Biology › Section H · Gene expression and its regulation › Topic H.3

Eukaryotic transcription and RNA processing

Prokaryotes transcribe with one polymerase and translate immediately; eukaryotes keep their genes behind a nuclear membrane, split the work across three polymerases, and put every raw transcript through finishing school - caps, tails, and splicing - before it ever meets a ribosome.

Same process, new address

Prokaryotes and eukaryotes transcribe fundamentally the same way - but the eukaryotic setting changes the logistics. Genes live inside a membrane-bound nucleus, so every transcript must be shipped out to the cytoplasm for translation, and it must survive the trip. Eukaryotes therefore invest heavily in protecting and processing their mRNA. They also split transcription across three different RNA polymerases, each with its own subset of genes, and their mRNAs are usually monogenic - one transcript, one protein.

The three RNA polymerases

RNA polymerase I works in the nucleolus and makes all the ribosomal RNA except one molecule, the 5S rRNA. RNA polymerase II works in the nucleus and makes every protein-coding pre-mRNA - the overwhelming majority of eukaryotic genes. RNA polymerase III, also nuclear, handles the leftovers: the 5S rRNA, the transfer RNAs, and the small nuclear RNAs that later help splice mRNA. Each polymerase has ten or more subunits (prokaryotes get by with five), and each requires its own distinct set of helper proteins to reach the DNA.

The mushroom poison test

How do you tell which polymerase reads a new gene? Feed it alpha-amanitin, the poison of the Death Cap mushroom, and watch. The three polymerases respond very differently: polymerase I is completely insensitive and keeps transcribing; polymerase II is extremely sensitive and halts almost immediately; polymerase III is moderately sensitive. So a gene that falls silent at low poison levels was read by polymerase II - a strong hint it encodes a protein. A cheap diagnostic that turns a toxin into a lab tool.

A bigger, busier promoter

Eukaryotic promoters dwarf their prokaryotic counterparts. The core element is a TATA box - in the mouse thymidine kinase gene, the sequence TATAAAA sits about 30 base pairs upstream of the start site. Its A-T richness is the point: those bonds are easy to melt, helping the template locally unwind. Beyond it, the same promoter carries a CAAT box around -80 and often GC-rich and octamer boxes further upstream - elements that bind factors boosting initiation efficiency, common in genes the cell expresses constantly.

Transcription factors build the platform

The prokaryotic polymerase binds a promoter alone. Its eukaryotic counterpart cannot: proteins called transcription factors must bind the promoter first and recruit the polymerase to the DNA. For polymerase II, these are the basal transcription factors, named TFII plus a letter from A to J. They assemble stepwise into a preinitiation complex, each factor stabilizing the platform until polymerase II joins and transcription begins. Enhancers and silencers tune the frequency of initiation from a distance - helpful, but not required - while the basal factors are indispensable.

Elongation through chromatin, and three endings

Once initiated, elongation proceeds much as in prokaryotes: the polymerase reads the template and extends the pre-mRNA in the 5' to 3' direction. The eukaryotic obstacle is packaging - DNA is wound around histone octamers into nucleosomes, each spooling about 146 nucleotides. A complex called FACT (facilitates chromatin transcription) pulls histones aside as the polymerase approaches and replaces them behind it. Termination differs by polymerase: polymerase II runs 1,000-2,000 nucleotides past the gene's end before the extra tail is cleaved off during processing; polymerase I stops at a specific 18-nucleotide signal recognized by a termination protein; polymerase III stops at an RNA hairpin, echoing the rho-independent mechanism of bacteria.

Finishing school: cap and tail

A eukaryotic pre-mRNA is unfinished until processed. While it is still being synthesized, a 7-methylguanosine cap is attached to the 5' end: it shields the transcript from degradation and is recognized by the translation machinery to help ribosomes start. At the other end, an endonuclease cleaves the transcript just past an AAUAAA sequence and poly-A polymerase strings roughly 200 adenines onto the 3' end. This poly-A tail adds further protection and signals that the transcript is ready for export to the cytoplasm. The investment pays off in longevity: eukaryotic mRNAs survive for hours, while a typical E. coli mRNA is degraded within seconds.

Splicing out the interruptions

Eukaryotic genes are interleaved: exons (expressed sequences) encode protein, and introns (intervening sequences) interrupt them. All introns must be removed and the exons rejoined - splicing - before translation, and the surgery must be exact: err by a single nucleotide and the rejoined exons shift reading frame, producing a dysfunctional protein. The work is done by spliceosomes, complexes of proteins and small nuclear RNAs that recognize the intron's boundaries. Some genes carry more than 70 introns, each demanding its own removal. Because exons can be reconnected in different combinations (alternative splicing), one gene can supply several proteins.

Worked example: poison as a diagnostic

A researcher finds an uncharacterized gene and adds alpha-amanitin to the cells, watching transcript levels. Transcripts keep appearing even at high poison concentrations. What polymerase is at work? Polymerase I, which is insensitive - and the gene is therefore likely a ribosomal RNA gene, not a protein-coding one. Had transcription collapsed at the slightest trace of poison, polymerase II would be the reader and the gene a protein-coding candidate; a gene shutting down only at moderate-to-high levels would point to polymerase III, the tRNA and 5S rRNA specialist. One poison, three thresholds, a clean identification.

Worked example: the off-by-one splice

A spliceosome removes an intron but cuts one nucleotide too early, leaving a stray nucleotide at the start of the following exon. Predict the protein. Every codon after the error reads in a shifted frame, so the amino acid sequence past that point bears no relation to the intended protein - and translation likely halts early at a stop codon the shift happens to expose. The protein is junk. This is why spliceosomes operate with single-nucleotide precision, and why splicing errors are implicated in cancers and other diseases: a mutation at an intron boundary, or in the spliceosome's own RNAs, can quietly corrupt every protein the affected transcript was meant to produce.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, assuming eukaryotic RNA polymerase binds the promoter directly - transcription factors must assemble first. Second, mixing up the polymerases: I makes rRNA (minus 5S), II makes all protein-coding mRNA, III makes 5S rRNA, tRNA, and small nuclear RNA. Third, confusing the 5' cap with the poly-A tail - cap protects and recruits ribosomes; tail protects and flags export. Fourth, thinking introns are transcribed into protein - they are removed before translation. Fifth, forgetting that splicing must be nucleotide-perfect - a one-base slip frameshifts the exons. Sixth, expecting mRNA editing everywhere - guide-RNA editing is a trypanosome and mitochondrial special case, not the eukaryotic norm.

Key takeaways

Eukaryotic transcription happens in the nucleus, so transcripts must be processed, protected, and exported before translation. Three polymerases divide the work - I: rRNA (except 5S), II: all protein-coding pre-mRNA, III: 5S rRNA, tRNA, and small nuclear RNA - and alpha-amanitin distinguishes them by sensitivity (I insensitive, II extreme, III moderate). Promoters combine a TATA box around -30 with CAAT, GC-rich, and octamer elements; basal transcription factors (TFII series) build the preinitiation complex that recruits polymerase II. FACT moves histones aside as elongation threads through nucleosomes, and termination differs by polymerase. Processing adds a 5' methylguanosine cap and a roughly 200-adenine poly-A tail (mRNA now lasts hours, not seconds), and spliceosomes cut introns out with single-nucleotide precision - enabling alternative splicing, one gene, several proteins. In trypanosome mitochondria, guide RNAs even insert missing uracils - RNA editing as a possible echo of an RNA-driven world.

Flashcards

Flashcard

RNA polymerase I

Nucleolar polymerase making ribosomal RNA

Transcribes all rRNAs except 5S rRNA in the nucleolus; completely insensitive to alpha-amanitin.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

A newly discovered gene stops being transcribed when cells are treated with a low concentration of alpha-amanitin. Which polymerase was reading it?

Question 2 of 5

Why does the TATA box help transcription begin?

Question 3 of 5

What is the role of basal transcription factors like the TFII series?

Question 4 of 5

What happens if a spliceosome removes an intron but leaves one extra nucleotide attached to the following exon?

Question 5 of 5

How does the 5' cap and poly-A tail extend an mRNA's working life?

← Previous topicNext topic →