Biology › Section G · Chromosomes and DNA › Topic G.3

Discovering DNA and its structure

For nearly a century after its discovery, DNA was dismissed as too simple to carry heredity — proteins looked the likelier library. A chain of elegant experiments overturned that: Griffith's dead bacteria that killed, Avery's enzymes, Hershey and Chase's radioactive phage, Chargaff's suspiciously paired ratios. Then one X-ray photo let Watson, Crick, and Franklin's data reveal the double helix — and its structure immediately explained how it copies and stores information.

Nuclein: the first isolation

In the 1860s, physician Friedrich Miescher isolated phosphate-rich chemicals from the nuclei of white blood cells (leukocytes) and named the unknown substance nuclein — later recognised as DNA and RNA. Nobody suspected it carried heredity: proteins, with their twenty amino-acid alphabet, seemed far better suited to storing information than a repetitive sugar-phosphate chain. It took a century of experiments to prove otherwise.

Griffith's transformation experiments (1928)

British bacteriologist Frederick Griffith gave the first demonstration that hereditary information can move horizontally between cells — not just down from parent to daughter. Working with Streptococcus pneumoniae, he used two strains: the R (rough) strain, non-pathogenic because its surface lacks a capsule, and the S (smooth) strain, pathogenic thanks to its capsule. Injected alone, live R bacteria left mice healthy; heat-killed S bacteria did the same. But injecting live R together with heat-killed S killed the mice — and only live S bacteria could be recovered from the corpses. Something from the dead S cells had entered the living R cells and transformed them into the pathogenic form. Griffith called it the transforming principle.

Avery, MacLeod, and McCarty: the elimination

In 1944, three researchers — Oswald Avery, Colin MacLeod, and Maclyn McCarty — hunted the transforming principle systematically. They prepared mixtures from killed S cells, degraded each candidate with a specific enzyme — protease for protein, RNase for RNA, DNase for DNA — and tested whether each could still transform R bacteria. Every mixture transformed except the one whose DNA had been destroyed. The conclusion was unavoidable: DNA, not protein, was the transforming principle and the substance of heredity.

Hershey and Chase: the decisive phage

In 1952, Martha Chase and Alfred Hershey settled the question with a virus. A bacteriophage — here T2 — is simple: a protein capsid around a nucleic acid core, infecting bacteria by injecting the core while the coat stays outside. That division of labour was the trick. Protein carries sulfur but no phosphorus; DNA carries phosphorus but no sulfur — so labelling one batch of phage with radioactive ³⁵S marked only the coats, and labelling another with ³²P marked only the DNA. Let each batch infect Escherichia coli, blend the coats off, and centrifuge: heavy bacterial cells pellet at the bottom, light coats float in the supernatant.

Worked example: reading the Hershey-Chase tubes

Predict each tube's radioactivity, step by step. (1) The phage injects only its genetic material; whatever enters the cell must be the hereditary molecule. (2) ³⁵S tube: the label rides the protein coats, which stay outside — after blending, the radioactivity stays with the empty coats in the supernatant, none in the pellet. (3) ³²P tube: the label rides the DNA, which enters — after blending, the radioactivity sits in the bacterial pellet, and new phage carry ³²P onward when the cells burst. (4) Conclusion: DNA is injected, copied, and passed to offspring phage — the genetic material, not protein. (5) The design converts a chemical question into a location question: the blender separates entry from non-entry.

Chargaff's rules

Austrian biochemist Erwin Chargaff measured the base composition of DNA across species and found two things. First, the percentages of A, T, G, and C vary from one species to the next — yet hold steady among individuals of a single species, making base composition a molecular signature of each species. Second, in every sample the amount of adenine equals thymine and guanine equals cytosine: A = T and G = C. Those equalities hinted at paired relationships years before anyone saw the structure, and gave Watson and Crick exactly what their model needed.

The nucleotide: DNA's building block

DNA is a polymer of nucleotides, each built from a nitrogenous base, a deoxyribose sugar (carbons numbered 1' through 5'), and a phosphate group. The bases split into two shapes: purines — adenine (A) and guanine (G) — with a double ring built of two fused rings, and pyrimidines — cytosine (C) and thymine (T) — with a single six-membered ring. Nucleotides link into a strand through phosphodiester bonds: the phosphate joins the 5' carbon of one sugar to the 3' carbon of the next, giving every strand a built-in 5'-to-3' direction — a detail that will matter enormously for replication.

The double helix: Franklin's photo, Watson and Crick's model

In the 1950s, Rosalind Franklin, in Maurice Wilkins' lab, probed DNA with X-ray diffraction; her photographs revealed the molecule's shape and dimensions, and James Watson and Francis Crick — who saw her data — pieced the structure together, publishing in 1953: two strands twisted into a right-handed helix. The strands are complementary and anti-parallel — where one runs 5' to 3', its partner runs 3' to 5'. Base pairing always joins a purine with a pyrimidine: A with T (two hydrogen bonds) and G with C (three), the base pairs stacked inside and the sugar-phosphate backbones outside. Watson, Crick, and Wilkins shared the 1962 Nobel Prize; Franklin had died by then, and the prize is never awarded posthumously.

Helix dimensions and grooves

The X-ray data fixed the geometry: neighbouring base pairs sit 0.34 nm apart, one full turn spans 3.4 nm, so ten base pairs stack per turn, and the diameter is a uniform 2 nm throughout. That uniformity is itself evidence for the pairing rule — only a purine-plus-pyrimidine combination keeps the width constant; two purines would bulge, two pyrimidines would pinch. The twist also carves two spiral grooves — a wide major and a narrow minor — binding sites for the DNA-binding proteins that run transcription and replication.

Worked example: Chargaff arithmetic

A DNA sample is 15% adenine — deduce the rest. (1) By Chargaff's rules, A = T, so thymine is also 15%; together A + T = 30%. (2) The remaining 70% must split equally between G and C, since G = C. (3) So: 15% A, 15% T, 35% G, 35% C — sum 100%. (4) Note that both AT-rich and GC-rich genomes exist — the AT:GC ratio varies by species. (5) The deeper implication: strict pairing means each strand holds all the information to rebuild the other — the physical basis of replication.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, thinking Griffith proved DNA was the transforming principle — he only named it; Avery, MacLeod, and McCarty identified it 16 years later. Second, mixing up the Hershey-Chase labels: protein carries sulfur, DNA carries phosphorus. Third, assuming Chargaff's rules force a 50/50 AT-to-GC split — A must equal T and G must equal C, but the AT:GC ratio varies freely between species. Fourth, pairing purine with purine — a double-ring base must face a single-ring base, which is exactly what keeps the 2 nm diameter uniform. Fifth, forgetting anti-parallelism — the strands run in opposite directions. Sixth, crediting Franklin with a Nobel — she died before the 1962 award, which is never given posthumously.

Key takeaways

DNA won the molecule-of-heredity contest through elimination: Miescher isolated nuclein from cell nuclei (1860s); Griffith's live-R-plus-heat-killed-S mice showed a transforming principle moving horizontally (1928); Avery, MacLeod, and McCarty's enzyme knockouts left DNA the only candidate (1944); Hershey and Chase's ³⁵S/³²P phage showed only DNA enters cells (1952); Chargaff found A = T and G = C, species-specific. The structure Watson and Crick proposed in 1953 on Franklin's X-ray data closes the case: a right-handed double helix of complementary, anti-parallel strands; purine-pyrimidine pairs (A-T with two hydrogen bonds, G-C with three) stacked 0.34 nm apart, ten per 3.4 nm turn, inside a uniform 2 nm diameter with major and minor grooves for protein binding. The pairing rules are a checksum for every genome — and the mechanism by which each strand templates the other.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Nuclein

Miescher's name for nuclear phosphate-rich chemicals

Isolated 1860s from leukocyte nuclei; later DNA and RNA.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

In Griffith's experiments, mice died when injected with heat-killed S-strain bacteria mixed with live R-strain bacteria. What did this reveal?

Question 2 of 5

In the Hershey-Chase experiments, where was the radioactive phosphorus (³²P) found after blending and centrifuging?

Question 3 of 5

A species' DNA is 30% adenine. What is its guanine percentage?

Question 4 of 5

Why does a DNA double helix maintain a uniform 2 nm diameter along its entire length?

Question 5 of 5

How many hydrogen bonds hold guanine to cytosine, and how many hold adenine to thymine?

← Previous topicNext topic →