Biology › Section S · Ecosystems and conservation › Topic S.6
Preserving biodiversity
Knowing why species are disappearing is only half the job. Conservation biologists also have to find out what exists, judge how close each species is to the edge, and then protect, connect and restore the places where life persists, with laws, reserves and, as a last resort, captive breeding.
From diagnosis to treatment
Conservation works at several scales at once. Scientists catalogue species and rank their risk so effort goes where it is most needed. Laws limit hunting, trade and habitat destruction. Protected areas shelter whole ecosystems, not one species at a time. Restoration repairs damaged habitats, and captive breeding and seed banks are a safety net for species that would otherwise vanish. None succeeds alone, and all depend on people valuing what is being saved.
Measuring biodiversity with DNA
You cannot protect what you have not identified. DNA barcoding identifies species from a short, standard stretch of DNA that varies between species but little within one. Animals are usually barcoded with part of the mitochondrial gene for cytochrome c oxidase subunit I (COI); plants use chloroplast genes such as rbcL and matK, because their mitochondrial DNA changes too slowly. Barcoding can name a specimen from a scrap of tissue or a larva, and it uncovers cryptic species that look identical. A tropical butterfly long counted as one species, Astraptes fulgerator, turned out to be at least ten.
The IUCN Red List
The IUCN Red List ranks species by extinction risk. Its categories, from worst to least, are Extinct (EX), Extinct in the Wild (EW, surviving only in captivity or cultivation), Critically Endangered (CR), Endangered (EN), Vulnerable (VU), Near Threatened (NT) and Least Concern (LC); Data Deficient (DD) means too little is known to judge. Only CR, EN and VU count as threatened. A species is assessed against five criteria, A to E, and placed in the highest category it meets. For example, criterion D uses population size alone: fewer than 50 mature individuals is CR, fewer than 250 is EN and fewer than 1,000 is VU.
Worked example: assigning a category
Criterion A2 covers a decline over 10 years or three generations, whichever is longer, whose causes may not have ceased, be understood or be reversible: at least 80 percent is CR, 50 percent EN, 30 percent VU. Take two wide-ranging species (simplified cases). 1. Species X: 180 mature individuals, numbers stable. No decline, so A does not apply; under D, 180 is below 250 but not below 50, so EN. 2. Species Y: fell from 12,000 to 1,800 over three generations. Decline: (12,000 − 1,800) ÷ 12,000 = 85 percent, so A2 gives CR. 3. Under D, 1,800 exceeds 1,000, so D gives nothing. 4. Highest category met: Y is CR.
Laws and treaties
CITES, a global treaty in force since 1975, controls cross-border trade in tens of thousands of listed species: those on its Appendix I may generally not be traded commercially at all. The US Endangered Species Act of 1973 protects species listed as endangered or threatened, and their critical habitat, and requires recovery plans; the bald eagle, helped also by the DDT ban, was delisted in 2007. The 1918 Migratory Bird Treaty Act, passed to carry out a treaty covering the US and Canada and later extended to Mexico, Japan and Russia, protects migratory birds. In 2022 nearly 200 nations adopted a global "30 by 30" target: conserving 30 percent of land and sea by 2030.
Protected areas and reserve design
By the mid-2020s, protected areas covered roughly a sixth of Earth's land and under a tenth of the ocean, but many were chosen because the land was cheap, not because it was rich in species. Design draws on island biogeography, developed by Robert MacArthur and E. O. Wilson in 1967: larger islands hold more species because their populations go extinct less often, and nearer islands gain more colonists. A reserve is an island of habitat in a sea of farmland. Larger reserves are generally better, compact shapes have less edge, buffer zones soften the boundary, and corridors of habitat let individuals and their genes move between reserves.
Worked example: core habitat
Edge effects (more light, wind, predators and invasive plants) reach, say, 0.5 km into a reserve. Compare three designs of 16 km² each. 1. One square, 4 km × 4 km: the core is (4 − 2 × 0.5) × (4 − 2 × 0.5) = 3 × 3 = 9 km², or 56 percent. 2. Four squares of 2 km × 2 km: each core is 1 × 1 = 1 km², so 4 km² in total, 25 percent. 3. One strip, 1 km × 16 km: the core width is 1 − 2 × 0.5 = 0, so no core at all. 4. Conclusion: for species needing interior habitat, one compact reserve beats fragments or strips of the same area.
Limits of reserves
Reserves face real problems. Political and economic pressure tends to make them smaller, not larger. Protection means little without enforcement, and poaching and illegal logging persist in many underfunded parks. Climate change will move suitable conditions out of fixed boundaries, so planners now favour networks linked by corridors. Some reserves have forced Indigenous and local people off their ancestral land, and conservation that works with local communities, sharing benefits such as tourism income, is usually fairer and more lasting. Finally, reserves cannot save biodiversity if the land and sea around them are managed unsustainably.
Restoring ecosystems
Restoration can rebuild degraded ecosystems, though it cannot revive an extinct species. Grey wolves were reintroduced to Yellowstone National Park in 1995, about 70 years after the last pack was killed. Wolves are widely treated there as a keystone species, one whose effect on its community is far larger than its numbers suggest: by hunting elk and changing where they graze, they are linked to the recovery of streamside willows, the return of beavers, and more food for scavengers, though ecologists still debate how strong these effects are. Dam removals, such as two on Washington's Elwha River between 2011 and 2014, have reopened rivers to salmon.
Captive breeding: a last resort
Zoos, aquaria and botanic gardens can breed species that cannot survive in the wild for now. The California condor fell so low that every remaining wild bird was captured by 1987, only 27 birds in all; captive breeding and releases have since raised the population to several hundred, many flying free. Such programmes are costly, protect few species, and start from a small gene pool, so managers pair animals to limit inbreeding. Released animals may lack learned skills such as avoiding predators. Zoos also aim to educate visitors, but studies of their effect on behaviour give mixed results.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, calling every Red List species threatened: only CR, EN and VU count, while NT and LC do not. Second, confusing IUCN categories with the separate legal listings of the US Endangered Species Act. Third, ranking a species by one criterion only: it takes the highest category met under any criterion. Fourth, judging a reserve by total area alone: shape, edges and connections decide how much core habitat it has. Fifth, assuming restoration can undo extinction. Sixth, treating captive breeding as the main solution: it is a costly safety net for a few species.
Key takeaways
DNA barcoding, using COI in animals and chloroplast genes in plants, identifies species and reveals cryptic ones. The IUCN Red List ranks risk from Extinct to Least Concern; CR, EN and VU are the threatened categories, assigned by criteria A to E. CITES controls international trade; the US Endangered Species Act protects listed species and their habitat. Island biogeography guides reserve design: large, compact, buffered and connected reserves hold the most core habitat, but need enforcement and local support. Restoration can rebuild ecosystems, while captive breeding saves a few species on the brink.
Flashcards
Flashcard
Identifying species from a short, standard DNA sequence
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
A species has 40 mature individuals, a stable population and a large range. Under IUCN criterion D, which category does it qualify for?
Question 2 of 5
Which three IUCN Red List categories together make up the threatened species?
Question 3 of 5
A square reserve measures 6 km by 6 km, and edge effects reach 1 km in from every side. How much core habitat does it have?
Question 4 of 5
What is the main purpose of a wildlife corridor between two reserves?
Question 5 of 5
Ecologists describe Yellowstone's wolves as a keystone species. What does that mean?
