aa = 0.5, and aa = 0. 4. Check the logic: the aa genotype contributes nothing at all, which is exactly what a fitness of zero means. 5. Prediction: over generations, the A allele's frequency rises and the a allele's falls, because AA individuals pour the most genes into the next pool.
Stabilizing selection
When the environment consistently favours an average phenotype and selects against both extremes, the population undergoes stabilizing selection. Woodland mice whose fur best matches the fairly uniform brown of the forest floor escape predators; mice that are paler or darker stand out and get eaten. Over generations the bell curve of fur colour narrows around the average and the population's variation shrinks. Nothing new appears — the middle simply gets safer while the tails of the distribution are trimmed off.
Directional selection
When the environment changes so that one extreme of a trait becomes the best, directional selection shifts the whole population toward that extreme. Introduce flower-eating rabbits to a meadow and taller flowering plants survive to reproduce while shorter ones are eaten; over generations the average height of the plant population climbs. The peppered moth tells the same story in reverse: as industrial soot darkened the trees, the darker moths became better camouflaged and came to dominate the population. The result is a bell curve that slides to a new centre, still one peak, but moved.
Diversifying selection
Sometimes both extremes beat the middle. In diversifying selection, two or more distinct phenotypes each have an advantage while the intermediate forms are, on average, less fit. A beach with light-coloured sand broken by patches of tall dark grass favours mice that are very light or very dark — each has a background that hides it — while medium-coloured mice match neither and fall to predators. The outcome is the opposite of stabilizing selection: genetic variance increases, and the single bell curve splits toward two peaks.
Worked example: Reading a shifted distribution
Researchers classed a mouse population's fur as light, medium, or dark. Before a new predator arrived: light 210, medium 560, dark 230. After 15 generations: light 430, medium 95, dark 475. 1. The starting counts form a bell curve with one peak in the middle (medium). 2. In the later counts both extremes grew while the middle collapsed — medium fell from 560 to 95. 3. Both extremes favoured and the average selected against is the signature of diversifying selection. 4. Check the alternatives: stabilizing would have kept medium on top, and directional would have grown one extreme while the other shrank. 5. Prediction: fur-colour variance in this population should keep rising, with the two extremes pulling apart.
Frequency-dependent selection
In frequency-dependent selection, a phenotype's success depends on how common it is. Negative frequency-dependent selection favours the rare: male side-blotched lizards come in orange, blue, and yellow throats, each with a strategy — orange fight, blue guard a mate, yellow sneak. It works like rock-paper-scissors: orange beats blue, blue beats yellow, yellow beats orange. Whichever colour is rarest wins, so the populations cycle: orange dominates, then yellow rises, then blue, then orange again. Negative frequency dependence maintains variation by constantly rescuing rare phenotypes. Positive frequency-dependent selection is the mirror image: the common phenotype wins and the rare one fades, eroding variation.
Sexual selection
Mates are won, not just survived for. Sexual selection is selection driven by access to mating, and it builds secondary sexual characteristics — the peacock's enormous tail, the deer's antlers, bright colour in males. It can be stronger than ordinary survival pressure: a peacock's tail makes him slower and more visible to predators, yet males with the largest, most colourful tails win the females. The result is often sexual dimorphism, a persistent visible difference between the sexes. Sexual selection explains traits that natural selection alone would strip away.
Why females choose costly ornaments
Three ideas address the puzzle. The handicap principle: a heavy, risky tail honestly advertises quality, because only a genuinely strong male survives carrying one — the risk itself is the proof. The good genes hypothesis: ornaments display efficient metabolism or disease resistance, so a female choosing a flashy male is choosing good genes for her offspring. The Fisherian runaway model, proposed by Ronald Fisher in 1915, says preference and ornament can feed each other: females prefer long tails, so males grow longer ones, and sons inherit the tail while daughters inherit the preference, each trait amplifying the other until the cost to survival halts the runaway.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, fitness is not physical strength — it is reproductive contribution, and a frail individual that leaves many offspring is fitter than a strong one that leaves none. Second, match the curve to the force: stabilizing trims both extremes, directional moves one peak, diversifying builds two. If the middle survives best, it is not diversifying. Third, frequency-dependent selection is not about the environment changing — the environment stays put, and rarity itself is the advantage. Fourth, sexual selection is still selection, even when it harms survival; mating success, not survival, is what counts there. Fifth, do not call every change adaptive — drift can spread a harmful allele, and evolution has no direction.
Key takeaways
Adaptive evolution is natural selection shifting allele frequencies: for helpful heritable traits, against harmful ones. Fitness measures contribution to the next gene pool, always relative to others. Stabilizing selection keeps the average, directional shifts toward one extreme, diversifying favours both extremes, frequency-dependent selection rewards or punishes rarity, and sexual selection builds costly ornaments that win mates. Evolution aims at nothing: selection simply makes the most of the heritable variation that happens to exist, while drift and gene flow shuffle on regardless.
Flashcards
Flashcard
Selection shifting allele frequencies toward helpful heritable traits
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
On a beach of light sand with patches of dark grass, very light mice and very dark mice both survive well, while medium-coloured mice are eaten most often. Which type of selection is this?
Question 2 of 5
Rabbits that eat the flowers of short plants are introduced to a meadow. Over many generations, the average flower height of the plant population climbs. Which type of selection occurred?
Question 3 of 5
Parents of genotype AA raise 12 offspring on average, Aa parents raise 6, and aa parents raise 0. What is the relative fitness of the Aa genotype?
Question 4 of 5
In side-blotched lizards, when orange-throated males dominate the population, yellow-throated sneaker males begin to rise in frequency. What is this an example of?
Question 5 of 5
A peacock's tail makes him slower and more visible to predators, yet females prefer the largest tails. Which idea explains that the tail's very riskiness proves male quality?
