Biology › Section J · Evolution › Topic J.8

Determining evolutionary relationships

Looks can deceive: similar organisms may be unrelated, and close relatives can look nothing alike. Biologists sort traits into homologous and analogous, then build clades.

The problem of resemblance

A hippopotamus resembles a pig, yet DNA makes the whale its closest living relative. When biologists determine evolutionary relationships, the central problem is that similarity has two possible causes — shared ancestry or shared conditions — and only the first tells you who is related. So the first job is sorting an organism's traits into two piles: homologous, inherited from a common ancestor, and analogous, built separately by different lineages facing the same environment. Everything in a phylogenetic tree depends on getting that sort right.

Homologous structures

Homologous structures share an underlying design because of common ancestry, even when they do different jobs. A human arm, a bat wing, a whale flipper, and a cat's front leg all hide the same skeleton: one upper bone, two lower bones, a cluster of wrist bones, then digits. Complexity is the clincher. Two inventors independently designing a car with all the same parts in the same arrangement would be nearly impossible, but two people independently inventing a hammer is unsurprising. The more complex two structures' shared arrangement is, the more surely the overlap comes from a shared evolutionary past.

Analogous structures and convergence

Analogous structures perform the same job without sharing an evolutionary history. A honeybee's wing, a bird's wing, and a bat's wing all fly — but the bee's wing contains no bones at all and develops from entirely different embryonic material. This is convergent evolution: similar conditions push unrelated lineages toward similar solutions. Convergence is why appearance alone cannot build a tree. Two organisms may be close relatives yet look wildly different because one minor genetic change produced a major body difference, or be distant relatives yet look nearly identical because both adapted to the same environment.

Vestigial structures

Some homologous parts arrive nearly worn out. Vestigial structures are reduced remnants with little or no function: the hip bones buried inside a whale's body, the human tailbone, the wing stubs of flightless birds. They make perfect sense as inheritance — leftovers from ancestors in which those structures were useful, carried along as lineages changed their way of life. A vestigial structure is evidence of relationship precisely because it serves so little purpose now: descent explains why it is there at all.

Molecular evidence

The deepest comparison is in the DNA. All living things use DNA and almost exactly the same genetic code, and closely related species carry more similar sequences: humans and chimpanzees share about 98 to 99 percent of their DNA. Trees built from molecular data closely match trees built from anatomy and fossils. Early embryos agree too: fish, chick, and human embryos share tail-like structures and throat pouches, reflecting developmental genes inherited from a common ancestor. Molecules have traps, though. An insertion or deletion mutation can shift every base down a sequence, making two related codes look unrelated, and two distant species can randomly share many bases in the same positions. That is why biologists use morphology and molecules together — the coupled evidence is far stronger than either alone.

Worked example: Building a cladogram from traits

Four animals are scored for four traits: lamprey (vertebral column only), fish (vertebral column, hinged jaws), lizard (vertebral column, hinged jaws, amniotic egg), and human (all four: those three plus hair). 1. Identify the outgroup, the lineage that branched off first: the lamprey lacks every trait except the vertebral column, so the tree roots at it. 2. Order the traits by who shares them: vertebral column is shared by all, hinged jaws by all but the lamprey, the amniotic egg by lizard and human, hair by human alone. 3. Nest the branches by that order — each trait marks one branch point. 4. Apply maximum parsimony: in this tree each trait evolves just once, the fewest changes possible, and it reads lamprey, then fish, then lizard, then human going outward. 5. Read off the clades: every branch point, taken with everything above it, defines a group that descended from one ancestor.

Worked example: Placing a species by its DNA

A newly found rodent is compared with three known species: its DNA is 96 percent similar to species A, 92 percent to species B, and 81 percent to species C. 1. Start from the highest match — A at 96 percent — as the closest relative. 2. Order the rest by falling similarity: B next, C most distant, so the branches run outward in that order. 3. Treat the distant figure cautiously: at 81 percent, some shared bases may be random matches rather than kinship. 4. Confirm with anatomy — a tooth or skull feature checked against the molecular result — before concluding, because coupled evidence is the standard. 5. Conclusion: the rodent sits nearest A, with B the next relative and C the farthest.

Cladistics and clades

Once homologous traits are sorted, scientists organise them with cladistics: a system that sorts organisms into clades — an ancestor plus all of its descendants, also called monophyletic groups. Lizards, rabbits, and humans all descend from an ancestor that had an amniotic egg, so together they form the clade Amniota; add frogs, fish, and lampreys and you get the larger clade Vertebrata. A group that leaves out some descendants is not a clade. To choose among possible trees, biologists apply maximum parsimony: the best hypothesis is the one that needs the fewest evolutionary events to explain the evidence.

Shared ancestral and derived characters

Within a clade, characters come in two relative kinds. A shared ancestral character is one the whole clade inherited from deep in its past — within Amniota, the amniotic egg itself, present in every member. A shared derived character is a newer modification shared only by some members — within Amniota, hair belongs to the mammal branch. Derived characters mark the branch points and so do the real work of building the tree. The terms are relative: the amniotic egg is ancestral inside Amniota but derived when compared against animals outside it. The lesson: ask 'derived compared with what?' before labelling any trait.

Why phylogeny matters

Tree-building is not bookkeeping — it pays its way. Researchers in China identified a DNA marker — a known chromosome location — shared by legume-family (Fabaceae) species with antifungal properties. When another legume, the tree Dalbergia sissoo, turned out to carry the same marker, phylogeny predicted it was worth testing, and it proved to have antifungal activity. Know a species' relatives and you know where to look for the same useful chemistry.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, same function does not mean homology — the bee's wing flies like a bat's but is analogous, so always ask about structure and origin, not just the job. Second, clades must be complete: a group that omits some descendants of its ancestor is not a clade, however natural it looks. Third, do not call a trait derived or ancestral in the abstract — the label flips with the comparison group. Fourth, molecular data is not automatically superior; insertions, deletions, and random matches can mislead, so strong conclusions lean on molecules and morphology together.

Key takeaways

Homologous structures share design through common ancestry; analogous structures share only function, built separately by convergence; vestigial structures are inherited leftovers. Embryology and DNA add matching evidence, with human and chimpanzee genomes about 98 to 99 percent identical. Cladistics sorts organisms into clades — a single ancestor plus all its descendants — using shared derived characters, which mark branch points, while shared ancestral characters reach deeper than the clade in question; maximum parsimony picks the tree with the fewest evolutionary events. And the effort matters: phylogeny guides the search for new medicines among the relatives of known useful species.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Homologous structures

Same underlying design from a common ancestor

Arm, bat wing, whale flipper: one bone, two bones, wrist, digits.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

A honeybee's wing and a bat's wing both serve for flight. The bee's wing has no bones and a different embryonic origin. What are these two wings?

Question 2 of 5

Which of these groups is a clade?

Question 3 of 5

Inside the clade Amniota, what kind of character is hair?

Question 4 of 5

Humans and chimpanzees share about 98 to 99 percent of their DNA. What does this support?

Question 5 of 5

Researchers found a DNA marker in antifungal plants of the legume family and then found the same marker in another legume species. Why was this useful?

← Previous topicNext topic →